0:00:00.120,0:00:01.840
So, you probably know that employment

0:00:01.880,0:00:03.280
discrimination is illegal.

0:00:03.440,0:00:05.400
But do you know all the ways that illegal

0:00:05.440,0:00:06.647
employment discrimination

0:00:06.680,0:00:08.040
happens in the workplace?

0:00:08.280,0:00:09.560
Well, you're in luck.

0:00:09.680,0:00:10.760
I'm an employment lawyer,

0:00:10.800,0:00:12.880
and in this video, I'm going to detail

0:00:13.040,0:00:15.000
the different theories of discrimination.

0:00:15.040,0:00:16.880
That is all the ways that illegal

0:00:16.920,0:00:19.280
discrimination happens in the workplace.

0:00:19.400,0:00:20.367
So, stick around.

0:00:23.800,0:00:26.040
[MUSIC] Before I begin,

0:00:26.440,0:00:28.720
nothing in this video is legal advice.

0:00:28.920,0:00:30.360
If you think you were discriminated

0:00:30.400,0:00:32.400
against at work, talk to an employment

0:00:32.440,0:00:33.760
lawyer in your jurisdiction.

0:00:33.920,0:00:35.130
If you're in Washington State,

0:00:35.163,0:00:37.360
feel free to reach out to my firm.

0:00:37.560,0:00:38.840
The link to my website is

0:00:38.880,0:00:40.100
in the description below.

0:00:40.400,0:00:41.367
Okay, let's get to it.

0:00:43.067,0:00:45.080
So, before we talk about all the ways

0:00:45.113,0:00:47.280
that employment discrimination arises

0:00:47.320,0:00:49.280
in the workplace, let's talk a little bit

0:00:49.320,0:00:51.840
about how the law defines discrimination.

0:00:52.040,0:00:52.960
It will be important

0:00:53.000,0:00:54.120
later in our discussion.

0:00:54.200,0:00:56.320
To do that, we'll first look at the law.

0:00:56.560,0:00:58.720
Our protections against discrimination

0:00:58.800,0:01:00.520
arise originally in the

0:01:00.600,0:01:02.640
Civil Rights Act of 1964.

0:01:02.800,0:01:05.200
Most states have also enacted their own

0:01:05.240,0:01:07.440
anti-discrimination statutes that

0:01:07.560,0:01:10.040
supplement the Civil Rights Act of 1964.

0:01:10.200,0:01:12.880
But all workplace discrimination is based

0:01:12.920,0:01:14.680
on the same language originating

0:01:14.720,0:01:16.960
in that Civil Rights Act of 1964.

0:01:17.080,0:01:19.047
The specific part of the Civil Rights Act

0:01:19.080,0:01:19.727
that we'll be looking

0:01:19.760,0:01:21.127
at is called Title VII.

0:01:21.160,0:01:22.960
And specifically, we'll be focusing

0:01:23.160,0:01:25.680
on Section 703, Subsection A.

0:01:25.800,0:01:26.720
That section reads,

0:01:26.753,0:01:29.040
"It shall be an unlawful employment

0:01:29.080,0:01:31.440
practice for an employer to discriminate

0:01:31.520,0:01:34.080
against any individual with respect to his

0:01:34.160,0:01:36.880
compensation, terms, or conditions, or

0:01:37.000,0:01:39.200
privileges of employment, because of such

0:01:39.240,0:01:40.960
individual's race, color,

0:01:41.120,0:01:43.287
religion, sex, or national origin."

0:01:43.320,0:01:44.800
So, to put it simply,

0:01:45.000,0:01:47.080
Title VII's anti-discrimination provision

0:01:47.280,0:01:50.280
outlaws discrimination in compensation,

0:01:50.440,0:01:52.127
terms or conditions of employment,

0:01:52.160,0:01:53.520
or privileges of an employment

0:01:53.720,0:01:55.960
because of protected characteristics.

0:01:56.000,0:01:57.120
But that discrimination can

0:01:57.160,0:01:58.720
happen in any number of ways.

0:01:58.960,0:02:01.080
So, let's talk about each way that that

0:02:01.120,0:02:03.127
discrimination can arise in the workplace.

0:02:04.867,0:02:07.160
So, there are three main theories

0:02:07.200,0:02:09.480
of discrimination that, if they occur,

0:02:09.680,0:02:12.040
they trigger the protections of Title VII

0:02:12.120,0:02:14.240
or the protections of the state-specific

0:02:14.320,0:02:15.607
statute that outlaws

0:02:15.640,0:02:17.080
discrimination in your state.

0:02:17.120,0:02:19.400
These three theories of discrimination are

0:02:19.440,0:02:21.080
known as the following: first,

0:02:21.320,0:02:22.960
disparate treatment; second,

0:02:23.120,0:02:25.080
disparate impact; and third,

0:02:25.240,0:02:26.767
hostile work environment.

0:02:26.800,0:02:28.640
So, let's outline all three of them,

0:02:28.760,0:02:30.640
and I'll provide some examples too.

0:02:31.040,0:02:32.847
So first,

0:02:32.880,0:02:34.520
we'll talk about disparate treatment.

0:02:34.640,0:02:36.320
Now, disparate treatment is the most

0:02:36.400,0:02:37.960
obvious form of discrimination.

0:02:38.240,0:02:39.880
It's the type of discrimination you

0:02:39.920,0:02:41.287
probably think of when you think

0:02:41.320,0:02:42.600
of employment discrimination.

0:02:42.680,0:02:44.880
It simply means that an employer took

0:02:44.920,0:02:47.560
an adverse action against an employee

0:02:47.840,0:02:49.167
because of that employee's

0:02:49.200,0:02:50.760
protected characteristics.

0:02:50.800,0:02:53.640
That adverse action can be discharge,

0:02:53.720,0:02:55.720
demotion, change in benefits,

0:02:55.840,0:02:57.160
change in compensation,

0:02:57.193,0:02:59.440
failure to hire or failure to promote,

0:02:59.520,0:03:01.647
or anything else that changes the worker's

0:03:01.680,0:03:03.200
terms or conditions of employment.

0:03:03.400,0:03:04.280
Remember back to our

0:03:04.320,0:03:05.440
language from Title VII.

0:03:05.560,0:03:07.400
It needs to change the compensation,

0:03:07.520,0:03:08.920
terms, conditions,

0:03:08.960,0:03:11.480
or privileges of employment because of

0:03:11.520,0:03:13.287
the employee's protected characteristics.

0:03:13.320,0:03:15.167
And disparate treatment can be a difficult

0:03:15.200,0:03:17.160
form of discrimination to prove because it

0:03:17.200,0:03:19.520
requires discriminatory intent

0:03:19.680,0:03:20.767
on the part of the employer.

0:03:20.800,0:03:22.720
The employer must have the intent

0:03:22.800,0:03:24.320
to discriminate against the employee

0:03:24.520,0:03:25.680
because of the employee's

0:03:25.720,0:03:27.040
protected characteristics.

0:03:27.280,0:03:28.840
Now, the employee's protected

0:03:28.880,0:03:30.880
characteristics need not be the only

0:03:30.960,0:03:33.040
motivation for the employer's decision,

0:03:33.200,0:03:35.320
but it needs to be a motivating factor.

0:03:35.480,0:03:36.840
In Washington law, we call

0:03:36.880,0:03:38.840
that the substantial factor test.

0:03:38.920,0:03:40.680
An example of disparate treatment

0:03:40.760,0:03:42.920
discrimination would be a hiring manager

0:03:42.960,0:03:45.687
refusing to hire a woman based on his

0:03:45.720,0:03:48.047
concern that the woman will have to take

0:03:48.080,0:03:49.887
time off later in her employment

0:03:49.920,0:03:51.200
to take care of her child.

0:03:51.240,0:03:53.287
He took an adverse action against

0:03:53.320,0:03:55.200
the woman by failing to hire her.

0:03:55.233,0:03:57.527
She was in a protected group because sex

0:03:57.560,0:03:59.680
and gender is a protected characteristic,

0:03:59.720,0:04:00.920
and he was motivated by her

0:04:00.960,0:04:02.080
protected characteristic.

0:04:03.667,0:04:06.080
The next theory of discrimination is known

0:04:06.120,0:04:07.840
as disparate impact,

0:04:07.880,0:04:09.480
and it occurs when an employer has

0:04:09.520,0:04:11.120
a seemingly neutral policy

0:04:11.560,0:04:13.800
that negatively and disproportionately

0:04:14.040,0:04:15.480
impacts workers who are

0:04:15.520,0:04:17.000
members of a protected group.

0:04:17.120,0:04:18.480
Unlike disparate treatment,

0:04:18.680,0:04:20.240
disparate impact does not

0:04:20.320,0:04:22.000
require discriminatory motive.

0:04:22.200,0:04:24.967
Instead, affected employees need only show

0:04:25.000,0:04:27.400
the consequences of that neutral policy

0:04:27.640,0:04:29.247
and how they fall more harshly

0:04:29.280,0:04:30.360
on the protected group.

0:04:30.560,0:04:31.280
For example,

0:04:31.440,0:04:33.520
in a case here in Washington State called

0:04:33.640,0:04:35.240
Kumar versus Gate Gourmet,

0:04:35.320,0:04:38.320
the employer had a policy of not allowing

0:04:38.360,0:04:40.167
workers to bring lunch to work, and

0:04:40.200,0:04:42.160
instead providing the workers their lunch.

0:04:42.320,0:04:44.480
The problem was that the employer failed

0:04:44.520,0:04:46.520
to provide vegetarian options,

0:04:46.560,0:04:48.367
and a group of these employees were

0:04:48.400,0:04:50.240
members of a religious group

0:04:50.273,0:04:52.320
who could not consume meat.

0:04:52.480,0:04:54.400
So, the company's policy forced these

0:04:54.433,0:04:56.847
employees to either consume meat in

0:04:56.880,0:04:59.087
violation of their religion or go hungry.

0:04:59.120,0:05:01.200
So, while the policy didn't explicitly

0:05:01.280,0:05:02.960
discriminate against any group,

0:05:03.080,0:05:05.440
it fell more harshly on this protected

0:05:05.520,0:05:06.960
group because religion is

0:05:07.000,0:05:08.360
a protected characteristic.

0:05:08.400,0:05:10.760
The policy had a discriminatory impact

0:05:10.880,0:05:12.880
on the terms or conditions of employment

0:05:12.913,0:05:15.080
because being able to have lunch

0:05:15.200,0:05:17.200
at work is a condition of employment.

0:05:18.900,0:05:21.920
Now, the final theory of discrimination is

0:05:22.000,0:05:24.120
called hostile work environment,

0:05:24.160,0:05:26.200
but this form of discrimination is most

0:05:26.240,0:05:28.360
commonly referred to as harassment.

0:05:28.440,0:05:30.760
But hostile work environment is a specific

0:05:30.880,0:05:32.640
kind of harassment that triggers those

0:05:32.680,0:05:34.600
protections we talked about from Title VII

0:05:34.720,0:05:36.327
or the state-specific statute

0:05:36.360,0:05:38.320
that outlaws discrimination in your state.

0:05:38.400,0:05:40.440
Remember back to the language

0:05:40.480,0:05:43.240
from Title VII, discriminating in terms or

0:05:43.280,0:05:44.960
conditions of employment because

0:05:45.000,0:05:46.480
of a protected characteristic.

0:05:46.680,0:05:48.920
So, if a manager harasses an employee

0:05:49.080,0:05:51.160
and the harassment is so severe or

0:05:51.240,0:05:53.407
pervasive that it alters the employee's

0:05:53.440,0:05:55.847
ability to do their job, and the manager's

0:05:55.880,0:05:58.320
conduct is based on or because

0:05:58.360,0:05:59.640
of the employee's protected

0:05:59.680,0:06:01.680
characteristic, then that's discrimination

0:06:01.800,0:06:03.840
because it impacts the employee's terms or

0:06:03.880,0:06:04.887
conditions of employment,

0:06:04.920,0:06:06.127
their ability to do their job,

0:06:06.160,0:06:07.447
and it's based on the employee's

0:06:07.480,0:06:08.720
protected characteristics.

0:06:08.840,0:06:10.320
And that form of discrimination is

0:06:10.360,0:06:12.247
called a hostile work environment.

0:06:12.280,0:06:14.280
For more information on hostile work

0:06:14.313,0:06:16.360
environment, I made an in-depth video

0:06:16.480,0:06:18.560
that you can view by clicking on the link.

0:06:18.600,0:06:19.700
I'll put it up here.

0:06:19.767,0:06:21.920
In that video, I explain the criteria

0:06:21.960,0:06:23.767
that a worker must prove in order

0:06:23.800,0:06:25.007
to establish a claim

0:06:25.040,0:06:26.400
of hostile work environment.

0:06:26.433,0:06:28.440
An example of hostile work environment

0:06:28.480,0:06:30.920
discrimination would be a manager making

0:06:31.120,0:06:33.647
misogynistic jokes every day for a period

0:06:33.680,0:06:36.360
of time to a female worker, making

0:06:36.400,0:06:38.920
her feel uncomfortable or even unsafe.

0:06:39.320,0:06:41.640
Okay, so now you know the three kinds

0:06:41.680,0:06:43.600
of illegal employment discrimination.

0:06:43.840,0:06:45.280
The law refers to these theories

0:06:45.320,0:06:47.400
of discrimination as disparate treatment,

0:06:47.480,0:06:48.440
disparate impact,

0:06:48.560,0:06:50.120
and hostile work environment.

0:06:50.160,0:06:51.287
But discrimination is

0:06:51.320,0:06:52.807
a complex area of law.

0:06:52.840,0:06:54.640
To learn more about discrimination,

0:06:54.760,0:06:55.840
check out my guide.

0:06:55.960,0:06:57.040
I have a link to it

0:06:57.080,0:06:58.207
below in the description.

0:06:58.240,0:06:59.647
If you think you were the victim

0:06:59.680,0:07:01.320
of illegal employment discrimination,

0:07:01.520,0:07:03.360
talk to a lawyer in your jurisdiction.

0:07:03.400,0:07:04.760
If you're in Washington State,

0:07:04.793,0:07:07.200
you can feel free to reach out to my firm.

0:07:07.320,0:07:09.280
The more we hold employers accountable

0:07:09.320,0:07:10.680
for their wrongdoing, the more we

0:07:10.720,0:07:12.727
prevent them from harming other workers.

0:07:12.760,0:07:14.360
Okay, that's all for me this week.

0:07:14.480,0:07:15.240
See you next time.