WEBVTT

00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:08.356
♪ [music] ♪

00:00:08.356 --> 00:00:12.545
NARRATOR: This video essay will examine 
the effects of television toy commercials

00:00:12.545 --> 00:00:16.445
on our society's perception 
of gender-appropriate toys.

00:00:16.445 --> 00:00:23.592
At a young age, society tells us that we fit
into one of two categories: boy or girl.

00:00:23.592 --> 00:00:27.814
Playing with children's toys is one of the
ways in which we learn our gender roles.

00:00:27.814 --> 00:00:31.049
Media, specifically toy 
television commercials,

00:00:31.049 --> 00:00:33.407
help relay the message to society

00:00:33.407 --> 00:00:36.917
that there are specific toys
for each gender.

00:00:36.917 --> 00:00:41.447
Before we begin, let's take a look at 
how and why gender is constructed.

00:00:41.447 --> 00:00:44.496
By the age of 10, children 
have formed an understanding

00:00:44.496 --> 00:00:47.222
of the personality traits
that belong to each gender

00:00:47.222 --> 00:00:49.360
Many people believe 
that gender construction

00:00:49.360 --> 00:00:52.787
is a blend of nature and nurture.

00:00:52.787 --> 00:00:55.489
It takes effort to process
a lot of information.

00:00:55.489 --> 00:00:56.629
To reduce this effort,

00:00:56.629 --> 00:01:00.456
our minds stereotype and categorize 
information into smaller units.

00:01:00.456 --> 00:01:03.683
Therefore, categorizing things
as being male or female

00:01:03.683 --> 00:01:06.487
makes it easier for us
to process information.

00:01:06.487 --> 00:01:09.029
Once they understand 
the basic concepts of gender,

00:01:09.029 --> 00:01:14.443
children remain very rigid in their ideas of 
gendered behaviors, occupations, and toys.

00:01:14.443 --> 00:01:19.217
Studies have found that male characters
tend to dominate children's commercials.

00:01:19.217 --> 00:01:21.055
COMMERCIAL: Thunderbirds are go!

00:01:21.055 --> 00:01:24.788
We've located the distress call.
We must get there fast!

00:01:25.268 --> 00:01:29.731
NARRATOR: Many of them have also found 
that gender portrayals in advertising are often

00:01:29.731 --> 00:01:33.215
negatively stereotyped in ways 
that are restrictive and demeaning.

00:01:33.215 --> 00:01:35.018
COMMERCIAL: Baby Alive!

00:01:35.018 --> 00:01:36.935
My baby's first cold!

00:01:36.935 --> 00:01:38.451
Let's use the bear thermometer.

00:01:38.451 --> 00:01:39.631
Good girl!

00:01:39.631 --> 00:01:42.282
I can give you medicine
and change your wet diaper.

00:01:42.282 --> 00:01:44.149
You're better now, Baby!

00:01:44.149 --> 00:01:47.911
NARRATOR: Segregating toys in this way
can be detrimental to children

00:01:47.911 --> 00:01:50.641
who are still forming their identities.

00:01:50.641 --> 00:01:54.997
Other studies have found that female toys 
often encourage girls to focus on their looks,

00:01:54.997 --> 00:01:57.711
whereas male toys encourage
power and strength.

00:01:57.711 --> 00:02:00.598
COMMERCIAL: A glitter blow-dryer? 
That's so Barbie!

00:02:00.598 --> 00:02:05.406
♪ Look at that glitter. 
Change the color, Change the style ♪

00:02:05.406 --> 00:02:07.775
COMMERCIAL: The Transformers war is here!

00:02:07.775 --> 00:02:11.455
And both sides can change 
from vehicle to blaster in an instant.

00:02:11.455 --> 00:02:15.334
NARRATOR: Finally, 
commercials featuring females

00:02:15.334 --> 00:02:17.426
are usually for dolls and accessories,

00:02:17.426 --> 00:02:19.459
whereas commercials featuring males

00:02:19.459 --> 00:02:22.056
are often for building toys
and action figures.

00:02:22.056 --> 00:02:23.693
COMMERCIAL: It's a great big jet!

00:02:23.693 --> 00:02:27.423
♪ In the sky! Walk the runway! 
Yeah, we rock it! ♪

00:02:27.423 --> 00:02:29.543
COMMERCIAL: Want something your way?

00:02:29.543 --> 00:02:30.358
You build it!

00:02:30.358 --> 00:02:32.872
Introducing U-Build Battleship.

00:02:32.872 --> 00:02:35.271
NARRATOR: 
Boys are encouraged to play with cars,

00:02:35.271 --> 00:02:38.197
trucks, building toys, and science toys.

00:02:38.197 --> 00:02:40.828
Generally the toys promote 
strength and power.

00:02:40.828 --> 00:02:44.612
COMMERCIAL: One system, you can build
up and customize your heavy-duty truck

00:02:44.612 --> 00:02:48.163
with tons of parts and drop 
the motor into any Mod Machine.

00:02:48.163 --> 00:02:50.827
Tonka Mod Machines,
each sold separately.

00:02:50.827 --> 00:02:52.117
That's Tonka tough.

00:02:52.117 --> 00:02:55.928
NARRATOR: Girls are encouraged to play
with toys such as kitchen sets, and dolls

00:02:55.928 --> 00:02:58.064
that promote domestic
and nurturing behavior.

00:02:58.064 --> 00:03:01.424
COMMERCIAL: Only you can help 
shy little Furberries come out and play!

00:03:01.424 --> 00:03:04.764
COMMERCIAL: It's the cake bakery!
The easy way to make designer cakes!

00:03:04.764 --> 00:03:06.954
Bake your cake in the 
microwave in 30 seconds!

00:03:06.954 --> 00:03:09.663
NARRATOR: Let's take a look 
at some older toy commercials

00:03:09.663 --> 00:03:11.064
to see how this all began.

00:03:11.064 --> 00:03:13.653
Historically, toy commercials have been
much more rigid

00:03:13.653 --> 00:03:16.872
in depicting what type of toys 
boys and girls should play with.

00:03:16.872 --> 00:03:19.191
Here are some older 
commercials for boys' toys.

00:03:19.191 --> 00:03:22.249
Notice the absence of 
a female model or voiceover,

00:03:22.249 --> 00:03:24.162
the nature of the toys being advertised,

00:03:24.162 --> 00:03:26.951
and the qualities they are 
suggesting boys should have.

00:03:26.951 --> 00:03:30.744
COMMERCIAL: This opens up 
the wild action world of Port Apache,

00:03:30.744 --> 00:03:33.911
with Indians, cavalrymen, 
shell-shooting cannons.

00:03:33.911 --> 00:03:37.463
COMMERCIAL: The most action 
you can get, from Mattel.

00:03:37.463 --> 00:03:41.241
NARRATOR: Now let's take a look 
at some girl commercials from the past.

00:03:41.241 --> 00:03:44.219
Notice how they promote 
appearance and domesticity.

00:03:44.219 --> 00:03:49.378
COMMERCIAL: Yes, with Suzy Homemaker,
you can entertain, wash dishes, clean house,

00:03:49.378 --> 00:03:55.194
launder, iron, bake all this, 
and always look lovely.

00:03:55.194 --> 00:03:58.758
COMMERCIAL: She keeps herself 
pretty by using Sugar Plum.

00:03:58.758 --> 00:04:02.398
NARRATOR: Luckily, there have been 
many positive changes in toy commercials

00:04:02.398 --> 00:04:04.135
in the past 50 years or so.

00:04:04.135 --> 00:04:07.852
Recently, there have been more depictions 
of boys and girls playing with toys

00:04:07.852 --> 00:04:10.471
that are typically more geared 
toward the other gender.

00:04:10.471 --> 00:04:16.061
COMMERCIAL: ♪ So much fun, you'll want
to squeal, Little Live Pets, little mice. ♪

00:04:16.061 --> 00:04:20.129
NARRATOR: There are also more depictions 
of boys and girls playing with toys together

00:04:20.129 --> 00:04:22.257
to indicate that the toy is gender-neutral.

00:04:22.257 --> 00:04:28.262
COMMERCIAL: Expressive and unexpected.
Stuart is up, down, tumbling all around.

00:04:28.262 --> 00:04:29.170
Minions!

00:04:29.170 --> 00:04:32.968
NARRATOR: Some commercials have 
even resorted to not using a model at all

00:04:32.968 --> 00:04:36.856
and instead using hands to indicate 
that a toy is gender-neutral.

00:04:36.856 --> 00:04:39.894
COMMERCIAL: Build the shuttle,

00:04:39.894 --> 00:04:43.587
place the new satellite,
and prepare for liftoff.

00:04:43.587 --> 00:04:46.691
NARRATOR: Still not convinced 
that toy commercials have an impact

00:04:46.691 --> 00:04:49.829
on society's perception of 
gender-appropriate toys?

00:04:49.829 --> 00:04:51.966
Studies have indicated 
that children may view

00:04:51.966 --> 00:04:54.375
more than 40,000 
advertisements a year.

00:04:54.375 --> 00:04:56.548
That means that they are 
potentially watching

00:04:56.548 --> 00:04:59.958
tens of thousands of
gendered advertisements.

00:04:59.958 --> 00:05:03.192
There's research that indicates 
that advertisements do indeed

00:05:03.192 --> 00:05:05.622
affect children's attitudes 
toward the brand.

00:05:05.622 --> 00:05:08.146
According to the American 
Psychological Association,

00:05:08.146 --> 00:05:13.112
50% of children remember a toy
advertisement a week after seeing it.

00:05:13.112 --> 00:05:17.084
Furthermore, it is thought that children
may focus more on the advertisements

00:05:17.084 --> 00:05:19.436
than on the television show itself.

00:05:19.436 --> 00:05:22.096
So why should we be concerned?

00:05:22.096 --> 00:05:26.816
Aside from the fact that it is dangerous
to restrict children to one rigid identity,

00:05:26.816 --> 00:05:29.408
research has also speculated 
that toy-gendering

00:05:29.408 --> 00:05:34.182
could affect men and women's aptitudes
and skills for different professions as adults.

00:05:34.182 --> 00:05:37.382
The toys that boys play with 
encourage a freedom of imagination

00:05:37.382 --> 00:05:41.308
and teach spatial skills that are 
often necessary for scientific careers.

00:05:41.308 --> 00:05:44.770
On the other hand, girl toys
focus more on nurturing skills,

00:05:44.770 --> 00:05:47.005
domestic skills, and appearance.

00:05:47.005 --> 00:05:48.796
Many theorize that this is one reason

00:05:48.796 --> 00:05:51.444
why there are more men in 
scientific fields than women.

00:05:53.639 --> 00:05:57.693
While there has been some progress with
de-gendering television toy commercials,

00:05:57.693 --> 00:05:59.614
we still have a long way to go.

00:05:59.614 --> 00:06:02.440
Commercials continue 
to be gender-restrictive;

00:06:02.440 --> 00:06:04.953
the gendering is simply done 
in a more modern way,

00:06:04.953 --> 00:06:08.286
giving the illusion that things have 
changed when they really haven't.

00:06:08.286 --> 00:06:11.064
Take a look at these two Barbie 
commercials, for example.

00:06:11.064 --> 00:06:15.345
The first is from 1959,
and the second is from 2015.

00:06:15.345 --> 00:06:20.010
♪ Purse and hats and gloves and more 
and all the gadgets gals adore ♪

00:06:20.010 --> 00:06:24.259
COMMERCIAL: It's for you Moschino Barbie!

00:06:24.259 --> 00:06:27.486
Moschino Barbie doll, 
fabulosity totally included.

00:06:27.486 --> 00:06:31.654
NARRATOR: Some may think that having
a boy in a Barbie commercial is progress.

00:06:31.654 --> 00:06:35.638
However, his mannerisms are still very
feminine by our society's standards,

00:06:35.638 --> 00:06:38.223
indicating that Barbies 
are indeed feminine toys.

00:06:38.223 --> 00:06:42.618
In this way, it's not much better than 
the Barbie commercial from the '50s.

00:06:42.618 --> 00:06:46.132
We must keep in mind that the 
advertisements are not entirely at fault

00:06:46.132 --> 00:06:49.286
because gender is constructed 
by our society.

00:06:49.286 --> 00:06:53.563
Advertisements simply perpetuate 
gender stereotypes by attempting to appeal

00:06:53.563 --> 00:06:56.315
to consumers' socially influenced desires.

00:06:56.315 --> 00:06:59.694
In other words, society 
creates gender stereotypes,

NOTE Paragraph

00:06:59.694 --> 00:07:01.899
and advertisements perpetuate them.

00:07:01.899 --> 00:07:06.241
In order to make a change, we must figure
out why we haven't made more progress.

00:07:06.241 --> 00:07:09.930
Is it society that is resisting?
Or are the toy companies?

00:07:09.930 --> 00:07:10.880
Or is it both?

00:07:10.880 --> 00:07:14.576
Whatever the cause, 
we must not be discouraged.

00:07:14.576 --> 00:07:20.761
Things are improving slowly, 
but there's still much work to be done.

00:07:20.761 --> 00:07:51.682
♪ [slow jazzy music plays during credits] ♪