WEBVTT
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:02.628
1, 2, 3
AAAAAAAAHHHHHHH!
00:00:02.643 --> 00:00:05.013
Hi everyone, BRATthony Greeentano
here,
00:00:05.013 --> 00:00:09.013
the internet's busiest music nerd.
And it's time for a review
00:00:09.013 --> 00:00:12.441
of this new record "Brat" from Charli xcx.
00:00:12.441 --> 00:00:17.862
Here we have the 6th official full-length
studio album from pop-singer and
00:00:17.862 --> 00:00:20.422
songwriter Ms Charli xcx.
00:00:20.422 --> 00:00:24.572
One of my most anticipated albums of
the year, why?
00:00:24.572 --> 00:00:28.812
Well, over the past decade in my eyes,
Charli has grown into one of the most
00:00:28.812 --> 00:00:32.812
creative, unique, and pioneering forces
in current day pop music.
00:00:32.812 --> 00:00:36.075
And her evolution has been interesting
to watch, to say the least.
00:00:36.075 --> 00:00:39.055
I'm not a fan of her early work,
truth be told, but
00:00:39.055 --> 00:00:42.253
today it serves as an interesting
reference point.
00:00:42.253 --> 00:00:44.663
Uh, for what she is doing on this
record.
00:00:44.663 --> 00:00:48.920
The "True Romance" and "Sucker" eras of
her career, uh, did bring some of
00:00:48.920 --> 00:00:51.541
her biggest hits and features to date,
that is true,
00:00:51.541 --> 00:00:55.341
but sonically, much of the music she was
dropping around this time wasn't...
00:00:55.341 --> 00:00:57.451
very daring or even deep.
00:00:57.451 --> 00:01:00.562
At best, you could say it was catchy
and of-the-time.
00:01:00.562 --> 00:01:03.582
Around the mid-2010s, though,
is when Charli's music
00:01:03.582 --> 00:01:05.586
really began to push boundaries.
00:01:05.586 --> 00:01:08.736
Crossing over creatively with writers and
producers from the
00:01:08.736 --> 00:01:10.515
up-and-coming PC music label.
00:01:10.515 --> 00:01:14.775
I'm talking people like Danny L Harle
and EASYFUN, A.G Cook,
00:01:14.775 --> 00:01:15.815
and the late SOPHIE,
00:01:15.815 --> 00:01:18.574
who at the time were gaining
quite the reputation for
00:01:18.574 --> 00:01:22.896
revitalizing a lot of Y2k-era pop
aesthetics but with a
00:01:22.896 --> 00:01:25.280
hyper-futuristic, jittery sound.
00:01:25.280 --> 00:01:29.380
And our first taste of this new direction
came in the form of
00:01:29.380 --> 00:01:33.027
Charli xcx's "Vroom Vroom" EP in 2016.
00:01:33.027 --> 00:01:36.295
Which some critics just did not know what
to make of at the time,
00:01:36.295 --> 00:01:39.601
and while it was my EP of the year
that year,
00:01:39.601 --> 00:01:43.601
I could still see how this would have
turned a lot of people off if they
00:01:43.601 --> 00:01:47.033
came into Charli's music having certain
expectations,
00:01:47.033 --> 00:01:49.133
given that she was a pop artist.
00:01:49.133 --> 00:01:54.335
Because "Vroom Vroom" in tone, is,
at points, kind of dark, and visceral
00:01:54.335 --> 00:01:56.688
and groovy in a weird way.
00:01:56.688 --> 00:02:00.931
Campy, too, with some tracks varying so
wildly from part to part that,
00:02:00.931 --> 00:02:05.361
uh, you could almost take what she was
doing here as, like, a joke or novelty.
00:02:05.361 --> 00:02:08.835
However, the tracks on this EP are
deadly serious.
00:02:08.835 --> 00:02:14.190
And were also a new, bold step for
pop music as well as in a hot moment,
00:02:14.190 --> 00:02:17.368
for both Charli and PC Music creatively.
00:02:17.368 --> 00:02:22.218
Because at this point, I think Charli became
the perfect conduit for what they were
00:02:22.218 --> 00:02:26.879
trying to channel this detailed and
retro-futuristic, reconstruction
00:02:26.879 --> 00:02:32.341
of 2000s pop music, that blur the lines
between the satirical,
00:02:32.341 --> 00:02:33.664
but also reverent.
00:02:33.664 --> 00:02:36.953
Meanwhile, Charli's creative chemistry
with A.G and SOPHIE
00:02:36.953 --> 00:02:40.701
allowed her, I think, to experiment more
and mature as a songwriter.
00:02:40.701 --> 00:02:43.957
Allowing her the freedom to drop
zany bangers as well as
00:02:43.957 --> 00:02:45.539
sleek-powerful anthems.
00:02:45.539 --> 00:02:49.539
Songs with strange structures, or very
unlikely features,
00:02:49.539 --> 00:02:54.310
A lot of these ideas and concepts were
more or less road-tested on
00:02:54.310 --> 00:02:57.033
the mixtape she dropped back in 2017,
00:02:57.033 --> 00:03:01.201
and then in my eyes, it was all
fully realized on her excellent 2019
00:03:01.201 --> 00:03:02.313
"Charli" record.
00:03:02.313 --> 00:03:06.663
Now, over the years, as Charli has
developed this new sound,
00:03:06.663 --> 00:03:10.493
her writing has offered more depth,
has become more personal and intimate,
00:03:10.493 --> 00:03:13.190
especially on her pandemic album,
"How I'm Feeling Now".
00:03:13.190 --> 00:03:16.134
But I think Charli's writing has grown
more conceptual, too.
00:03:16.134 --> 00:03:21.564
With her presentation as this posh,
English party girl on many of her songs
00:03:21.564 --> 00:03:26.216
has more or less become this exaggerated
character she plays into.
00:03:26.216 --> 00:03:30.814
However, in a way, Charli's instantly
recognizable sound and unique place
00:03:30.814 --> 00:03:37.895
in the pop landscape, uh, became both a
blessing and a curse at the dawn of the 2020s.
00:03:37.895 --> 00:03:43.287
Because her style had gone from
challenging to kind of definable
00:03:43.287 --> 00:03:48.866
with this newly-minted "hyperpop"
term that was being thrown onto everybody
00:03:48.866 --> 00:03:52.370
who sounded even vaguely like her or
100gecs.
00:03:52.370 --> 00:03:56.943
And she quickly went on to strip away
many of the "hyper" characteristics
00:03:56.943 --> 00:04:02.985
of her music on her next album, "Crash",
working with a totally new team of producers
00:04:02.985 --> 00:04:07.587
And while I can't deny the record does
feature some respectable hits,
00:04:07.587 --> 00:04:09.747
I have to ask: At what cost?
00:04:09.747 --> 00:04:13.747
Because "Crash" did very measurably have
quite a bit less character than
00:04:13.747 --> 00:04:16.596
anything that Charli had dropped
in recent years at the time
00:04:16.596 --> 00:04:20.927
Which brings us to today. Charli's
latest album cycle here, "BRAT".
00:04:20.927 --> 00:04:25.665
Where I think she's genuinely reconnecting
with the trajectory that has brought her
00:04:25.665 --> 00:04:28.600
to this point and made her a special artist
to begin with.
00:04:28.600 --> 00:04:32.803
Even EASYFUN and A.G Cook are back
in the mix on this production side,
00:04:32.803 --> 00:04:35.609
on a whole lot of tracks, uh, numerous
others too.
00:04:35.609 --> 00:04:41.089
There are even references to A.G Cook
on some of the lyrics to this record
00:04:41.089 --> 00:04:44.281
as quite a bit of meta-commentary
is going on as well.
00:04:44.281 --> 00:04:49.252
You can really tell that Charli is fully
embracing the impact she's had on pop music
00:04:49.252 --> 00:04:55.462
in recent years, and really using it as
more of a strength than a weakness
00:04:55.462 --> 00:04:57.732
that she can be pigeon holed into.
00:04:57.732 --> 00:05:00.689
And I think that's something she can
do confidently because
00:05:00.689 --> 00:05:05.119
her and A.G Cook aren't just merely
trying to, y'know,
00:05:05.119 --> 00:05:09.119
revive some kind of hyperpop trend on
this LP.
00:05:09.119 --> 00:05:14.909
I mean, for sure, Charli's goal and focus
is to give us this autotuned, bold,
00:05:14.909 --> 00:05:18.909
and hard-hitting homage to 2000s era
pop music,
00:05:18.909 --> 00:05:24.840
but this time around we have a refreshing
focus on dance-pop, on EDM from that era,
00:05:24.840 --> 00:05:28.712
on electropop from that era, club bangers
generally.
00:05:28.712 --> 00:05:33.732
With a pretty aggressive edge, making this
LP very worthy of the title "BRAT".
00:05:33.732 --> 00:05:36.142
Because this record is meant to be
danced to.
00:05:36.142 --> 00:05:37.874
And, at points, cry to.
00:05:37.874 --> 00:05:41.377
As I think Charli's writing is more mature
and thoughtful than it's ever been.
00:05:41.377 --> 00:05:45.229
For one, her party girl persona takes
a bit of a dark turn,
00:05:45.229 --> 00:05:47.086
or at least gets deflated a bit
00:05:47.086 --> 00:05:49.976
as she reveals that it's kind of a
mask,
00:05:49.976 --> 00:05:55.526
and that she doesn't always feel
like she's worthy of being there at the party
00:05:55.526 --> 00:05:58.156
or that her and the party are a bit
at odds.
00:05:58.156 --> 00:06:02.808
Meanwhile, "i think about it all the time"
sees Charli musing about whether or not
00:06:02.808 --> 00:06:05.444
she can continue her career in the way
she currently is,
00:06:05.444 --> 00:06:10.356
while also becoming a mother, which she
very clearly has interest in at some point.
00:06:10.356 --> 00:06:14.806
Skipping ahead here, it's also kind of
crazy how narratively, this contrasts so hard
00:06:14.806 --> 00:06:18.906
with her going back full into party mode
on the closing track, "365".
00:06:18.906 --> 00:06:24.026
Of course, there are notes of nostalgia
on this album, too, that is very much
00:06:24.026 --> 00:06:28.026
in line with tracks like "1999", most
notably on "Rewind",
00:06:28.026 --> 00:06:31.286
but this song specifically is more about
Charli missing the older aspects
00:06:31.286 --> 00:06:32.754
of her life before the fame.
00:06:32.754 --> 00:06:37.358
Between sticky choruses on this track,
she delivers her verses in this way that
00:06:37.358 --> 00:06:40.748
kinda comes off like, conflicted internal
monologue, or like
00:06:40.748 --> 00:06:42.480
she's musically journaling.
00:06:42.480 --> 00:06:45.850
There are lots of tracks on this thing too
that deal in love.
00:06:45.850 --> 00:06:49.850
But these songs narratively feel vastly
different from previous singles like
00:06:49.850 --> 00:06:50.969
"Good Ones", for example.
00:06:50.969 --> 00:06:54.839
Tracks where historically, Charli can be
seen running away from love
00:06:54.839 --> 00:06:59.021
or being a bit self-effacing and talking
about how she's fucking it all up.
00:06:59.021 --> 00:07:02.002
Instead, on songs such as the really
infectious
00:07:02.002 --> 00:07:03.666
singing "Talk talk to me!"
00:07:03.666 --> 00:07:07.242
as, uh, as well laughs
as the very cinematic
00:07:07.242 --> 00:07:09.464
singing "Everything is romantic"
00:07:09.464 --> 00:07:14.267
Yeah, Charli can be seen accepting
love and doing quite a few shoutouts
00:07:14.267 --> 00:07:15.773
to her fiancé George.
00:07:15.773 --> 00:07:20.619
But yes, between this and numerous nods
to wanting to have maybe a more normal
00:07:20.619 --> 00:07:24.883
life at some point, Charli really presents
some interesting internal conflicts
00:07:24.883 --> 00:07:30.019
throughout this album, which we also
hear as well on tracks where she is
00:07:30.019 --> 00:07:35.335
singing about things like friendship
and sharing the limelight with other women.
00:07:35.335 --> 00:07:38.446
I mean, historically Charli is very
pro-woman,
00:07:38.446 --> 00:07:41.895
especially when it comes to supporting
other artists with her music
00:07:41.895 --> 00:07:46.215
through features, through attention she
can throw their way with her creativity
00:07:46.215 --> 00:07:50.215
I mean, even look at the lyrics in the
music video to one of the big singles
00:07:50.215 --> 00:07:51.475
from this record, "360".
00:07:51.475 --> 00:07:54.770
That is the Charli that most fans
know and love.
00:07:54.770 --> 00:07:57.863
By that same token, there are
numerous songs on this record
00:07:57.863 --> 00:08:02.248
where she is being very unfiltered
and just admitting
00:08:02.248 --> 00:08:08.224
how, just, insecure and plagued with
fear she is sometimes.
00:08:08.224 --> 00:08:12.665
There's "Sympathy is a knife" where she
talks about, just, being so
00:08:12.665 --> 00:08:16.665
self-conscious around this other woman
that she wishes for
00:08:16.665 --> 00:08:18.274
a gun to shoot herself with.
00:08:18.274 --> 00:08:22.274
Which is context that some fans might
even miss if they're mostly wrapped up
00:08:22.274 --> 00:08:27.267
in the roaring bass and fantastic string
hits going on the dance beat.
00:08:27.267 --> 00:08:30.701
There's also "GIrl, so confusing" where
Charli sings about the difficulties
00:08:30.701 --> 00:08:34.825
of letting people in, and navigating
the music industry among other
00:08:34.825 --> 00:08:37.841
people who she may have a difficult
time connecting with,
00:08:37.841 --> 00:08:38.889
knowing how to trust.
00:08:38.889 --> 00:08:42.889
The song seems to be very specifically
about a single person who
00:08:42.889 --> 00:08:47.329
maybe she's been likened to by fans
but she doesn't fully see it.
00:08:47.329 --> 00:08:51.193
However, there's still a desire there
on some level to make the friendship
00:08:51.193 --> 00:08:52.467
or the connection work.
00:08:52.467 --> 00:08:56.467
Then the song "Von dutch" sees Charli
getting pretty aggressive and
00:08:56.467 --> 00:08:57.719
combative lyrically.
00:08:57.719 --> 00:09:01.243
Specifically in regards to someone who
doesn't seem to like her,
00:09:01.243 --> 00:09:03.083
maybe even is talking behind her back.
00:09:03.083 --> 00:09:07.686
And her response to that is, essentially,
this big anthemic "Fuck you" here.
00:09:07.686 --> 00:09:12.847
Where she's delivering some biting lyrics
about how this person may actually be
00:09:12.847 --> 00:09:15.105
nothing if it weren't for some
"little dance" they're doing.
00:09:15.105 --> 00:09:19.858
So, yeah, there are these intense
emotional peaks all over the album
00:09:19.858 --> 00:09:24.699
but the biggest bombshell of all of them
has to be the song, "So I".
00:09:24.699 --> 00:09:31.584
Which is very obviously a tribute to the
late great producer and songwriter SOHPIE
00:09:31.584 --> 00:09:34.963
who actually collaborated with Charli
quite a few times,
00:09:34.963 --> 00:09:40.465
so consistently, in fact, from an outside
perspective, I don't think any fan of either
00:09:40.465 --> 00:09:45.237
Charli or SOPHIE would have presumed
anything of them and their connection.
00:09:45.237 --> 00:09:49.530
Other than something along the lines of,
"Hey, they're collaborators, they have
00:09:49.530 --> 00:09:51.801
big respect for each other, they
love each other,
00:09:51.801 --> 00:09:53.261
they're probably friends,
00:09:53.261 --> 00:09:57.061
Charli, SOHPIE, SOPHIE, Charli,
name a more iconic duo-"
00:09:57.061 --> 00:10:02.820
But what Charli says on this track here
actually tells a very different story
00:10:02.820 --> 00:10:07.584
and is quite revealing in a way that
is actually pretty admirable.
00:10:07.584 --> 00:10:11.584
Because the angle of the song is,
yes, very sad, obviously,
00:10:11.584 --> 00:10:14.144
but it doesn't necessarily paint Charli
in the best light.
00:10:14.144 --> 00:10:20.001
And, again, it's painfully sad and
has made me reflect on the tone
00:10:20.001 --> 00:10:24.699
that tributes in art or whatever
other medium often take.
00:10:24.699 --> 00:10:27.929
They usually end up being less about
the tributed person
00:10:27.929 --> 00:10:31.231
and more about the tributer's love and
adoration.
00:10:31.231 --> 00:10:34.582
"Look how great I think this person
is, who we all think is great."
00:10:34.582 --> 00:10:38.795
And Charli's song here does contain
quite a bit of praise for SOHPIE
00:10:38.795 --> 00:10:40.225
that's true, don't get me wrong.
00:10:40.225 --> 00:10:45.038
But a lot of the track is actually an
admittance on Charli's part, with her
00:10:45.038 --> 00:10:48.317
pretty much saying, "I was a shitty
friend."
00:10:48.317 --> 00:10:50.999
"I kinda pushed this person away. I wish
I didn't."
00:10:50.999 --> 00:10:56.270
"And now, I am plagued with an
insurmountable amount of regret."
00:10:56.270 --> 00:11:01.347
Which does make it a really tough listen
even if I think instrumentally and
00:11:01.347 --> 00:11:03.677
melodically it is one of the strongest
showings here.
00:11:03.677 --> 00:11:08.581
Narratively and emotionally there are
quite a few cuts that I think are
00:11:08.581 --> 00:11:12.821
a bit lighter in tone, but they still
contribute a great amount of quality to
00:11:12.821 --> 00:11:16.821
the record and are just generally
fun and entertaining to listen to.
00:11:16.821 --> 00:11:20.161
There's "Club classics", which I thought
was an incredible single to
00:11:20.161 --> 00:11:24.433
the album. Also, "B2b", which is just some
very straightforward, cut and dry,
00:11:24.433 --> 00:11:29.816
throwback, quality dance pop with a pretty
clear hot and cold, back and forth
00:11:29.816 --> 00:11:32.006
love on the rocks type narrative
00:11:32.006 --> 00:11:36.006
There's also "Apple", which is some
very groovy throwbacks synthpop too.
00:11:36.006 --> 00:11:40.867
All about a situation and dynamic that
Charli likens to a rotten apple,
00:11:40.867 --> 00:11:45.566
it's a situation she describes having to
escape from by car, by plane,
00:11:45.566 --> 00:11:50.056
There's "Mean girls", which is a
character portrait about exactly that,
00:11:50.056 --> 00:11:53.838
with a soaring and anthemic chorus
plus a killer piano break
00:11:53.838 --> 00:11:56.214
that the entire track builds off of
from there.
00:11:56.214 --> 00:11:59.574
And then at the very end there's
"365", which is this
00:11:59.574 --> 00:12:03.574
version of the song "360" that kicks
the record off, this
00:12:03.574 --> 00:12:08.244
mirrored, remix-as-reprise big finish.
00:12:08.244 --> 00:12:11.353
With some acid bass mixed in there
for good measure.
00:12:11.353 --> 00:12:14.552
So, I love the way the record finishes.
Love the way it kicks off,
00:12:14.552 --> 00:12:17.431
and the flow from moment to moment
generally is great.
00:12:17.431 --> 00:12:20.206
It's to the point where certain tracks
in the leadup to the record
00:12:20.206 --> 00:12:24.206
that I thought were just kind of okay
sound better being reinforced
00:12:24.206 --> 00:12:27.453
by the vibes and the aesthetics of the
surrounding songs on the album.
00:12:27.453 --> 00:12:30.355
Because as I've heard the entire
thing now many times over,
00:12:30.355 --> 00:12:31.485
I don't think there's a skip on it.
00:12:31.485 --> 00:12:35.485
The production generally goes hard
as hell, it is vibrant, it is colorful,
00:12:35.485 --> 00:12:39.102
it is very visceral at times, aggressive,
but,
00:12:39.102 --> 00:12:42.621
I can see some people kinda scratching
their heads at the fact that it doesn't
00:12:42.621 --> 00:12:48.125
come across quite as futuristic as some
of those "hyperpop" classics
00:12:48.125 --> 00:12:48.899
in recent years.
00:12:48.899 --> 00:12:52.116
But more importantly what I think
the production does on
00:12:52.116 --> 00:12:55.826
this album is that it serves the songs.
00:12:56.111 --> 00:12:59.701
It's sweet when it needs to be,
it's dynamic when it needs to be,
00:12:59.701 --> 00:13:02.701
it's lowkey or explosive when it needs
to be,
00:13:02.701 --> 00:13:06.482
and there is still a very clear and
consistent aesthetic focused on
00:13:06.482 --> 00:13:09.624
the entire album that centers around
a certain era of pop and dance music.
00:13:09.624 --> 00:13:13.398
So, I'm not necessarily disappointed
with this record not being as
00:13:13.398 --> 00:13:16.628
ahead of the curve as a project like
"Charli", for example.
00:13:16.628 --> 00:13:22.000
Especially considering that Charli xcx
copycats these days are abound.
00:13:22.000 --> 00:13:26.600
The impact that people like her and A.G
and SOPHIE have had on the modern era
00:13:26.600 --> 00:13:30.131
of pop music, is not going anywhere
anytime soon.
00:13:30.131 --> 00:13:34.131
And it's with that I say I loved
"BRAT", killer album,
00:13:34.342 --> 00:13:38.342
and I think that this record proves that
Charli truly is a generational pop artist.
00:13:38.342 --> 00:13:42.602
Which is why I'm feeling a strong 9,
to a 10 on this LP.
00:13:42.974 --> 00:13:43.744
Tran-
00:13:43.744 --> 00:13:47.103
sition. Have you given this album a
listen? Did you love it? Did you hate it?
00:13:47.103 --> 00:13:48.934
What would you rate it?
"You're the best, you're the best",
00:13:48.934 --> 00:13:50.744
What should I review next?
Hit the like if you'd like,
00:13:50.744 --> 00:13:53.275
please subscribe, please don't cry,
hit the bell as well.
00:13:53.275 --> 00:13:56.025
Over here next to my head is another video
you can check out,
00:13:56.025 --> 00:13:58.225
hit that up or the link to subscribe
to the channel.
00:13:58.225 --> 00:14:02.000
Anthony Fantano, Charli xcx. Forever.