-
Moira: Kia ora koutou.
-
Me karakia tātou.
Kia hora te marino
-
Kia whakapapa pounamu te moana
Hei huarahi mā tātou i te rangi nei
-
Aroha atu
Aroha mai
-
Tātou i ā tātou katoa
Hui ē!
-
Tāiki ē!
-
Kia ora koutou,
mihi atu kia koutou katoa.
-
Welcome, thank you so much for being here
for this webinar session which is around supporting
-
parents and whānau of intersex young people.
Weʻll talk a bit more about intersex young
-
people and our organisations and the
Be There campaign that this is part of in a minute.
-
But just to start off with Iʻll stop sharing
my slide and we can all introduce ourselves,
-
let you know whoʻs all here.
Iʻm Moira Clunie, Iʻm Project Lead
-
for Te Ngākau Kahukura, and coming to you
from Tāmaki Makaurau, from Mt Eden in Auckland.
-
Iʻll pass over to Joey to
introduce themselves.
-
Joey: Kia ora. Thanks Moira, thank you
for opening this space for us.
-
And kia ora koutou, itʻs nice to have
some people here with us live
-
and wonderful also if you are watching this
as a recording which how we anticipate quite a lot
-
of people will probably be getting into it.
So, kia ora on the non-live part of this.
-
Iʻm Joey, Iʻm the Education Lead
at Te Ngākau Kahukura.
-
My pronouns are they/them and Iʻm also Zooming
you from Tāmaki Makaurau, specifically out west,
-
near Te Henga, Bethells Beach which is also where
I grew up, on the whenua of Te Kauwarau Ā Maki.
-
We can probably hand to Jelly next, right?
We have a fabulous guest here to do a
-
presentation and, bring this
conversation to life with us today. Jelly.
-
Jelly: Kia ora.
-
Joey: So nice that youʻre here.
-
Jelly: Oh, thanks so much for having me.
-
Iʻm really excited for this conversation.
So, Iʻm Jelly.
-
Iʻm from Intersex Aotearoa.
Iʻm in Te Whanganui-A-Tara.
-
And weʻre gonna, I think weʻre gonna
have a great conversation today.
-
Thanks to everyone here and Te Ngākau
Kahukura and Jono in the background doing tech.
-
Shout out.
-
Joey: Shout out.
I was gonna say that but you got to it first.
-
Jelly: Oh sorry [laughter]
-
Joey: No, itʻs great. Yeah, we have
our lovely colleague Jono
-
in the chat is collecting of questions
and various comments so if you have any
-
questions that occur to you as we go along,
feel free to pop them into the chat and Jono
-
will be monitoring that so that we donʻt
miss it if we are mid blah, blah, blah at the time.
-
Cool .Ok Iʻm gonna say
a little bit about,
-
the Be There project which is kind of the
mechanism that we are bringing you
-
this webinar through.
Itʻs a great collaboration
-
between a whole lot of rainbow led, intersex led,
trans led support organisations across Aotearoa.
-
So, itʻs a project from the Rainbow
Support Collective and our members include
-
Dunedin Pride, Burnett Foundation Aotearoa,
Qtopia, Rainbow Youth, Te Ngākau Kahukura,
-
Rainbow Health Waikato, InsideOUT, Q-Youth,
Intersex Aotearoa, Outline Aotearoa,
-
and Gender Minorities Aotearoa.
-
You can tell where we are [laughter].
One of the things that came through
-
the process of doing Be There as a project,
which had a kind of public campaign with
-
some posters and a whole lot of information
on a website and now weʻre doing
-
some workshops and some webinars, one of
the things that really came through was that
-
intersex young people and families with young
people with variations of sex characteristics,
-
we know terminology is varied, were really
being missed in some parts of our messaging,
-
you know, some of our content really needs
some adapting and some shifting and some
-
making sure itʻs more relevant for a range
of different perspectives.
-
And weʻre working on that with the Be There
project, so weʻre deeply grateful to have Jelly
-
and other people guiding us on that work.
-
I think that one of the key messages from
Be There has been ʻshow unconditional loveʻ.
-
Itʻs like the first top level message that
hits home pretty well for, I would
-
say any young person so including
intersex young people, rainbow young people,
-
trans young people, broadly, broadly anyone.
I also thought that one of our key messages of
-
ʻyou are not aloneʻ is a really relevant one
because we donʻt want parents and whānau and
-
caregivers to feel like they are alone either.
This is a webinar that is
-
particularly aimed at parents and whānau
of intersex young people.
-
Weʻre welcoming also our other allies and
supporters and potentially people working
-
in health and social services who are attending
to learn more about the topic but our
-
real goal is to aim this at parents and
whānau of young people.
-
We want you to feel more confident to support
the intersex young person in your whānau,
-
to know where you can go to
get more information or advice.
-
We donʻt feel like weʻve got all of
the answers here but we are
-
really, really pleased and grateful and
quite humbled to be part of this conversation.
-
We know its a really ongoing evolving
everchanging kind of space.
-
Weʻll be sharing some insights,
particularly Jelly will be sharing
-
some insights in a presentation about
intersex health and what some adults
-
have said they wished their whānau knew.
Ah, yeah, maybe Iʻll stop there.
-
I could keep going but I wanna keep us
moving on and I think Moira has the next
-
slide about some language notes?
-
Moira: Yeah, thanks Joey. And just briefly
to kind of situate ourselves in terms of the topic,
-
Jelly will speak more to this later on, but I just
wanted to briefly say that intersex is an
-
umbrella term that talks about
people who are born with
-
innate variations in their sex characteristics.
-
So, they might have chromosomes or bodies
or hormones, genitalia,
-
a range of different kind of aspects of their body
that might be considered as outside of the
-
kind of typical definitions of male or female.
Not everybody who fits
-
under this umbrella might use the word ʻintersexʻ
or might know the word ʻintersexʻ.
-
They might have just heard a particular
diagnostic word from a doctor.
-
They might not be aware of fitting into
this kind of wider umbrella term.
-
And not every whānau uses the word
ʻintersexʻ to talk about who their loved one is.
-
Thereʻs a range of other terminology
thatʻs used around differences
-
of sex development, words around diagnostic
labels or conditions or variations.
-
Intersex can be a really helpful umbrella term
to talk about that whole range of diversity but
-
isnʻt the word that everybody necessarily uses.
So just to say that briefly and Jelly will
-
have a presentation and more to say about it
later, but Jelly did you have anything to add
-
at this point?
Did I get that more or less right?
-
Jelly: You nailed it.
That was beautiful.
-
Moira: Nice one. Thank you, so I’ll close
the slides down again and pass back to Joey
-
to situate us a bit more.
-
Joey: Cool. I really just have some
practical notes,
-
which is about welcoming people to use
the chat function and the Q&A function.
-
So, if you want to pop questions or comments,
thoughts that you have into that,
-
into the chat, you have the option to
send it to us as hosts and panellists
-
only or to send it to everyone.
You can introduce yourself
-
and ask questions there if you like to.
You’re also welcome just to be a silent observer.
-
And if you’re watching this as a recording,
I know that’s what you will be doing.
-
We’re gonna make some space for answering
questions at the end of the webinar and
-
this is gonna be quite conversational.
We’re gonna chat amongst ourselves so if you have
-
even just thoughts, rather than fully formed
questions that you just wanna throw into the mix,
-
that’s really helpful and great for us.
You know, we would,
-
even if we don’t have the answer to something,
we would welcome you to ask the question.
-
We’ve got Jono in the chat, as I mentioned,
collecting things.
-
The Q&A function is good if you want to
ask an anonymous question.
-
You know because you can do it in the
chat but just sending it to us, but we’ll
-
still know who it was that asked that question.
Whereas if you use the Q&A function, I believe you
-
can make yourself anonymous completely and
then we won’t know who asked the question either.
-
That just might be reassuring or helpful
if you were feeling that way.
-
We are recording this webinar
and planning to make it publicly available.
-
So, be mindful of that.
We’re not going to let anybody unmute
-
themselves and speak as an audience member.
We’re gonna be the only ones speaking
-
and the only people who will be
visible will be us as presenters.
-
But, if we get a question coming in that
is in any way naming any information about
-
anyone, we won’t be reading that question out.
We’ll be anonymising things, or editing things, or
-
possibly reframing things if anything comes
through that we think is a bit...
-
sharing a bit too much information
about any particular person.
-
Just in case you ask something, and it gets
reframed, and you’re worried about why,
-
this is partly why because it will be
a public education resource.
-
So, we’re balancing that, kind of, that edge of
wanting it to be really relevant,
-
wanting your comments and your questions,
feel free to put them in and also wanting
-
to make sure it can go out to a
really wide audience after this as a recording.
-
And as I’ve said, we’re aiming this primarily,
at parents and whānau of intersex young people.
-
We know we have a wider audience than that
who are attending or who will be watching this, and
-
we really welcome all of you and ask that you are
respectful and generous to each other and to us.
-
We will be also to you.
We know that these topics are often difficult.
-
Sometimes not something we know how to talk
about comfortably and with a lot of
-
flow so we will be doing our best.
Please be compassionate to
-
yourselves and, and to us about it as well.
Moira, I think you had something else to add?
-
I love that Jelly is nodding.
I get so much support and good feeling when
-
Jelly nods while I’m talking [laughter].
So that’s great, thanks.
-
Jelly if you have anything to
add at that point, feel free.
-
Jelly: Thanks.I’m, I’m really
enjoying this webinar so far. Great!
-
Joey: Thanks.
-
Moira: Nice one.
I just had a few more thoughts
-
to add before we get into Jelly’s presentation
which is just to say that we’re really
-
coming from a place of wanting to encourage
whānau and parents of intersex young people to
-
be in a better position to love and support
the young person in their family.
-
We don’t have medical expertise
and we’re not coming with medical
-
advice today.
Te Ngākau Kahukura
-
and Intersex Aotearoa have worked together
before on lots of things and we share
-
some principles on which we do this work.
So some of what’s really important to both
-
of our organisations is supporting bodily autonomy
and supporting self-determination, supporting
-
young people to be who they are.
We want to see a world that actively
-
embraces and values all of our young people,
including intersex young people,
-
and doesn’t position or understand any of us
as broken or inherently wrong or in need of fixing.
-
We want young people to not be getting those
messages as they’re growing up.
-
Also recognise that medical paradigms and
diagnosis and the sorts of information that
-
come from doctors can be really empowering
and useful for some people.
-
For many people, as well,
we recognise the harm
-
that the medical establishment has done and,
in some contexts, continues to do particularly,
-
when they’re working with intersex people.
And we want there to be different paradigms,
-
different knowledge bases for people
to be able to use and feel supported by.
-
We also know that lots of people don’t have
heaps of knowledge about intersex stuff.
-
There’s not that many opportunities
to have these public conversations.
-
There might be some clunky language or
questions or comments that come through.
-
Really encouraging people to ask
questions even if they’re not quite
-
sure of the language or how to word it.
Sometimes, as Joey was saying,
-
we might offer a different way of
phrasing things for the recording.
-
And also, wanna acknowledge for
those of you that are here that it can be hard
-
to be an intersex person in spaces
like this and to be hearing different
-
words used about yourself and your experience.
Yeah, wanna really encourage respectful and
-
generous communications so that people
who don’t know as much can learn
-
from this conversation.
-
That’s me, I think.
I’m gonna invite Jelly to
-
share some slides and some thoughts with us now.
And then we’ll have some space for questions and
-
conversation afterwards.
And as Joey was saying,
-
please do pop any thoughts or questions in
the chat or in the Q&A as we go through as well.
-
But, Jelly, can I pass over to you?
-
Jelly: You can. Thanks so much, both of you,
for grounding us in such a well held environment,
-
and, I did want to just say that when we are
talking about this topic, you know,
-
that we are sometimes covering difficult
things and lots of feelings can come up.
-
So, take care do what you need to do
as an audience member.
-
Because, yeah, it’s a ride but this is hopefully
a gentle one that we all
-
can enjoy and learn together.
So today, I’m here.
-
I’m a adult with an intersex variation.
-
Um, M.R.K.H is my acronym
for my variation.
-
I don’t even know how to pronounce it.
That’s not me trying to be cool with the acronym.
-
Says quite a lot, doesn’t it.
But I also wanted to name that I
-
am not a parent but I’m here today to
have a conversation about where we’re at,
-
are at as a broader society and what are some
of the ways to think about the roles of parents and
-
carers within that as they journey through life
with the young person with an intersex variation.
-
So, we’ll be talking about being a child’s advocate,
privacy versus concealment models,
-
relationships, support, and affirmation.
In this presentation, and I’m sure that
-
we’ll have more expansive conversations after that,
but it’s just a launching pad for us to,
-
to land in this space together.
-
So, next slide please.
-
So as, Moira already, beautifully said,
-
there’s an explanation here that includes
sex characteristics and the explanations.
-
The list there around what
makes up a person’s primary
-
sex characteristics we all have.
Ans then so, as Moira said, those
-
variations can be considered outside of normal.
And there’s a list at the top there of,
-
of different variations.
Not all of them, but some of them.
-
And the most important thing, I think,
to say is that sex variations are naturally occurring.
-
And many like old religions and indigenous
groups have terms for intersex.
-
So while we might be
using this term which has a
-
medical whakapapa and has been reclaimed
sort of in the 90s by intersex activists,
-
it’s important that we think about all the
different paths that have led us to this point.
-
And I read just the other day there’s
been a recent discovery in archaeology of
-
a 900-year-old Viking in Sweden with
hypospadias. So, you know, I think,
-
this isn’t necessarily a new conversation
but interestingly enough, I think,
-
because of our more recent history
for the past 70 to 100 years of medicalisation,
-
it is a new for a lot of us.
So, it’s great to be here and
-
talking about this and learning together.
And as Moira said terminology,
-
we choose to use the term ‘variations’,
rather than some of the more diagnostic
-
terms, rather than ‘condition’ or ‘disorder’
or ‘defect’ as you might have heard it
-
in healthcare settings or texts.
Next slide please.
-
So, if intersex is a natural occurrence,
what then is normal?
-
The cool thing is within your family or whānau
you get to paint a new world for your tamariki.
-
And I think we could all benefit from
reconsidering what normal is.
-
So, natural variations of sex
characteristics is sitting around
-
1.7 to 4% of the global population.
In Aotearoa, that is over 80,000 people
-
yet we still don’t really know how to talk
about it and maybe who to talk about it with.
-
I think again this is an invitation for us to
create a new normal to reconsider what is normal.
-
And we can do that through connecting,
reading resources, and educating ourselves
-
to upskill yourself and those around you.
And I look at it this way,
-
intersex bodies are a gift that release us
from these impossible constraints
-
of what is considered normal.
Next slide please.
-
So, of course being a parent with
a child with intersex variations,
-
there’s a bit of responsibility there.
And as you know, as a parent or carer
-
of a child, you are your child’s advocate.
This might be overwhelming at times to find
-
the right advice or pathways.
I know that I, as an adult, still
-
find it intimidating in some healthcare settings.
You know, trying to find the right terminology
-
to express what I mean, and all the
health literacy challenges that we come across.
-
But we all deserve supportive
healthcare services.
-
The most important thing I
can suggest is take your time.
-
Unless there’s a medical emergency,
most intersex variations,
-
are not at all life threatening
so feel free to slow down.
-
And as part of that, ask questions.
Ask for a second opinion, especially as your
-
tamariki can’t advocate for themselves.
And get a range of perspectives.
-
So, that might look like connecting with
other parents that might have a child with
-
a variation of sex characteristics or reach out
to a support organisation like Intersex Aotearoa,
-
connect with intersex adults.
Next slide please.
-
And why is it that we don’t know much,
if anything, about these natural variations.
-
So, as I spoke about before, the
medical model has been around since
-
the, the 1950s, but earlier than that,
in the 20s, I think, post war we saw,
-
this, new surgical techniques
influencing some of their approaches.
-
And that approach is based
on what is called a Concealment Model.
-
So this has meant that there’s been
a culture of “you don’t have to talk about it,
-
and we can make variant
bodies not look different”.
-
And what that has left us with is a
harmful culture of shame and silence.
-
And we know that, even those
young people that might not go through
-
surgical interventions experience harm from
the impacts of not talking about these things.
-
So, it’s really important as parents
to understand the complexity of your
-
child’s particular variation, for sure.
It’s also important to define what might
-
be considered to be a genuine health issue
relating to that variation.
-
And then differentiate that between what might
be a social issue and then of course what the
-
immediate needs of your child is.
So, are they happy?
-
Are they healthy?
Not talking about
-
something doesn’t make it go away.
As your child grows, they will naturally
-
try to understand themselves and
how they fit into the world around them.
-
This is easier if you’ve already
found ways to discuss it as a family.
-
And children deserve privacy
as much as adults, right?
-
But how do we untangle those differences
between what privacy is from that shame
-
and secrecy that we might have consciously
or unconsciously absorbed about variant bodies?
-
And it’s kind of clear as the theme of this
presentation, communication is the key.
-
So, talk your tamariki
in a way that works for them.
-
Next slide please.
-
Relationships and communication.
-
One thing we know is a major issue
for intersex young people
-
and whānau is the lack of talking about it.
From the contact that we have with community,
-
we actually know that for lots of people
who have intersex variations
-
they’re only talking about it with their healthcare
professionals or maybe one or two people,
-
could be a friend, could be a family member.
That’s a pretty lonely place to be.
-
So, you know, one thing is to
think of terminology as a tool.
-
So, where I talked about my variation,
-
I’ve got this acronym that I can’t even
pronounce, but, what it is is a tool for me.
-
I can go online and find a support group
that relates to that particular variation.
-
And then another tool that I found is the
umbrella term ‘intersex’ that connected me to
-
this wider umbrella of all these other people
that have been through a similar experience to me.
-
And that can be really powerful, and I would
highly recommend it to families as well.
-
So, maybe what we could
talk about is, is how to get there.
-
Maybe you’re not quite ready for that,
but taking time to practice as a family,
-
the right way to language your
child’s sex variation is a great idea.
-
So, maybe when they’re little start small,
share positive references to different bodies.
-
As they grow more verbal, you might chat about
bodies and how they can be different or the same.
-
And once you get more comfortable,
you could extend that to external networks
-
to model language for your whānau and friends.
And whoever it is that you are talking to,
-
make it happen.
So I also wanted to note, in terms of the
-
shapes on the slide, they’re all the
same size. That’s intentional.
-
So, it’s really important not to prioritise
one mode of support over the other.
-
And you know, often the healthcare
model is the dominant model.
-
So, balancing that, making sure that your
child has access to appropriate healthcare,
-
but at the same time that
you all need,support.
-
That little yellow circle in the middle
is the most important.
-
Next slide please.
-
So, support, as I was just saying, parents and
caregivers you deserve support too.
-
But we need to manage and balance this,
the needs of you and then the needs of the child.
-
And these will, of course, change
and evolve over time.
-
So, understanding what is yours,
what feelings whether they may
-
be those fears or unconscious or conscious bias
or, you know, the absorbed stigma and shame.
-
And getting the support you
need to work through them.
-
But also remembering this
isn’t necessarily about you.
-
Lots of parents we talk to hold guilt, and this can
really shadow the experience for the child.
-
Your child’s needs for support
will change and evolve over time
-
and understanding what they need and what this
support looks like to them is most important.
-
Support for them might be as simple as
you not being so uptight about it.
-
Support for them might
look like you talking to a therapist
-
or finding different therapeutic supports
that help you process your feelings as a parent.
-
Support for them might be they might like to
meet another person with a variation one day.
-
Next slide.
-
Affirmation.
-
So how we talk about bodies
will be mirrored by your child.
-
How do you talk about
your own body within your whānau?
-
Model positive body
language with each other.
-
Your child doesn’t have to have extra
attention or pointed out as ‘special’.
-
Make sure you’re celebrating
all bodies within your family.
-
So, you know, all bodies are beautiful.
All our bodies are different and special.
-
Different is cool.
You are perfect just the way you are.
-
And intersex is taonga.
-
Next slide please.
Oh, look at that. That flew by!
-
So we’re obviously going to
have more discussion now, but
-
I just wanted to take this moment to say
please reach out if you want to connect.
-
If maybe you don’t come up with
a question right now, but think of one,
-
in the next weeks or days or months,
please email us for a chat or,
-
yeah, with any concerns or queries
you have, that’s most welcome. Thanks team.
-
Joey: That was beautiful Jelly.
-
Jelly: Thanks.
-
Joey: Not only are your slides beautiful,
but I feel like
-
your message is very clear and on point.
-
Jelly: Cool. That’s good.
Whew! [laughter].
-
Joey: Yep, We’ve come up with a number of
questions and, yeah, please send them through
-
if you have them as audience members
as well. I wanted to say to Jelly that I really
-
think there’s a similarity in terms of any
whānau or parent or caregiver needing to
-
have a supportive processes for themselves
as part of loving and caring for their child, right.
-
And this is true if you have a kid with
variation sex characteristics, or true if
-
you have a kid that’s doing gender differently,
or true if you have a kid who’s whatever, whatever,
-
it’s so important for our parents and caregivers
and whānau to know that their
-
feelings and their experiences are valid.
And also, what I heard you saying was like
-
find the support that you need and be part
of the range of different options that exist,
-
that, there should be more obviously, but
that exist for parents and whānau and then
-
also young people and adults,
intersex adults as well as young people, like,
-
that you don’t have to expect that this
will be something you hold by yourself.
-
Or something that you can only talk to,
say you’re co-parenting with another person that you
-
get only to talk to that one other person or
only talk to the doctor about or only, you know, then
-
your child might be someone you end up getting
support from about this when actually they’re at
-
the centre of that with their own needs.
Which might be quite different
-
to the parents needs.
And,where do the child’s needs end up?
-
Kind of being pushed to the side maybe,
if the parents needs get prioritised
-
all the time if they don’t get their own path.
You know, it’s like everyone needs
-
their own path.
-
Jelly: Mmmmm.
-
Joey: So, I really appreciated that.
I do a lot as a trans person I
-
do a lot of trying to figure out the
differences and similarities between,
-
being a young person who’s trans or being a young
person who’s intersex and what that’s like.
-
And I think there’s a lot of
similarity there for a lot of us.
-
But it also is quite different.
Like, that concealment, that medical model of
-
concealment, can you tell us any more about that?
Like about the concealment versus privacy?
-
Like, cause you’re not saying
“shout it from the rooftops.
-
Let it all hang out, whatever,
whatever, who cares?”.
-
You’re saying “no, privacy is really important”.
But what’s the difference?
-
Could you say more about a medical model that’s
doing concealment versus what you’re advocating
-
which more about privacy.
-
Jelly: Mmmm. Yeah.
Thanks for that Joey.
-
And I just wanted to say as I was listening
to you speak thinking about,
-
those parallels and differences
we might see in young people.
-
And you know I think, if we’ve got really
young people with intersex variations
-
and then we’ve got a really
concerned parent who’s going “oh I need to
-
really talk about this with my kid”.
And the kid’s like “this is boring…
-
I want to read a book about dinosaurs”.
You know, we might see,
-
some sort of disconnect in stages
as that young person grows older.
-
Maybe their feelings start growing stronger,
and, you know, as the parent might be,
-
more conditioned to their,
-
to their feelings.
And so maybe that’s complementary.
-
But, I think, yeah, talking about
that sort of evolution of,
-
lots of young people don’t really...
like really young people don’t really care.
-
They’re happy.
They’re like,
-
they’re embodied in their experience.
They’re like “cool, I can climb this tree.
-
That’s great, my body does
the thing I need it to do”.
-
You know, and then, and it might be
that those needs change over time.
-
So, I just was reflecting
while you were speaking.
-
But yeah, the idea around, I think,
the responsibility of, for family and carers,
-
around privacy is, again, that’s gonna be evolving
depending on the young persons needs.
-
They might be totally happy to be educating
their friends, whānau and skipping around,
-
being like “my body’s different”.
You know like “that makes me cool”.
-
Or that young person might a year later be like
“I don’t wanna talk about this with anyone.
-
No thanks. I don’t even wanna talk
about it with my parents, ugh”.
-
But I think trusting that you’ll know what to do
at that time is really important.
-
Not getting overwhelmed
with the future.
-
But actually just reacting in relationship
with your young person.
-
And letting them somewhat lead that.
It’s not putting responsibility on them
-
to tell you what to do but for you to be
able to respond to where they’re signalling
-
and how they’re doing that.
And that’s empowerment, I think, where
-
we’ve got a concealment model, a history
of saying “we’re gonna protect your child,
-
by making it not a problem for them.
By erasing the physical
-
reality and also not, not giving them any tools
to language what that difference might be”.
-
And it doesn’t work.
You know, it’s still there.
-
We can remove all those things.
We can not give them any verbal tools.
-
We can do all the operations.
And you know, people talk about
-
doing it at an age where kids can’t remember
but we know that our bodies remember.
-
And so, rather than those concealment models
that I do believe have the best intentions at
-
heart, you know, we’ve got the evidence
to show that actually a model that
-
is about empowerment and bodily autonomy
and informed consent and all those wonderful
-
things that we all want for ourselves.
I think, we now know that we can actually find
-
a balance for all that stuff, without putting
too much responsibility or onus on the young
-
person or the doctor or you know, and really
just thinking about it as a collaborative process.
-
Joey: Mmmm.
-
Jelly: Yeah.
-
Joey: Yeah, and privacy as a thing where you’re
centring the young persons needs at any given
-
moment and knowing it’ll change over time.
So, it’s not saying
-
“never talk about it, always talk about”.
It’s not making rules that are hard and fast
-
like that but saying “ok, I’m gonna respond as
someone who loves this young person to whatever’s
-
going on for them at that time”.
Which seems to be a lot of what
-
parenting, [laughter], my friends who are parents,
that’s generally what I see them doing.
-
Like, struggling to catch up sometimes,
but often being like “ok, I’m in this phase now”,
-
“ok, now, now we’re doing this, alright”.
And trying to always figure out how to,
-
how to be there with their kid.
-
Jelly: Yeah. Hey, nice chucking in
of the ‘be there’.
-
Joey: Be There with your kid [laughter].
-
Jelly: [Laughter] yeah… It’s
-
Joey: Moira… Sorry Jelly. Moira did you have
anything? I saw you nodding at a few points there.
-
Moira: Yeah, nodding at all sorts of points.
I was thinking a bit about the same point
-
in your presentation Jelly about the support needs
of parents and young people. And one question
-
that came to mind is wondering what parents
can do with their feelings [laughter].
-
Like you know we talked about the
importance of not necessarily always
-
bringing that to your kid to have educate
you or to have to kind of
-
talk about it if it’s not the conversation
they’re wanting to have at the time.
-
But, wondering what support options there might be
for parents who are trying to make sense of
-
things or having a bit of a hard time.
-
Jelly: Yeah, I mean, I think what we hear mostly from
parents and carers is really wanting to end that
-
isolation for themselves in terms of, there’s not
heaps of resources just immediately there.
-
You might not get them
from the healthcare setting.
-
They might be able to tell you what the
medical pathways are, but not necessarily like,
-
what those emotional pathways are.
So there are, you know options like,
-
the wonderful world of the internet, and
jumping on, like, there’s a Facebook page,
-
‘Parents of Intersex Children’ I think
it’s called but we can put the link into
-
the chat if you’re not already connected.
And that’s an international group.
-
And then of course there’s
more informal networks,
-
grapevines that I know exist in Aotearoa where
people have... you know, the need’s been
-
so strong to connect with others that
they’ve forged those pathways themselves.
-
And as an organisation we have so many
aspirations to be able to have a future where
-
we’re providing or supporting facilitation of
peer support for young people, parents
-
and whānau, in different variation groups or
the sort of cultural, intersections
-
as well that are so important in Aotearoa.
So, yeah I’m also saying watch this
-
space then because we’re hoping in the next
couple of years to develop that more and more.
-
But immediately, if anyone does need to
connect you can email us and we can,
-
we can make sure that we can
find different ways do that.
-
Even if, I mean, the things that make a
difference, I think, is just like having someone
-
that says, “I get it”.
You know?
-
Joey: Yeah.
-
Jelly: Yeah.
-
Joey: We have a related question, as well,
from the audience which I could pop in
-
here cause it’s a really helpful question.
How can we encourage medical professions to
-
share the details about how people could connect?
So, if you are a parent of an intersex baby or
-
newly diagnosed with a variation, a kid
in your family and you’re looking for support.
-
Obviously, you’ve mentioned the Facebook
group parent support for intersex, that’s great,
-
and you’ve mentioned Intersex Aotearoa,
but apart from that, the support mechanisms
-
themselves or what the organisations are, what can
we do to get medical professionals to recognise
-
the importance of that piece?
-
Jelly: Yeah.
-
Joey: Should we just keep telling them?
[Laughter].
-
Jelly: Yeah, I think yup, it is gonna
have to be a collaborative process.
-
You know, we’ve got a pretty stretched
national healthcare system for sure.
-
But we also deserve better.
We’re not, we don’t get
-
referrals through any formal pathways,
despite sharing information.
-
Starship has done a bit of work with us over
the years, specifically with Mani Bruce Mitchell,
-
and yet still we don’t necessarily
hear from people.
-
And what we do hear is parents, who have had
children in the last couple of months who’ve been
-
told there’s no where for them to go.
So you know, it’s not...
-
there’s sometimes there’s these ideas
that like “oh we did things
-
badly in the past but we’re so much better now”.
Where we actually know that if that’s one of
-
the primary concerns of families is like
“I need to be in touch with other people”, then
-
what a better conduit for that,
but, in healthcare settings.
-
So, yeah, again,
there’s work happening.
-
We’ve got a Budget from our government
that's saying in the next
-
four years there’ll be better training and
resources made for medical professionals.
-
We’ve also got people like Denise Steers who’ve
been making resources for parents and
-
caregivers, also secretly for the doctors to
read, you know, and reflect on as they
-
hopefully use those resources with parents.
And they are full of similar
-
support groups and contacts that we’ve
been talking about here.
-
So we’ll definitely see changes.
They might not be as fast as we’d like them to be,
-
but they are happening.
Yeah.
-
Joey: That’s what I was gonna say too
that I think it’s what can be done as it often
-
feels like a really small steps but actually
cumulatively, we get there with some change,
-
we get there with some movement.
Like, I think Intersex Aotearoa
-
and Te Ngākau Kahukura will be collaborating
on some further webinars particularly for
-
health professionals and medical students,
later this year and early next year.
-
So, you know, it’s not like one or two or three
webinars will fix everything, but the more access
-
we get to talk directly to clinicians,
health professionals, anyone in that healthcare
-
provision space, the more we do share this
kind of message to say actually there’s a lot of,
-
a lot of unmet need for social connection
and for that to be part of this picture.
-
It’s a necessary part.
We’re not saying that the
-
medical stuff is not important as well,
but you can’t just only have that.
-
You gotta have some other aspects
of support and pathways that work
-
for people.
-
Moira: Mmmm.
And some of that,
-
in terms of what doctors need to know is
not necessarily, like it’s not hard,
-
it’s not rocket science or expensive or difficult
necessarily. It’s just being able to bridge
-
conversations with different sectors outside of
the medical establishment, eh, which
-
can be a bit challenging, sometimes.
-
Jelly: Yeah. Yeah, I think you’ve both
brought up sort of that idea of like,
-
there’s been pretty firm silos around,
-
the sort of compartmentalisation of humans.
And you know, we talk about this thing here
-
and then we don’t connect it to this bit
of work that people are doing over here.
-
And I really wanna say that we’ve got
such an interest and passion of,
-
about collaborating and changing
those silos and working together.
-
And we know internationally,
there’s more warmth around
-
medical spaces using multi-disciplinary
teams and making sure that there’s
-
actually therapeutic positions within some of
those departments, so that parents and
-
in that immediate diagnosis time with a
young, with a very young infant for example.
-
Lots of these chats
get really focussed on infants.
-
And that’s where we have to accept that’s
sitting at the moment in terms of where
-
the change will probably happen.
But I do wanna acknowledge that
-
there’s all stages of life where diagnosis
can happen, and everyone deserves support.
-
So there might be around some of
those immediate diagnostic
-
moments that there’ll be better equipped
staff within those healthcare settings.
-
But yeah, also having lots of different approaches,
eh, and not just one is,
-
is gonna be the way
that real change happens.
-
Joey: Mmm.
Mmm.Mmm.
-
I know from doing work with nursing school
programs and then seeing nurses in the
-
workforce as well over a number of years lately,
particularly in relation to trans stuff but kind
-
of also broadly rainbow stuff, that often the
content that’s this kind of level of like,
-
you know, bodies are bodies and humans are
humans and could we all just be a bit more,
-
a bit more chill and a bit more respectful
and a bit more responsive.
-
That has come through on a social level rather
than from a curriculum level and sometimes
-
that means the students are really leading the
discussion and leading the way and the lecturers
-
are trying to catch up.
Sometimes they’re onto it,
-
but sometimes they’re like “oh right,
that’s a different model of,
-
talking about bodies and talking about humans”
than they had when they were being trained.
-
And that’s hopeful, you know, cause even if it’s
hard for us to get in and make the curriculum
-
better which a lot of us are working on and
trying to do as part of this whole big picture,
-
there’s still a shift happening cause when the
shift happens in community
-
and in social context, that comes in.
It’s just maybe slower than we would
-
like, but it’s still valid and helpful.
-
Jelly: Yeah absolutely.
And best of luck to students coming into
-
those cultures that, you know, might still be stuck
in different generational perspectives.
-
And we know those spaces
can be really hierarchical.
-
So, yeah. But again, yeah,
I totally agree there’s hope.
-
There’s definitely hope there.
Yeah.
-
Joey: I liked what you said about
wanting parents to get strongly a sense of,
-
like feel free to slow down.
A sense of take some space and some
-
time when you’re making decisions particularly
about medical or healthcare stuff for your child.
-
Like, sure if there is some kind of medical
emergency then, and my understanding is
-
that it might’ve been framed as a medical
emergency in some contexts which wasn’t true.
-
So, then of course that’s really a stressful
place to be as a parent if you are being
-
given the impression that this something
that needs to be immediately fixed rather
-
than actually something you could take time
to do more research and have more conversations
-
and sit with your own process and talk to other
whānau who you’re close to and feel trust with.
-
Is there anything you wanted to add about
that kind of ‘take your time’ message?
-
Jelly: Yeah, it sounds simply, eh, but I think,
that’s been hard won by those of us that
-
didn’t have that opportunity, or our parents
didn’t have the opportunity.
-
Or like there was no access to any
other alternative or resources.
-
So yeah, it’s, getting a diagnosis whatever
age your child is is scary and overwhelming.
-
And so, if something’s being framed in a
health context, and it’s got that,
-
it’s got that weight to it but someone’s offering
this solution at the same time, of course,
-
what an opportunity, thank God.
You know, and so, it’s really,
-
it’s difficult cause there’s... I have no sense of blame
on anyone put in that position of having
-
to make that call when of course that’s with
the intention of care and love and the best…
-
Joey: Absolutely.
-
Jelly: And some of that health literacy stuff
we talk about is, it’s resisting that
-
intimidation of that moment where
someone’s using language that you don’t
-
quite understand but you’re in a hospital so it
must be bad [laughter], you know, of actually
-
just saying, you know, “thanks so much.
I’m gonna take some time and go and talk
-
to some people, can you tell me at this
immediate moment whether my child’s at risk
-
of harm?” And if it’s a no, then great.
Let's just go and take
-
a breath, you know.
Stand in the carpark.
-
Count to ten whatever it is that you need to do.
And I think we’re hearing more and more,
-
that... because we’re hearing from parents
who’ve said “oh I got told this horrible
-
thing but I’m over here and I found you and
I found other parents”, you know, they’re
-
showing us that there is more information
out there for people to be like “hey,
-
I think I’ve heard about this and maybe it’s not
so bad and we should go do some more research”.
-
Yeah.
-
Joey: Mmmm. We're amazingly almost at the point
where we’re gonna be doing our wrap up thoughts
-
and pointing to all of the resources
that we want people to connect with.
-
I thought I would let Moira have a moment,
share any thought, comment, question
-
if you feel like it at this time?
-
Moira: I’m not sure if it’s a question or a thought.
I’ll start talking and
-
we’ll see where we get to [laughter].
But I was just reflecting on your,
-
you had a point in your slides Jelly, about
your child is a taonga and I know that had a,
-
you developed a resource for parents a while
ago that had that same title as well.
-
And I really love that sense of like,
a lot of what we’re talking about is,
-
support or some sense of like difficulty or stress
around your child being born with...
-
slightly different to how you might’ve expected.
But actually, it’s not just about
-
you know, support around a problem, right.
It’s also about how do we celebrate,
-
difference and how do we celebrate our
young people for who they are and, yeah,
-
I really love that sense of this being a
taonga, of this being something really special.
-
And it’s, yeah, a difference but not
necessarily a problem.
-
I guess I wanted to shout out in terms of
like you talked about the internet as
-
a source of support and things as well.
I feel like one of the things
-
I found really interesting and helpful is
actually YouTube and Instagram in terms
-
of people sharing their own personal stories
and there’s a lot of
-
a lot of intersex people, a lot of people coming
from different perspectives who are kind
-
of sharing about their life in a way that
just makes sort of possibility
-
more visible for kids growing up.
You know, I think being able to see
-
different examples of what people
look like and how people live
-
as you grow up can be a
really positive part of that as well.
-
I’m not sure if that’s a question.
That’s just a general reflection
-
I guess too, is to not to forget that,
as we’re talking about this that we’re not,
-
we’re not talking about a problem
that you need to solve.
-
We’re talking about young people who are
an important, beautiful part of your family
-
who we wanna celebrate.
-
Jelly: Thanks Moira. That’s so nice, and yeah, it’s
one of the more sort of challenging things of this
-
work is we spend so much time sort of rallying
against the difficulties of the systems.
-
But don’t always have the time to actually just
do that celebration stuff that,
-
that joy that difference brings.
And I genuinely think that
-
that people with intersex variations are a gift.
And we actually open up
-
infinite possibilities of embodiment.
But also, the perspective that gets you
-
you know, in like
“I’m great! I’m ok! I love my body!”.
-
You know, and you can have that
same trust for your child.
-
And it’s so nice to land on this point,
-
as we sort of are thinking about
closing up this because
-
so much of the way that caring for someone else
can manifest as in concern,
-
and that's so valid.
But when that sort of
-
gets twisted in protection and gets all tight,
that can hinder
-
some of that development stuff
that we want for our young people.
-
So, I think, yeah, just trusting that they’re
gonna be ok and you’re
-
working on this together as you go.
You don’t have to be an expert.
-
You don’t have to know everything but,
yeah, like Moira said, there’s heaps of really great,
-
and beautiful people out there sharing just
their stories and their lives and
-
their journey and learnings.
Which is so generous right?
-
And there’s so much evidence of the abundance
of joy and, and some of that affirmative
-
treasure stuff that we all need and love.
-
Joey: Some that treasure is very located
in you and around you, Jelly.
-
I happened to notice.
So, I strongly appreciate your
-
you know, I know you’re bringing a lot of
people with you, it’s not you individually.
-
The whole thing, so, thank you. Thank you in
particular and also thanks to everyone at Intersex
-
Aotearoa who’s feeding into all of this work.
You are doing massive amounts of work
-
and we have huge amounts of respect
for what you have been doing.
-
And look forward to all these ongoing
collaborations like we’ve been talking about.
-
That does feel like a good place
to wrap up on, right?
-
Jelly: Yeah, and I’ll just say, yeah, awhi to all the
intersex people who have taught me so much and
-
shared their stories with me and parents too.
Definitely on the shoulders of giants as they say.
-
Joey: Mmmm. Possibilities, right?
Feeling like it’s less
-
about having the exact answer, and more
about seeing that there are possibilities,
-
that there have been possibilities
and there are possibilities in the future.
-
Thank you.
So, I think
-
Jono will be posting into the chat some links and
context for you to get in touch with us.
-
You can do that through our website, Te Ngākau
Kahukura website, or you can do that through the
-
Be There website.
You can also,
-
contact Jelly and Intersex Aotearoa more broadly
on the info email that’s in the chat.
-
We also will be in touch with an
evaluation survey about this webinar.
-
And it is always really heartening for us
if anybody takes a moment, even just to say,
-
“thanks I enjoyed that”.
You know, you can give us
-
really indepth feedback if you’d like.
You can go as hard as you like with your
-
evaluation of our educational material.
But also just feel free to respond
-
and say as much or as little as you’d like
in the evaluation survey that will
-
go out to all of the people
who've registered for this.
-
Any other resources that I was gonna mention?
There’s a whole lot of links up on the
-
Be There website which I know
you’ve been sent the link to.
-
I would like to maybe close
before Moira closes with karakia.
-
I think the whakataukī that we
were gifted from
-
Dr. Elizabeth Kerekere to Te Ngākau Kahukura,
is really extremely relevant and
-
I believe that Elizabeth was with us today
in the audience, and sending out love
-
to you, Elizabeth, for your support in our mahi.
The whakataukī is kia puāwai, me puāwai.
-
And I’m thinking this is pretty broad for our
young people, rainbow people, intersex people,
-
to thrive, we must grow, we must do the work.
And that’s what this webinar is about too.
-
We are doing the work and we are hoping
that we can all do the work together
-
and then the work is not so overwhelming
and terrifying as it sometimes can feel.
-
Ok, I will stop talking.
I will hand to Moira to close.
-
Jelly, do you have any last thoughts?
-
Jelly: Just thanks.
Always awesome
-
talking with you both and thanks to
everyone that came along today or will watch
-
this in the future.
-
Moira: Kia ora. Well, thanks Jelly for everything
you’ve shared, your wisdom.
-
Thanks Joey, thanks Elizabeth,
thanks Jono in the chat.
-
I’ll share my screen.
We’ve just got a couple of slides to share.
-
Some links around extra resources
if you want to read or listen to or watch
-
something else following on from this.
The Be There website itself has a
-
page up there of resources for supporting
intersex children and young people including
-
that one that I mentioned that Jelly developed
a couple of years ago, ‘Your Child is a Taonga’.
-
And as part of the Be There campaign or project
as well, also running a
-
series of workshops for kind of more broadly
parents and whānau of rainbow young people.
-
Those are more interactive.
So, there’s like 20 people in each
-
session and there’ll be more of a chance for
people to share more of their own
-
story and ask questions of the facilitators, the
team from InsideOUT will be running those ones.
-
So, if you’re interested in those
and available on those dates,
-
they’re up on the screen now as well.
But, that’s all from me.
-
Just thank you so much everybody for being
here and for those of you who might watch
-
this in the future as a recording.
And I’ll just close us as we opened
-
with a karakia.
Me karakia tātou.
-
Unuhia, unuhia,
Unuhia ki te uru tapu nui
-
Kia wātea, kia māmā
Te ngākau, te tinana
-
Te wairua i te ara takatā
Koia rā e rongo
-
Whakairia ake ki runga
Kia tina, tina
-
Hui ē, taiki ē
-
Kia ora!
Thanks everybody.