WEBVTT

00:00:00.979 --> 00:00:03.114
In 1989,

00:00:03.114 --> 00:00:05.556
an artist by the name of Dread Scott,

00:00:05.556 --> 00:00:07.626
who has also graced the TED stage,

00:00:07.626 --> 00:00:10.645
created a piece of art in Chicago

00:00:10.645 --> 00:00:14.298
where he simply placed
an American flag on the ground

00:00:14.298 --> 00:00:18.292
and then invited you the viewer
to go and stand on that flag

00:00:18.292 --> 00:00:21.227
and record how it felt in a journal.

00:00:22.446 --> 00:00:26.923
And to me, one of the most powerful things
written in that journal in essence says,

00:00:26.923 --> 00:00:28.991
why are we so OK

00:00:28.991 --> 00:00:30.410
with homeless people,

00:00:30.410 --> 00:00:33.245
with human beings laying on the ground,

00:00:33.478 --> 00:00:34.997
but not flags?

NOTE Paragraph

00:00:37.272 --> 00:00:41.027
And to some of you,
this piece of art is quite disturbing,

00:00:41.027 --> 00:00:43.528
and that's kind of the point of this talk,

00:00:43.528 --> 00:00:45.694
not to upset you or to make you mad

00:00:45.694 --> 00:00:50.424
but to prove to you that flags
have an incredible power,

00:00:51.446 --> 00:00:54.595
and that even if you think
you don't care about flags, you do.

00:00:54.595 --> 00:00:56.071
You know you do.

00:00:56.071 --> 00:00:56.987
All right.

NOTE Paragraph

00:00:56.987 --> 00:00:59.740
By the end of it,
I hope that you're inspired

00:00:59.740 --> 00:01:02.976
to go out and harness this power of flags
and fight for a better world,

00:01:02.976 --> 00:01:04.462
but before we get there,

00:01:04.462 --> 00:01:07.688
we're going to start
on the opposite end of the spectrum,

00:01:08.444 --> 00:01:12.258
and before I show you the next stuff,
I need to say that anything I show here

00:01:12.258 --> 00:01:14.093
is not an endorsement,

00:01:14.093 --> 00:01:15.968
it's usually quite the opposite,

00:01:15.968 --> 00:01:19.855
but more than anything,
what I want to do is create a space here

00:01:19.855 --> 00:01:22.775
where we can look
at these flags, these designs,

00:01:23.058 --> 00:01:25.684
and examine how they make us feel.

00:01:26.235 --> 00:01:28.370
We're going to talk about our emotions.

00:01:28.370 --> 00:01:30.021
Is that OK with everybody?

NOTE Paragraph

00:01:30.021 --> 00:01:31.222
OK.

00:01:31.222 --> 00:01:33.491
You ready for your first flag?

NOTE Paragraph

00:01:33.491 --> 00:01:36.617
Cool, we'll start with an easy one.

00:01:37.069 --> 00:01:38.535
That was a joke.

00:01:39.537 --> 00:01:44.407
So, some of you may be a little bit uneasy
sitting in a room with this.

00:01:44.825 --> 00:01:47.718
I'm certainly feeling uneasy
standing in front of it.

00:01:47.718 --> 00:01:50.386
Some of you may be feeling
a little bit of pride.

00:01:50.804 --> 00:01:55.615
And that's understandable. This is Texas.
This is not a rare sight, is it.

00:01:55.999 --> 00:01:57.934
But let's start with the facts.

00:01:57.934 --> 00:02:01.420
So this is not the Confederate flag. OK?

00:02:01.420 --> 00:02:04.907
This is the battle flag
of the Army of Northern Virginia

00:02:04.907 --> 00:02:07.048
led by General Robert E. Lee,

00:02:07.048 --> 00:02:10.184
so next time someone tells you
that this is their heritage,

00:02:10.184 --> 00:02:13.271
unless their family fought
for that very specific militia,

00:02:13.271 --> 00:02:14.806
they're wrong. All right?

00:02:14.973 --> 00:02:18.033
And you have a flag expert's
permission to tell them so.

00:02:18.416 --> 00:02:23.120
This flag rose into prominence
during the mid-1950s and '60s

00:02:23.120 --> 00:02:26.447
as a response to the growing
Civil Rights Movement.

00:02:26.631 --> 00:02:28.215
And then, of course, today

00:02:28.215 --> 00:02:32.203
it has come to represent
the Confederacy to most of us.

00:02:33.620 --> 00:02:36.813
But I shouldn't have to remind you
what the Confederacy is.

00:02:36.813 --> 00:02:38.347
It was a rogue nation

00:02:38.347 --> 00:02:41.200
that rose up against the United States,

00:02:41.200 --> 00:02:43.069
waged war on the US,

00:02:43.069 --> 00:02:44.570
and at one point in time

00:02:44.570 --> 00:02:47.846
this was one of the most
un-American things you could have.

00:02:48.463 --> 00:02:51.216
But yet, this flag is protected

00:02:51.216 --> 00:02:54.689
by the same laws that protect
the United States flag

00:02:54.689 --> 00:02:57.228
in the states of Florida, Georgia,

00:02:57.228 --> 00:03:00.665
South Carolina, Mississippi and Louisiana.

NOTE Paragraph

00:03:01.748 --> 00:03:04.768
But let's pick on Georgia
for a second, shall we?

00:03:04.768 --> 00:03:06.678
So in 1956,

00:03:06.678 --> 00:03:10.414
a few years after desegregation
was mandated in public schools,

00:03:10.414 --> 00:03:12.799
Georgia changed their state flag to this.

00:03:14.867 --> 00:03:17.627
I think everyone watching can agree

00:03:17.627 --> 00:03:21.514
that this was not meant to be a flag
that every Georgian was proud to fly

00:03:21.514 --> 00:03:23.766
outside of their home, was it.

00:03:23.966 --> 00:03:29.461
Just like all of the Confederate statues
erected in the mid-1950s and '60s,

00:03:29.811 --> 00:03:33.081
this was meant to be a symbol
of who was in charge

00:03:33.081 --> 00:03:34.866
and who was not.

00:03:35.940 --> 00:03:37.943
This remained the flag of Georgia

00:03:37.943 --> 00:03:40.027
until the year 2001,

00:03:41.046 --> 00:03:43.398
and in that year they changed their flag

00:03:43.398 --> 00:03:44.686
to this.

00:03:45.266 --> 00:03:49.543
Now, as a flag expert, I can tell you
this is officially ugly.

00:03:49.543 --> 00:03:51.562
OK? It's OK to laugh at this flag.

00:03:51.562 --> 00:03:53.815
It's ugly, and because it's so ugly,

00:03:53.815 --> 00:03:57.040
that's one of the reasons
they changed it just two years later.

00:03:57.040 --> 00:03:58.542
They had a referendum

00:03:58.542 --> 00:04:00.932
where they got to choose
between that thing

00:04:00.932 --> 00:04:03.780
and then what is now
the current flag of Georgia.

NOTE Paragraph

00:04:04.464 --> 00:04:06.456
Now some of you might be wondering,

00:04:06.456 --> 00:04:07.490
wait a second, Michael,

00:04:07.490 --> 00:04:10.026
if that before wasn't
the Confederate flag,

00:04:10.026 --> 00:04:12.711
what was the Confederate flag?

00:04:13.061 --> 00:04:18.323
Georgia flies the first flag
of the Confederate States of America

00:04:18.323 --> 00:04:20.042
to this day.

00:04:20.325 --> 00:04:23.345
They just slapped their state seal on it.

NOTE Paragraph

00:04:23.345 --> 00:04:25.683
Well let's go back
to our emotions for a second.

00:04:25.683 --> 00:04:30.192
That didn't punch you in the gut
as much as the other one did, did it.

00:04:30.192 --> 00:04:31.442
Right?

00:04:31.872 --> 00:04:34.180
And that's why I love flags.

00:04:34.180 --> 00:04:37.316
They are the simplest pieces of design,

00:04:37.316 --> 00:04:39.552
usually just two or three colors,

00:04:39.552 --> 00:04:41.837
just some bars or stripes,

00:04:41.837 --> 00:04:45.713
but yet they can invoke
the deepest emotions within us.

00:04:45.713 --> 00:04:50.604
They'll make us swell with pride
or burn with hatred.

00:04:50.604 --> 00:04:53.387
We will die for a flag

00:04:53.387 --> 00:04:55.796
or even kill for one.

NOTE Paragraph

00:04:57.064 --> 00:04:59.949
One of my favorite designers,
his name is Wally Olins,

00:04:59.949 --> 00:05:02.606
they call him the father
of nation branding,

00:05:02.606 --> 00:05:04.361
and he's quotes as saying

00:05:04.361 --> 00:05:07.497
that everyone wants to belong,

00:05:07.497 --> 00:05:10.967
and then they want to display
symbols of belonging.

00:05:11.618 --> 00:05:15.945
And it's crazy that these pieces of cloth
that are just sewn together or dyed

00:05:15.945 --> 00:05:18.447
come to be such a sacred item,

00:05:19.115 --> 00:05:22.352
and that's because they become
parts of our identity.

00:05:22.684 --> 00:05:25.543
They are powerful tools to unify

00:05:25.543 --> 00:05:29.163
but equally powerful tools to divide.

00:05:29.580 --> 00:05:31.549
You ready for the next flag?

NOTE Paragraph

00:05:32.367 --> 00:05:33.925
Right.

00:05:34.793 --> 00:05:36.444
Take a moment.

00:05:36.444 --> 00:05:39.914
Really examine how you felt
when this hit the screen.

00:05:40.164 --> 00:05:42.350
I'm going to change
the slide pretty quickly

00:05:42.350 --> 00:05:45.658
so you don't take pictures of me
in front of this one.

00:05:45.993 --> 00:05:47.260
All right?

NOTE Paragraph

00:05:47.260 --> 00:05:50.397
So Germany after World War I,

00:05:50.397 --> 00:05:52.482
it was in a pretty bad state,

00:05:52.482 --> 00:05:56.642
and a young Adolf Hitler had a lot of,
let's call them ideas,

00:05:57.143 --> 00:05:59.979
of how Germany got to where they'd gotten

00:05:59.979 --> 00:06:01.947
and how to get them out.

00:06:01.947 --> 00:06:04.890
He spent entire chapters
in his book "Mein Kampf,"

00:06:04.890 --> 00:06:06.859
which I don't recommend reading,

00:06:06.859 --> 00:06:08.994
about how Germany lost World War I

00:06:08.994 --> 00:06:12.630
partially because the British
had better graphic design

00:06:12.630 --> 00:06:14.940
and better propaganda.

00:06:15.541 --> 00:06:17.758
So, as the Nazi Party rose,

00:06:17.758 --> 00:06:21.663
Hitler created one of the thickest
brand guides I've ever seen.

00:06:21.893 --> 00:06:24.224
It's thicker than most
company brand guides today,

00:06:24.224 --> 00:06:28.062
and in it he details titles and uniforms

00:06:28.062 --> 00:06:30.630
and lots and lots of flags.

00:06:31.010 --> 00:06:32.717
Hitler knew the power of flags.

00:06:32.717 --> 00:06:34.352
He says in "Mein Kampf,"

00:06:34.352 --> 00:06:37.479
"The new flag... should prove
effective as a large poster,"

00:06:37.479 --> 00:06:39.764
because "in hundreds of thousands of cases

00:06:39.764 --> 00:06:42.316
a really striking emblem

00:06:42.316 --> 00:06:45.753
may be the first cause
of awakening interest in a movement."

00:06:46.286 --> 00:06:48.062
He was an artist, after all.

00:06:48.062 --> 00:06:52.266
He knew the power
of visual identity and uniforms

00:06:52.266 --> 00:06:55.135
could reignite the German identity.

00:06:55.135 --> 00:07:00.096
And to millions of Germans
this was a welcome sign.

00:07:00.096 --> 00:07:04.233
But of course this was
a mark of death to others.

NOTE Paragraph

00:07:05.167 --> 00:07:09.495
We don't often think of flags as weapons,

00:07:09.495 --> 00:07:11.697
but like the Confederate battle flag,

00:07:11.697 --> 00:07:13.999
the Germans used their flag

00:07:13.999 --> 00:07:17.325
to make an outgroup feel unwelcome

00:07:17.325 --> 00:07:19.477
and less than.

00:07:19.477 --> 00:07:22.146
You see, when you create a flag,
you immediately do two things.

00:07:22.146 --> 00:07:24.082
You create an ingroup,

00:07:24.082 --> 00:07:26.567
a group that's meant
to be represented by the symbol,

00:07:26.567 --> 00:07:28.826
but then inevitably
you create an outgroup.

00:07:28.826 --> 00:07:30.377
And usually that's subtle.

00:07:30.377 --> 00:07:31.728
It's a byproduct.

00:07:31.728 --> 00:07:33.529
It's usually not the intent.

00:07:33.529 --> 00:07:37.941
But the Germans were very clear
as to who was represented by the swastika

00:07:37.941 --> 00:07:39.660
and who was not.

00:07:40.176 --> 00:07:44.881
In 1935, Jewish people were banned
from flying German flags.

00:07:44.881 --> 00:07:47.674
And in this way,

00:07:47.674 --> 00:07:51.093
the Germans, maybe more than
any other time in history,

00:07:51.093 --> 00:07:53.445
used the dual power of flags

00:07:53.445 --> 00:07:56.939
to unite but also to divide.

00:07:57.981 --> 00:08:01.216
Flags were used as identity weapons.

00:08:01.216 --> 00:08:05.510
And now, in 2019, the Nazi flag
is banned from being flown

00:08:05.510 --> 00:08:07.212
by anyone in Germany,

00:08:07.212 --> 00:08:11.232
and anyone in Austria, in Hungary,
in Russia and in Ukraine.

00:08:11.232 --> 00:08:12.850
Think about that.

00:08:12.850 --> 00:08:15.269
It's a piece of cloth, but it's banned.

00:08:15.269 --> 00:08:17.578
On its face, that sounds crazy,

00:08:17.578 --> 00:08:20.782
but I don't think anyone
in this room would disagree

00:08:20.782 --> 00:08:22.599
that it's probably good.

00:08:23.066 --> 00:08:26.669
Sounds a lot like a weapon.

NOTE Paragraph

00:08:26.669 --> 00:08:28.295
As a vexillologist,

00:08:28.295 --> 00:08:31.116
sometimes the most interesting
thing about a flag

00:08:31.116 --> 00:08:32.784
is not so much its design,

00:08:32.784 --> 00:08:36.619
but it's those laws around the flag.

00:08:36.787 --> 00:08:39.514
For instance,

00:08:39.514 --> 00:08:41.547
in India, to create an Indian flag,

00:08:41.547 --> 00:08:45.552
you must use a hand-spun
cloth named Khadi.

00:08:45.702 --> 00:08:48.262
If you make a flag out of anything else,

00:08:48.262 --> 00:08:50.896
you could go to jail
for up to three years.

00:08:51.514 --> 00:08:52.714
It's crazy.

00:08:52.714 --> 00:08:54.517
Here in Texas,

00:08:54.517 --> 00:08:56.251
we've all heard

00:08:56.251 --> 00:08:59.744
that the Texas flag is the only state flag
that can fly at the same height

00:08:59.744 --> 00:09:01.096
as the US, flag, right?

00:09:01.096 --> 00:09:03.754
Because we were a nation
before we were a state.

00:09:03.754 --> 00:09:05.485
Who here has heard that?

00:09:05.667 --> 00:09:06.668
Yeah.

00:09:06.668 --> 00:09:10.294
Well, I'm here to tell you
that is completely false. OK?

00:09:10.294 --> 00:09:15.015
First of all, we were not the only state
that was a nation before joining up,

00:09:15.015 --> 00:09:19.092
and secondly, all state flags can fly
at the same height as the US flag

00:09:19.092 --> 00:09:22.629
according to the US flag code.

00:09:22.629 --> 00:09:25.649
And I don't have to ask you
how you feel about this one, right?

00:09:25.649 --> 00:09:28.808
Most of us grew up pledging allegiance
to this every morning,

00:09:28.808 --> 00:09:31.311
knowing we should never
let it touch the ground, etc.

00:09:31.311 --> 00:09:36.231
We take our flag code very seriously
here in the United States.

NOTE Paragraph

00:09:37.232 --> 00:09:41.443
You remember, recently some NFL players
kneeling during the national anthem.

00:09:41.443 --> 00:09:43.344
It was a big controversy.

00:09:43.344 --> 00:09:45.229
They were breaking the flag code.

00:09:45.229 --> 00:09:49.123
It states during the national anthem,

00:09:49.324 --> 00:09:50.709
stand at attention,
hand at the heart, etc.

00:09:50.709 --> 00:09:55.913
But what was fascinating to me
as a vexillologist is that I didn't see

00:09:55.913 --> 00:09:57.723
anyone getting upset

00:09:57.723 --> 00:09:58.455
when something like this happens.

00:09:58.455 --> 00:10:01.959
The flag code says the flag should never
be carried flat or horizontally,

00:10:01.959 --> 00:10:04.000
but always aloft and free.

00:10:04.000 --> 00:10:06.764
So sometimes during
the exact same national anthem,

00:10:06.764 --> 00:10:09.389
this was being done and no one's upset.

00:10:09.389 --> 00:10:11.691
Or this. This happens all the time.

00:10:11.691 --> 00:10:13.075
The flag code is clear.

00:10:13.075 --> 00:10:17.837
No part of the flag should ever be used
as a costume or on an athletic uniform.

00:10:18.554 --> 00:10:20.289
This is Texas A&M baseball,

00:10:20.289 --> 00:10:23.175
not to get them in trouble,
but this happens all the time,

00:10:23.175 --> 00:10:25.927
especially in November.

00:10:25.927 --> 00:10:28.336
I'm sure, I can almost guarantee
when you leave here tonight,

00:10:28.336 --> 00:10:31.022
you will see on the back
of someone's car or truck

00:10:31.022 --> 00:10:33.558
a black and white American flag
with a blue stripe,

00:10:33.558 --> 00:10:35.076
a thin blue line, right?

00:10:35.076 --> 00:10:37.327
Blue Lives Matter.

00:10:37.327 --> 00:10:39.604
That breaks the flag code
in multiple ways,

00:10:39.604 --> 00:10:43.247
but all of these things are done
with the best intent.

00:10:43.247 --> 00:10:45.559
No one's here to argue that.

00:10:45.559 --> 00:10:47.718
But of course they break
a section of the flag code

00:10:47.718 --> 00:10:50.169
titled "Respect for the Flag,"

00:10:50.169 --> 00:10:52.655
so by putting this on your uniform,

00:10:52.655 --> 00:10:56.192
you are legally disrespecting the flag.

00:10:57.243 --> 00:10:59.685
And what I find interesting

00:10:59.685 --> 00:11:01.337
is that those NFL players
kneeling during the anthem

00:11:01.337 --> 00:11:04.306
and the people who would put
Blue Lives Matters stickers on their car

00:11:04.306 --> 00:11:08.000
are both on the opposite end
of a very big issue,

00:11:08.000 --> 00:11:11.686
but they're both breaking
the exact same law,

00:11:11.953 --> 00:11:16.208
a law that is 100 percent unenforceable.

00:11:17.024 --> 00:11:21.918
In fact, it was Dread Scott's
piece of art in 1989

00:11:21.918 --> 00:11:26.039
that led the Supreme Court to rule
that the flag code is just a guideline.

00:11:26.039 --> 00:11:28.348
You cannot be prosecuted
for breaking the flag code.

00:11:28.348 --> 00:11:32.187
You cannot be forced to be patriotic.

NOTE Paragraph

00:11:32.187 --> 00:11:37.257
So why, then, have all of these
little laws around how we use our flag

00:11:37.257 --> 00:11:38.965
if you can't enforce them?

00:11:38.965 --> 00:11:43.185
And that's because a nation

00:11:43.185 --> 00:11:45.738
is a fragile collective idea.

00:11:45.738 --> 00:11:47.896
It only exists in our minds.

00:11:48.529 --> 00:11:50.564
See this? Thank you.

00:11:52.176 --> 00:11:58.165
Sometimes a flag is the only
tangible symbol of that idea.

00:11:58.632 --> 00:12:04.229
Right? Our unity is sometimes
only held together by literal threads.

00:12:04.911 --> 00:12:06.846
And that's powerful.

00:12:06.846 --> 00:12:11.190
The flag code is meant to preserve
and protect that fragile idea,

00:12:11.190 --> 00:12:14.310
while also protecting
your right to break it.

NOTE Paragraph

00:12:14.960 --> 00:12:18.313
And that's what's special
about the United States, right?

00:12:18.313 --> 00:12:21.540
And that's what's unique about our flag.

00:12:21.540 --> 00:12:22.790
Our flag is amazing.

00:12:22.790 --> 00:12:26.194
It has changed more than
any other flag in the world.

00:12:26.194 --> 00:12:29.136
It's the flag code that says
when a new state is created,

00:12:29.136 --> 00:12:30.970
a star shall be added
to the union of the flag,

00:12:30.970 --> 00:12:35.414
and such addition shall take place
on the fourth day of July.

00:12:36.430 --> 00:12:40.924
Our flag is unique because
it is meant to grow as we grow.

00:12:41.758 --> 00:12:43.483
By design and by law,

00:12:43.483 --> 00:12:45.687
it is meant to change with us.

00:12:45.911 --> 00:12:48.696
It's a living symbol of our individuality,

00:12:48.696 --> 00:12:51.164
our diversity in the stars,

00:12:51.164 --> 00:12:53.250
and our unity.

00:12:53.250 --> 00:12:56.779
We have a gift in the United States
to have a flag that is inclusive.

00:12:56.779 --> 00:13:02.548
If the Nazi flag was an identity weapon,

00:13:02.548 --> 00:13:06.826
the United States flag, by design alone,
stands in direct contrast.

00:13:07.332 --> 00:13:10.816
And I have to say,
as a vexillologist in 2019,

00:13:10.816 --> 00:13:12.428
using this flag

00:13:12.428 --> 00:13:14.787
as an identity weapon against anyone

00:13:14.787 --> 00:13:18.857
disrespects it far more
than letting it touch the ground

00:13:18.857 --> 00:13:22.977
or any one of the other little laws
that we break every day.

00:13:22.977 --> 00:13:24.502
Right?

00:13:26.337 --> 00:13:30.290
This flag is a symbol of our union.

00:13:30.507 --> 00:13:33.808
We should never use this as a weapon
against someone else.

00:13:33.808 --> 00:13:38.522
I resonate so deeply with the person
who wrote in Dread Scott's journal,

00:13:38.522 --> 00:13:42.308
"We should never value the symbol
over the thing that it symbolizes.

00:13:42.992 --> 00:13:47.186
We should never value a piece of cloth
over a human life."

00:13:48.254 --> 00:13:51.341
And if you're ever going to use
a piece of cloth as a weapon,

00:13:51.341 --> 00:13:53.009
you should never use this one,

00:13:53.009 --> 00:13:56.752
not when it has always
had room for more stars.

00:13:56.752 --> 00:14:00.172
Hopefully by now, you've felt
the power of flags

00:14:00.440 --> 00:14:03.492
and you can see what they can do.

00:14:03.766 --> 00:14:05.751
So what if we harnessed that power

00:14:05.751 --> 00:14:09.104
and we used it to fight
for something greater?

00:14:09.104 --> 00:14:12.607
This is the flag of Earth,

00:14:13.748 --> 00:14:17.084
designed by Oskar Pernefeldt of Sweden.

00:14:17.852 --> 00:14:20.121
Just imagine with me for a second,

00:14:20.121 --> 00:14:24.115
what if we celebrated our humanity

00:14:24.115 --> 00:14:25.883
as much if not more

00:14:25.883 --> 00:14:28.669
than we celebrate our nationalities?

00:14:29.119 --> 00:14:33.698
As we become a spacefaring civilization
and we go off into the stars,

00:14:33.698 --> 00:14:36.700
what do our nations mean anyway
when you're standing

00:14:36.700 --> 00:14:39.151
on the surface of Mars
or any other planet?

00:14:39.435 --> 00:14:41.922
And then of course, back here on Earth,

00:14:41.922 --> 00:14:45.631
as our planet is facing a climate crisis,

00:14:45.881 --> 00:14:50.119
as our climate could be unlivable in
our children or grandchildren's lifetime,

00:14:50.335 --> 00:14:53.521
I believe we need a strong symbol, a flag,

00:14:54.179 --> 00:14:56.165
to unite us to fight,

00:14:56.682 --> 00:14:58.317
not just as nations,

00:14:58.317 --> 00:15:00.751
but as a species.

NOTE Paragraph

00:15:00.969 --> 00:15:02.252
Thank you.

NOTE Paragraph

00:15:02.469 --> 00:15:04.962
(Applause)