1
00:00:02,452 --> 00:00:04,682
Hi guys.

2
00:00:04,682 --> 00:00:05,872
(sigh)

3
00:00:05,872 --> 00:00:10,462
This is a response to my video "Les 
consequences du Francais en Haiti"

4
00:00:10,462 --> 00:00:14,562
which I did it in French talking about the
consequences of French in Haiti.

5
00:00:15,231 --> 00:00:19,743
I published this in April and I have the 
link to it up here and down there

6
00:00:19,743 --> 00:00:21,633
in my description box.

7
00:00:21,633 --> 00:00:25,633
I got some really strong reactions to 
that post and it seems like I really hit a

8
00:00:25,633 --> 00:00:32,503
nerve for some people so I'm dedicating
this week's message to response and debunk

9
00:00:32,503 --> 00:00:35,603
the prevalent counter arguments I received

10
00:00:35,603 --> 00:00:38,173
Here are the main points I made 
in that video:

11
00:00:38,173 --> 00:00:42,173
"French hinders comunication in 
self-expression among Haitians

12
00:00:42,173 --> 00:00:46,173
It divides the Haitian population and
fosters an inferiority complex for the

13
00:00:46,173 --> 00:00:48,499
majority of the population.

14
00:00:48,499 --> 00:00:54,039
Haitions sustitute someone's ability to 
muster a few words in French for wisdom or

15
00:00:54,039 --> 00:01:00,019
intelligence.Haitions fail to realize that
what they are seeing is more important

16
00:01:00,019 --> 00:01:02,745
than the language they used to say in.

17
00:01:02,745 --> 00:01:06,745
And lastly, Haitians by and large cannot 
speak French.

18
00:01:06,745 --> 00:01:11,515
These are fairly common and well-known
issues I presented to support my proposal

19
00:01:11,515 --> 00:01:15,515
of eliminating French as one of the two
official languages of Haiti.

20
00:01:15,515 --> 00:01:19,515
But many didn't want to hear it and here 
are some of the responses that I want to

21
00:01:19,515 --> 00:01:20,289
address.

22
00:01:20,289 --> 00:01:24,289
The first one is that the problem of Haiti
is one of education not of language.

23
00:01:24,289 --> 00:01:26,729
Here is my issue with that point.

24
00:01:26,729 --> 00:01:30,729
Everyone knows that the state of education
in Haiti is dire, that has always been the

25
00:01:30,729 --> 00:01:34,609
case in Haiti but have you stopped to 
think that language is the basis of

26
00:01:34,609 --> 00:01:38,609
learning and education, so if you are 
attempting to teach in a language that is

27
00:01:38,609 --> 00:01:42,609
cumbersome, unnatural and foreign to kids
then you keep them at a disadvantage.

28
00:01:42,609 --> 00:01:46,609
The medium that allows you to communicate
the knowledge you are attempting to pass

29
00:01:46,609 --> 00:01:48,479
on is extremely relevant.

30
00:01:48,479 --> 00:01:52,289
My experience as a student in Haiti was
that many of my teachers were not fluent

31
00:01:52,289 --> 00:01:53,630
in French, far from.

32
00:01:53,630 --> 00:01:58,360
So yes, there is an educational crisis in
Haiti and this isn't breaking news to

33
00:01:58,360 --> 00:02:03,030
anyone. But the fact that we are insisting
on sticking to French as the academic

34
00:02:03,030 --> 00:02:04,806
language is to our own detriment.

35
00:02:04,806 --> 00:02:10,166
It is pedagogically impractical and 
frankly at this point pretty irresponsible

36
00:02:10,166 --> 00:02:14,166
The other thing people say that kind of 
goes along with the lack of education

37
00:02:14,166 --> 00:02:18,166
argument is that well, we shouldn't just 
limit our kids to Creole we should teach

38
00:02:18,166 --> 00:02:22,166
them French, Spanish, German, Italian, 
everything.

39
00:02:22,170 --> 00:02:26,620
Ok, well, do I want our kids to learn 
multiple languages?

40
00:02:26,620 --> 00:02:28,160
Of course.

41
00:02:28,160 --> 00:02:32,160
I would like every little Haitian out 
there to know as many languages as the

42
00:02:32,160 --> 00:02:36,640
human brain can retain and my argument has
never been to eradicate French from

43
00:02:36,640 --> 00:02:41,710
Haitian schools but rather to repeal its
status as an official language of the

44
00:02:41,710 --> 00:02:46,820
republic of Haiti and instead prioritize 
Creole which is the language that every

45
00:02:46,820 --> 00:02:48,180
last Haitian speaks.

46
00:02:48,180 --> 00:02:50,700
Luxembourg has 3 official languages.

47
00:02:50,700 --> 00:02:54,700
One of them I'm sure most of people have 
never heard of, it's called Luxembourgish

48
00:02:54,700 --> 00:02:58,700
and it is the language that is indigenous
to its people, the language of the heart

49
00:02:58,700 --> 00:03:00,630
for them so to speak.

50
00:03:00,916 --> 00:03:04,916
Even though, not many people outside of 
Luxembourg use it, that is the language

51
00:03:04,916 --> 00:03:09,604
that kids are taught in the first year of 
primary school before switching to German

52
00:03:09,604 --> 00:03:11,124
and then French.

53
00:03:11,346 --> 00:03:15,346
And proficiency and all three of their
official languages is required for

54
00:03:15,346 --> 00:03:17,204
graduation from secondary school.

55
00:03:17,204 --> 00:03:19,854
Now as you can see they are somehow able 
to pull off a

56
00:03:19,854 --> 00:03:23,854
trilingual educational system to go along
with the fact that they have 3 offical

57
00:03:23,854 --> 00:03:28,483
languages meaning their important 
legislature, and official national affairs

58
00:03:28,483 --> 00:03:31,453
are recorded and reported steadily in all
3 of these languages,

59
00:03:31,453 --> 00:03:33,347
even the one that we've never heard of.

60
00:03:33,347 --> 00:03:35,357
What's the point of this little sidebar?

61
00:03:35,357 --> 00:03:37,987
Well, it isn't a sidebar at all.

62
00:03:37,987 --> 00:03:41,987
It is to answer to the people who would
rather say: let's just teach our Haitian

63
00:03:41,987 --> 00:03:45,987
kids every language on the planet instead 
of focusing on teaching them in their

64
00:03:45,987 --> 00:03:48,037
primary language, Creole.

65
00:03:48,037 --> 00:03:54,057
A language that is said to be official in
our country yet all the important business

66
00:03:54,057 --> 00:03:58,057
political, professional and administrative
dealings are not recorded or reported

67
00:03:58,057 --> 00:03:59,037
in Creole.

68
00:03:59,037 --> 00:04:03,037
Over the years, when nationally elected
officials address the population,

69
00:04:03,037 --> 00:04:07,037
they deliver speeches in French and all 
while everyone knows that Creole

70
00:04:07,037 --> 00:04:08,884
is the language.

71
00:04:08,884 --> 00:04:13,954
Creole is constitutionally one of our 
official languages but that's only

72
00:04:13,954 --> 00:04:17,954
"a L'oral" like people say, meaning it's 
only something we say.

73
00:04:18,018 --> 00:04:21,098
Have we even tried to apply it in that
capacity?

74
00:04:21,098 --> 00:04:27,108
Have we even tried before we start crying
how it is unsustainable as a global means

75
00:04:27,108 --> 00:04:29,248
of communication for our children?

76
00:04:29,248 --> 00:04:33,538
What kills me is that these people 
objecting so passionately against the

77
00:04:33,538 --> 00:04:38,822
removal of French are the first to boast 
that we defeated French in 1804

78
00:04:38,822 --> 00:04:42,822
and that's the one thing from which they
derive Haitian pride, yet they don't

79
00:04:42,822 --> 00:04:45,799
realize that they are perpetuating 
oppression,

80
00:04:45,799 --> 00:04:51,049
holding stubbornly onto the language and 
the ways of the French at the expense of

81
00:04:51,049 --> 00:04:52,169
their own culture.

82
00:04:52,169 --> 00:04:56,169
For those of you telling me that back in
the days, you and your friends used to

83
00:04:56,169 --> 00:05:00,069
speak French, that's like me say every 
Haitian speaks English because my friends

84
00:05:00,069 --> 00:05:00,802
and I speak it.

85
00:05:00,802 --> 00:05:02,572
That doesn't mean anything.

86
00:05:02,572 --> 00:05:06,572
If you look at the data, education has 
always been a privilege reserved for the

87
00:05:06,572 --> 00:05:10,572
very few in Haiti and only the educated
can manage to speak a little French in

88
00:05:10,572 --> 00:05:11,522
Haiti ergo.

89
00:05:11,522 --> 00:05:15,522
Certain people's experiences back in the 
day when things were a little bit better

90
00:05:15,522 --> 00:05:18,972
for some doesn't demonstrate that at some
point French worked in Haiti.

91
00:05:18,972 --> 00:05:20,878
It never did and never will.

92
00:05:20,878 --> 00:05:26,058
Now, the other argument I got quite a bit 
is that we can't get rid of French

93
00:05:26,058 --> 00:05:30,058
because we need something to keep us 
connected to the rest of the world and

94
00:05:30,058 --> 00:05:33,788
people were also saying that having a 
Creole take-over

95
00:05:33,788 --> 00:05:37,448
now would set us back because we would 
have to start from scratch

96
00:05:37,448 --> 00:05:40,138
since Creole is such an unformulated
language.

97
00:05:40,715 --> 00:05:45,339
Ok, first of all, I hate to break it to 
you but the world has left Haiti behind

98
00:05:45,339 --> 00:05:49,957
a long time ago, and it's not just because
our people don't speak French,

99
00:05:49,957 --> 00:05:53,957
it's because we have not invested or
educated our people.

100
00:05:53,957 --> 00:05:57,957
Speaking French is not what's going to get
connected or keep us connected to the

101
00:05:57,957 --> 00:06:01,957
world because we don't need French to
facilitate international exchanges

102
00:06:01,957 --> 00:06:05,957
and to implement French as a language of
the Haitian people would require the same

103
00:06:05,957 --> 00:06:09,957
effort as to implement any other language
outside of Creole.

104
00:06:09,957 --> 00:06:11,847
With Creole we have an advantage,

105
00:06:11,847 --> 00:06:14,288
that's our mother tongue, we already 
speak it.

106
00:06:14,288 --> 00:06:16,419
We have to make the distinction:

107
00:06:16,419 --> 00:06:20,419
To teach French is not the same as 
educating our people.

108
00:06:20,419 --> 00:06:24,649
Here in the USA, everyone speaks the same
language, yet you will see that an

109
00:06:24,649 --> 00:06:28,649
uneducated person cannot articulate or
express themselves.

110
00:06:28,649 --> 00:06:32,649
The reason why our Creole-speaking masses
sound uneducated oftentimes

111
00:06:32,649 --> 00:06:37,244
is because they are uneducated,not because
they are speaking Creole.

112
00:06:37,244 --> 00:06:42,484
However, French can make a smart and 
educated Haitian sound stupid

113
00:06:42,484 --> 00:06:46,484
And a stupid Haitian who can remember 
their French vocab and grammar rules is

114
00:06:46,484 --> 00:06:52,276
oftentimes reveal and considered smart,no
matter how dimwitted they might be.

115
00:06:52,276 --> 00:06:54,834
There is something really wrong with this
picture.

116
00:06:54,834 --> 00:07:00,067
I was lucky enough to listen to Maurice
Sixto at a young age and discovered how

117
00:07:00,067 --> 00:07:05,767
he was able to claim such profound, 
culturally relevant,poetic and educational

118
00:07:05,767 --> 00:07:07,257
stories in Creole.

119
00:07:07,834 --> 00:07:11,834
He was well spoken and most importantly
Haitians could understand and truly

120
00:07:11,834 --> 00:07:15,834
connect with the deeper meaning of what
he was sharing.

121
00:07:15,834 --> 00:07:20,245
Back then, he wielded the Creole language,
which some attempt to devoid of all

122
00:07:20,245 --> 00:07:24,306
virtues, brilliantly, because he was 
educated.

123
00:07:24,306 --> 00:07:29,326
He was able to use his imagination and
talent to enrich the language.

124
00:07:29,326 --> 00:07:33,326
Had there been more of an encouragement
for self-expression in Creole and Haiti

125
00:07:33,326 --> 00:07:37,456
and respect for the language, no doubt, it
would be at a more refined stage today.

126
00:07:37,456 --> 00:07:42,576
That's what happened when something is 
yours, when you care about something,

127
00:07:42,576 --> 00:07:44,097
you work at it.

128
00:07:44,097 --> 00:07:45,777
That's your responsibility.

129
00:07:45,777 --> 00:07:49,777
You don't just sit and say it will never 
work because the languages that are so

130
00:07:49,777 --> 00:07:53,097
sophisticated today weren't always that
way;

131
00:07:53,097 --> 00:07:56,477
people developed them, people made them
great.

132
00:07:56,477 --> 00:08:00,397
They didn't just sit and say let's adopt
another language that's already developed

133
00:08:00,397 --> 00:08:02,836
to help us assimilate and sound educated.

134
00:08:02,836 --> 00:08:06,836
That being said, I appreciate that fact 
that we need to equip our children with

135
00:08:06,836 --> 00:08:09,126
the tools to compete on a global level

136
00:08:09,126 --> 00:08:10,926
and that includes language skills

137
00:08:10,926 --> 00:08:14,616
but that doesn't preclude us from 
strengthening and valuing our own language

138
00:08:14,616 --> 00:08:18,616
in our own country and taking advantage of
it to educate our children.

139
00:08:18,616 --> 00:08:22,616
Keeping that in mind, if I had to choose 
the second mandatory language for the

140
00:08:22,616 --> 00:08:26,616
education in Haiti, for our kids to know 
inside and out, it would definitely not

141
00:08:26,616 --> 00:08:28,816
be French because in today's world,

142
00:08:28,816 --> 00:08:31,186
French is struggling to remain revelant.

143
00:08:31,186 --> 00:08:34,996
That has been the trend for some time now,
you can check out the links to a few

144
00:08:34,996 --> 00:08:38,356
articles I posted to support that 
statement in the description box.

145
00:08:38,356 --> 00:08:42,356
Listen my Haitian people, generally 
speaking, we don't speak French,

146
00:08:42,356 --> 00:08:45,536
me included, and here are the reasons why.

147
00:08:45,536 --> 00:08:49,536
Speaking a language is not about knowing
some of the grammar or being able to read

148
00:08:49,536 --> 00:08:51,607
and write or understand it.

149
00:08:51,607 --> 00:08:55,607
It's about living the language, hearing it
and feeling it.

150
00:08:55,607 --> 00:08:59,607
I know some kids who were tragically
forbidden by their parents in Haiti to

151
00:08:59,607 --> 00:09:03,607
utter of a word of Creole growing up in 
Haiti,

152
00:09:03,607 --> 00:09:08,777
yet they still didn't speak French what 
they did was essentially translate Creole

153
00:09:08,777 --> 00:09:12,137
phrases into French like for example

154
00:09:12,137 --> 00:09:16,137
"envoie les yeux pour moi s'il te plait"
(true story)

155
00:09:16,137 --> 00:09:20,137
Now, is it grammatically correct, sure,
is it French?

156
00:09:20,770 --> 00:09:23,100
I'll leave that up to you to decide.

157
00:09:23,183 --> 00:09:27,733
Of course you can interact very well with 
a native French speaker but communicating

158
00:09:27,733 --> 00:09:31,733
successfully to another Haitian in French
is much harder.

159
00:09:31,733 --> 00:09:37,613
Short of constantly immersing ourselves in
French in the French culture through up to

160
00:09:37,613 --> 00:09:41,133
date literature, cinema, or other creative
work,

161
00:09:41,133 --> 00:09:44,183
we really cannot keep up with the language

162
00:09:44,183 --> 00:09:49,018
So yeah, we don't speak French and it's ok
it's not the end of the world.

163
00:09:49,018 --> 00:09:53,018
What's not ok is people, my people, not

164
00:09:53,018 --> 00:09:57,879
capable of rationally debating a critical 
issues in our Haitian society.

165
00:09:57,879 --> 00:10:01,879
People who will tell me "well why aren't
you speaking Creole?"

166
00:10:01,879 --> 00:10:05,879
meanwhile their kids probably don't speak
a lick of Creole let alone the French that

167
00:10:05,879 --> 00:10:09,019
they are so loudly and mindlessly 
defending,

168
00:10:09,019 --> 00:10:11,772
people who are blinded by their bias.

169
00:10:12,070 --> 00:10:14,820
I said it in my other video and I'll 
repeat it now.

170
00:10:14,820 --> 00:10:16,429
I love the French language.

171
00:10:16,429 --> 00:10:19,359
My favourite recording artist this season
is actually Belgian.

172
00:10:19,359 --> 00:10:23,359
I am so grateful that I was afforded the
opportunity to learn French.

173
00:10:23,359 --> 00:10:25,999
Many Haitians don't get that opportunity.

174
00:10:25,999 --> 00:10:30,591
And I will pass on as much appreciation
for French to my kids as I can because the

175
00:10:30,591 --> 00:10:35,961
issue is not and has never been the
language; the issue is the many Haitian

176
00:10:35,961 --> 00:10:39,280
people who simply refuse to wake up.

177
00:10:41,044 --> 00:10:47,484
Once again, my name is Marli, I am a Haiti
hope ambassador and Wake up Haitians,

178
00:10:47,484 --> 00:10:51,484
seriously.