-
- Imagine being a professional pilot
-
with responsibility
for hundreds of passengers
-
being told how to fly your aircraft
-
by desperate, uninformed madmen.
-
And knowing that if
you do what they ask,
-
it will kill you and everyone on board.
-
How would you react?
-
Stay tuned.
-
It all started on
a beautiful autumn morning
-
in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia,
-
where Ethiopian Airlines
Flight 961 was scheduled
-
as a short hop over to Nairobi in Kenya,
-
and then it was scheduled
-
to continue onwards towards
Brassaville, Lagos and Abidjan.
-
On November 23rd 1996,
the aircraft scheduled
-
to operate this route
was a Boeing 767-260ER
-
with registration Echo
Tango Alpha India Zulu.
-
And this is a wide-body
twin-engine airliner
-
which had joined Ethiopian
Airlines back in 1987.
-
It was powered by two Pratt & Whitney
JT9D turbofan engines
-
and configured with
18 business class seats
-
and 174 in economy.
-
So in total, the aircraft
could carry a maximum
-
of 192 passengers,
though it wasn't scheduled
-
to be full on this particular day.
-
But the fact that this
767 was a long-haul aircraft,
-
often used for much
longer routes than this,
-
will come to play an
important part of this story.
-
Very early in the morning,
the ground crew had been advised
-
by the dispatcher to fuel the aircraft up
-
with about three and
a half hours worth of fuel.
-
That should have been
more than enough
-
for the first roughly two-hour
long flight over to Nairobi,
-
that's even when counting
things like potential holding fuel
-
and a diversion to their alternate airport.
-
But obviously this was also way less
-
than the maximum fuel quantity
-
that the 767 could hold,
-
which would give it
a range of around 11 hours.
-
And that's worth keeping in mind.
-
Anyway, as the boarding started,
-
the flight had been booked
with 163 passengers,
-
so if we include the 12 crew members,
-
the total figure of souls on board
-
would eventually become 175.
-
Most of the passengers
were of Ethiopian origin,
-
but there were also travelers
from 35 different countries,
-
including tourists,
-
business class travelers
and foreign nationals working
-
with NGOs and embassies in the region.
-
So as always, in modern aviation,
-
this was a mix of lives,
-
all brought together by circumstance.
-
Now the flight crew
that had been scheduled
-
to fly together on this particular day
-
was both seasoned professionals.
-
In command was Captain Leul Abate,
-
one of the most experienced pilots
-
in Ethiopian Airlines at the time.
-
He was 42 years old and
had amassed more than 11,500 hours
-
of total flying time,
-
including over 4,000
hours on the Boeing 767
-
that they were now about to operate.
-
His first officer,
-
Yonas Mekuria, was 34 years
old and was also well qualified.
-
He had slightly more
than 6,000 hours in total,
-
including nearly 2,500 on the type,
-
and together, they formed
-
a skilled and respected cockpit team.
-
In fact, Captain Leul was considered one
-
of the airline's top instructors
-
and had even been training
pilots over in the United States.
-
The cabin crew consisted
of 10 flight attendants,
-
most of whom were young,
fluent in multiple languages
-
and trained in hospitality
-
and in emergency evacuation procedures.
-
And they carried out their duties
-
that morning as they always did,
-
welcoming passengers,
helping with boarding
-
and completing the standard
pre-departure safety checks.
-
The pre-flight preparation
-
in the crew room
earlier had been standard,
-
with no particular threats noted,
-
so the crew had eventually
just walked straight out
-
to the aircraft and
started preparing it for departure.
-
And while they were doing that,
-
the passengers had all gone through
-
the standard security checks,
-
where nothing strange or
suspicious had been found.
-
The pushback from the gate at Bole
International Airport occurred
-
just before 8 o'clock local time,
-
and the weather conditions were great,
-
with only light winds
and a good visibility.
-
The aircraft taxied out
with the captain at the controls,
-
and at time 08:09,
the Bole Tower Controller,
-
cleared Flight 961 for
takeoff from Runway 07R.
-
The mighty aircraft soon
soared into the sky,
-
beginning its short southward
journey down towards Nairobi.
-
Everything was looking great so far.
-
The pilots were initially cleared
-
to climb to 35,000 feet,
or flight level 350,
-
following the standard
international airway,
-
tracking south over
The Great Rift Valley.
-
The early part of the flight
was completely uneventful,
-
with the pilots in the cockpit setting up
-
their navigational systems,
-
logging flight times and
doing all of the routine tasks
-
that we pilots do on every flight.
-
But that feeling of normality
would very soon change.
-
15 minutes after takeoff
at time 08:24,
-
the drink service began in the cabin,
-
with the passengers settling in,
-
some dozing off, others reading
or enjoying the view
-
of the rugged Ethiopian
landscape below them.
-
But seated in the economy cabin,
-
were three men who were now
looking around impatiently,
-
and they had no intention
of ever making it to Nairobi.
-
At time 08:29, as the aircraft
leveled off at 39,000 feet,
-
their final cruising level,
-
these three men, all Ethiopian citizens,
-
suddenly made their move.
-
They stood up from their seats
at the rear of the aircraft,
-
with one of them shouting,
-
"Everybody should be seated,
I have a bomb!"
-
And they then quickly moved up
-
through the business class
cabin towards the cockpit.
-
These were not trained hijackers.
-
In fact, it would later turn out
that they had no ties
-
to any organized militant
group or similar at all.
-
They were just
three desperate individuals,
-
which actually makes them
-
quite unusual hijackers for the time.
-
They all spoke primarily in French,
-
even though French is not
widely spoken in Ethiopia,
-
and it seems like they
had no clear motive either.
-
Even today, it's not clear if their goal
-
was to escape political persecution,
-
starting a new life,
-
or just to do something huge
and eye-catching
-
that would make them famous.
-
And when we're on
the subject of intent,
-
over the last few weeks,
-
I have noticed a completely new trend.
-
I wonder if you've seen it as well.
-
Several of my friends and contacts
-
have started sending me what
looks like official documents,
-
including interim reports
about recent serious accidents.
-
While these look really
convincing at a first glance,
-
so convincing actually
-
that industry professionals
are sharing them,
-
you don't have to
dig very deep to realize
-
that they are AI generated,
-
and you can see that
due to unrealistic dates,
-
made-up technical information, et cetera.
-
I don't know the full intent
behind these fake documents,
-
but you can be absolutely sure
-
that they are a goldmine
for hackers and bad actors
-
out to steal your information.
-
And that's exactly why my team
-
and I rely so much on today's sponsor,
-
NordVPN.
-
Nord is the only VPN app
to receive official certification
-
from independent cybersecurity testers,
-
and their Threat Protection Pro feature
-
blocked over 314 million scams
-
in the first three months of 2025 alone.
-
It will automatically
scan files for malware,
-
removing infected ones
before they can cause any harm,
-
and all of that runs in the background,
-
so you don't even need
to be connected to a VPN
-
for all of these safety perks to work.
-
Right now, you can
get four extra months free
-
when you sign up for the two-year deal
-
using this QR code, or by going
to nordvpn.com/pilot.
-
And remember that with Nord's
30-day money back guarantee,
-
there is absolutely zero
risk in trying them out.
-
Thank you, Nord.
-
Now let's get back to those hijackers.
-
Anyway, without any visible weapons,
-
the hijackers had soon made
-
their way into the front galley,
-
where they now burst into the cockpit,
-
which, remember, had no
security barriers at the time,
-
and it seems like surprise and speed
-
were their greatest
assets to achieve this.
-
As soon as they entered the cockpit,
-
they screamed out
that there were 11 of them,
-
likely to make the pilots
worry about something
-
known as sleepers in the cabin.
-
These are silent
members of a hijacking team
-
who doesn't make
themselves known at first,
-
in order to provide help
to the main hijackers
-
or stop potential
passenger rebellions.
-
But in this case,
there were no indications
-
that there were any more hijackers
-
than just these three
initial ones on board.
-
Anyway, the first thing they then did
-
was to beat up first officer Yonas
-
and then drag him out of the cockpit.
-
They then quickly grabbed
an on-board fire extinguisher
-
as well as the crash axe
which is stored in the cockpit,
-
thereby likely accessing
their first real weapons.
-
Captain Leul Abate was now
left alone at the controls,
-
and at this point, his assumption
-
was that the hijackers
would just tell him where to go,
-
as that was normally what happened
-
in hijack situations back then.
-
The Sudan, Egypt and
the entire Arab Peninsula
-
was within range
and could safely be flown to,
-
so that's what the captain expected.
-
But unfortunately,
-
that was not what
these hijackers had in mind.
-
No instead, they now issued a demand
-
so outrageous that Captain Leul
-
initially didn't even believe it.
-
"Fly to Australia," they shouted,
-
being completely
and terrifyingly serious.
-
This was obviously complete lunacy.
-
Like I explained before,
-
the pilots had requested fuel amounting
-
to around three and a half hours
-
for their flight over to Nairobi,
-
which was entirely appropriate
for such a short route,
-
but nowhere near sufficient
-
to cross thousands of miles of ocean.
-
So knowing this, Captain
Leul now tried his best
-
to stay calm and began to try
-
to educate the hijackers on the difference
-
between the aircraft's maximum
range and its actual range,
-
based on the amount of fuel loaded.
-
He even showed them
the fuel quantity indicators,
-
and hoped that this
would make sense to them,
-
but the hijackers were obviously
convinced that he was lying.
-
As proof, one of them
triumphantly pulled out a copy
-
of Ethiopian Airlines' inflight magazine,
-
which listed the 767's maximum
range as well over 11 hours.
-
And based on that, they insisted
-
that this proved that
the plane could make it.
-
The hijackers exclaimed
that they would blow up
-
the plane if Leul didn't comply,
-
and then showed him a device
that they claimed was a bomb,
-
but appeared to be just a large glove.
-
So Captain Leul seriously doubted
-
that the hijackers actually had a bomb,
-
but he also knew that they
were ready to resort to violence,
-
since they had already
beat up his first officer.
-
Now, they also had a
fire axe and a fire extinguisher
-
which they could use to bludgeon people,
-
so the threat of violence
was now very, very real.
-
On top of that, it was
also obvious that he was dealing
-
with potentially deranged individuals,
-
and if they decided to also take him out,
-
well then there would be
no one left to fly the plane.
-
So instead of antagonizing them,
-
Captain Leul now elected to just try
-
and keep them talking,
-
buying himself and the
crew some more time.
-
This was a decision
based on his own experience,
-
as, incredibly, this was not the first time
-
that he had been hijacked.
-
It was actually the third time.
-
He had previously been forced to fly to Sudan,
-
and in another hijacking to Kenya,
-
so I guess this was as routine to him
-
as something like this could ever be.
-
Now in both of those cases,
-
complying with the hijackers
-
and taking them where they were demanded,
-
had ended with the plane landing safely,
-
an experience that definitely formed
Captain Leul's perspective
-
that the best way to deal with hijackers
-
was to calmly accept their demands.
-
So he now contacted air traffic control
-
and told them that the aircraft
would be deviating,
-
and he then added that
the plane had been hijacked
-
and that he had been
demanded to fly to Australia.
-
Now at that time, the plane's
transponder was set to 2000,
-
and according to the report,
that never changed,
-
but generally speaking
hijackings forms part
-
of the three different situations
-
when a specific emergency code
-
should be entered into the transponder
-
to automatically alert air traffic control
-
about what is going on.
-
Those codes include 7700
for a general emergency,
-
7600 for a loss of communication,
and 7500 for hijacking.
-
But by now telling
air traffic control outright,
-
he likely achieved that same goal.
-
In any case, Captain Leul
-
was now faced with
an impossible choice.
-
If he complied with
the hijackers' demands,
-
they would definitely run out of fuel
-
in the middle of the Indian Ocean.
-
And since he was alone
against these three assailants,
-
fighting back could
pose another deadly risk
-
for everyone on board.
-
So he now had to come up
-
with some way of turning
the aircraft out over the ocean
-
to convince the anxious hijackers
-
that he was doing as he was told,
-
while still staying in range of land
-
and some type of alternates.
-
Luckily it seemed like
the hijackers were not familiar
-
with the cockpit
and its navigational display,
-
so it was likely that the only way
-
that they could determine
-
if he was going towards Australia or not
-
was if they could see water
out through the cockpit windows.
-
So that led Captain
Leul to a fateful decision,
-
one that would eventually mean
-
the difference between life and death
-
for some of the people on board.
-
He now began a
gradual turn towards the south,
-
still following the coast, flying southeast,
-
while still also maintaining
-
the appearance of
complying with their demands.
-
As this was happening,
two of the hijackers returned out
-
to the passenger cabin,
-
leaving their leader seated
in the first officer's chair.
-
The ones who had left
then commanded a flight attendant
-
to show them how the PA system worked,
-
followed by them making
announcements in both English,
-
French and Amharic,
telling the passengers
-
that they had control of the plane
-
and would be demanding a landing.
-
But they never told the passengers
-
that the place where they wanted
-
to land happened to be Australia.
-
Back in the cockpit,
-
the lead hijacker
now ordered Captain Leul
-
to contact the
Ethiopian Airlines sales office
-
in Australia using a phone number
-
that he had found
listed in the timetable.
-
And when the captain responded
-
that there was no phone on board,
-
this really angered the hijacker,
-
who threatened to beat him
up if he continued lying.
-
Captain Leul eventually
managed to convince him
-
that he should
instead relay any message
-
to Australia via air traffic control,
-
and the hijacker agreed,
-
which allowed Captain Leul
-
to now call up Nairobi Centre.
-
This control centre had luckily
-
already been alerted about the hijacking
-
by the controllers in Ethiopia,
-
which is otherwise where
that transponder code
-
would have come in handy,
-
as everyone in the aviation knows
-
what the code 7500 means.
-
But anyway, the captain
now calmly called up,
-
identifying the flight and asked
-
for help to relay a message
-
over to that number in Australia,
-
and he also now announced
that they would be flying
-
to Australia by a
point called Oscar Victor,
-
which must have really puzzled
-
the controller on the other end.
-
He now responded
by asking for confirmation
-
of that number that they wanted to call,
-
which Captain Leul repeated,
-
and the captain then also
added an important detail.
-
They were now cruising at 39,000 feet,
-
but had only two hours of fuel left,
-
which was obviously not
nearly enough to reach Australia.
-
When subsequently asked
by the controller
-
to confirm whether
he really intended to go there,
-
Captain Leul admitted the obvious.
-
It wasn't possible,
they didn't have the fuel,
-
so if things didn't change,
-
they would have to ditch in the ocean.
-
Captain Leul then also made a decision
-
to switch on the cockpit speaker
-
so that the hijacker could
hear this conversation,
-
thinking that that might perhaps
-
bring them to their senses.
-
So he then called
the controller back again,
-
saying, "Okay, I
just wanted our hijackers
-
to hear what you're communicating,
-
and if you have anything to say,
go ahead and tell them."
-
The controller now aware
of his new audience said
-
as plainly as he possibly could,
-
"Okay, I'm advising you
that with two hours of fuel,
-
you will be unable
to reach your destination,
-
and probably you will have
to land on the water.
-
The best solution is for
you to land in Mombasa.
-
Go ahead."
-
But in the cockpit, this little gambit
-
unfortunately hadn't worked.
-
In fact, it just
angered the hijacker further,
-
so Captain Leul now told Nairobi,
-
"Okay, they say they don't want to talk.
-
They are not willing
to negotiate on any terms."
-
And to that,
the controller just responded,
-
"Roger, Roger, Ethiopian 961,
-
Check Australia is more than six hours flight,
-
and you have only two hours fuel.
-
You will most probably
ditch in the ocean.
-
Why don't you land in Mombasa
and pick up some more fuel?"
-
But there was nothing really
that the captain could do here.
-
He just responded,
-
"There is no alternate other
than Australia, no alternate."
-
The controller now realizing
there was nothing more
-
that he could do, simply replied,
-
advise us when you expect
to reach Australia, ETA Australia."
-
And then perhaps in
a moment of frustration
-
or in a futile attempt to get through
-
to the criminal standing behind the captain,
-
the controller also added,
"Confirm they are ready
-
to land in the ocean and drown?"
-
Now, rather than bringing
the hijackers to their senses here,
-
this last sentence just
acted as the last straw,
-
and the lead hijacker decided
-
that he had now had enough.
-
He violently ripped
off Leul's sunglasses
-
and headset, finally ending
Flight 961's communication
-
with air traffic control.
-
Nairobi's center would keep trying
-
to contact Ethiopia 961,
-
but they would never
hear from the flight again.
-
Back in the cockpit, the
hijacker had now grown frustrated
-
with the captain's attempts
to resolve the situation,
-
and once again he just ordered
him to turn out to sea.
-
Now, we pilots are trained
to constantly use our training
-
to evaluate and re-evaluate
-
any situation we find ourselves in,
-
and that means basically put our feelings
-
and emotions to the side
and just act according
-
to what facts training and
experience tells us to do.
-
In order to do that,
-
we often follow decision-making models
-
like FORDEC or PIOSEE,
-
which helps us to structure
our decision-making
-
and clearly identify the problem,
gather information,
-
choose and execute the
best option and then evaluate.
-
But that's, of course,
impossible when dealing
-
with a commanding force
who isn't backed up
-
by any knowledge, reason
or common sense, only violence.
-
These hijackers had chosen
to operate from a place of fear
-
and never from a place of facts.
-
And in a situation like that,
even the most professional pilots
-
would not be able to
make much of a difference, really.
-
But that didn't stop
Captain Leul from trying.
-
Now before we go on,
-
let me just stop here for
a second to point something out.
-
Even though this is a horrible example
-
of a crime being committed,
-
I cannot keep myself
from seeing parallels
-
to the world we live in today,
-
where far too many of us
make important decisions
-
based on rumors, trends
-
or conspiracy theories
instead of facts.
-
Actually, this cockpit is
almost a perfect reflection
-
of where the scientific
community finds itself today,
-
being told what to do
by politicians with no background
-
in science or knowledge of their field.
-
As pilots, we live and die
based on the rules of physics,
-
decades of experience
-
and correct application
of leadership and procedures,
-
so we operate in a world
-
where it's still all
about doing what is right,
-
not just follow who is speaking.
-
And I think that's one of the reasons
-
why I love this industry so much.
-
Anyway, Flight 961 had now flown past
-
its original destination and
was still heading south.
-
When they passed abeam
Dar es Salaam in Tanzania,
-
the hijackers asked the captain
-
to again try and contact Australia,
-
which gave him a rare chance
to contact his company frequency
-
and advise them about their position,
-
heading and fuel endurance.
-
That was information
that could be critical
-
for determining their final crash site
-
if it would come to that.
-
But when the hijackers realized
-
that this was what the
captain was now doing,
-
he again snapped the
captain's headset off
-
and ordered him to start
-
flying away from the coastline,
-
out towards the vast blue
void of the Indian Ocean
-
and an almost certain death.
-
Captain Leul did as he was told.
-
He didn't really have a choice at this point,
-
but he didn't point the nose
just randomly out to sea.
-
Instead, he started heading southeast
-
towards the tiny
island nation of Comoros.
-
He had personally never
heard of this country before,
-
but he found the island chain in
a map that he had with him.
-
And crucially, the Comoros
capital city of Moroni
-
is home to Prince Said Ibrahim
International Airport,
-
which has a single 2,900
meter long runway, more than
-
long enough to land the Boeing 767.
-
And that could possibly be
-
the captain's last chance
-
to perform a controlled
landing somewhere.
-
But for now, the flight just continued,
-
slowly depleting its
last hours of fuel.
-
From about three hours into the flight,
-
we have the transcript from
the cockpit voice recorder,
-
who back then only saved
the last 30 minutes of flight.
-
The recording starts by
capturing a truly chaotic scene,
-
with hijackers who had,
by now stolen a couple
-
of bottles of whiskey
from the forward galley
-
all sounding drunk, and
with the lead hijacker
-
still in the first officer's chair
-
and another one standing
in the cockpit with them.
-
The third was still out in the cabin,
-
on guard for attempts
by the passengers
-
to try to retake the cockpit.
-
Captain Leul now
asked the lead hijacker
-
if he could at least be allowed
-
to tell the passengers
about what was going on,
-
but the answer from the hijacker
-
was short and concise, "No."
-
At this point, with
less than 30 minutes left
-
of fuel on board,
-
Captain Leul knew
that they were unlikely
-
to be able to land safely,
-
and he had therefore decided
that the next best option
-
would be to prepare his passengers
-
for a landing in the sea,
known as a ditching.
-
Under normal circumstances,
-
preparation for that would have been done
-
with the help of his cabin crew,
-
who would go through
-
what's known as time-
available emergency drills,
-
explaining brace positions,
-
emergency exits and positions of rafts,
-
as well as assigning buddy systems
-
for children or passengers
with special needs.
-
But now, none of that was being done.
-
He therefore calmly
warned the hijackers
-
that the situation was starting
-
to become out of his control,
-
and when it did, the plane
was likely going to crash.
-
One of the hijackers, angered by this,
-
asked if he wanted to die,
-
but to that, the captain
just calmly replied
-
that death was inevitable at this point.
-
The hijacker then implied
-
that they had made a promise
-
to take the situation
as far as it could go,
-
and now there was no turning back.
-
A chilling admission of their cause
-
now possibly turning
into a suicide mission.
-
A few minutes later,
the hijackers also decided
-
to remind Captain Leul
of the threat they posed
-
when the lead hijacker
looked at him and said,
-
"Don't worry, the axe is with me."
-
And he then, bizarrely,
attempted to lighten the mood
-
by offering Captain Leul
a drink of the whiskey they had,
-
calling it a bribe to calm his nerves.
-
When Captain Leul refused,
saying that there wasn't time
-
and asking to be left alone,
-
the hijacker just insisted
on getting him to drink.
-
But at that moment, the
low fuel pressure warning activated,
-
with its chilling chime
repeatedly now filling the cockpit,
-
telling anyone with
knowledge that the pumps
-
now had no more fuel to pump.
-
Seconds later, the inevitable happened,
-
as the right engine exhausted
its last few drops of fuel
-
and then just flamed out.
-
Now, a Boeing 767 at 39,000 feet
-
cannot maintain that altitude
with only one remaining engine.
-
It would either start
losing speed until it stalls,
-
or start descending down
-
towards an altitude
-
that can be maintained
with only one engine,
-
something known as a single-
engine service ceiling,
-
which is typically around 25,000 feet.
-
Captain Leul, of course, knew this,
-
and therefore, soon initiated the descent,
-
but the hijackers,
who had previously told them
-
to not go below 39,000 feet
under any circumstance,
-
now would not accept this reality.
-
Drunk, incoherent,
-
and with a childish
understanding of flight,
-
the lead hijacker
instead began to panic,
-
thinking that the captain
was now disobeying him.
-
He pointed to the altimeter
and exclaimed, "It is less!"
-
Captain Leul asked,
"What is less?"
-
And the hijacker exclaimed,
"The altitude!"
-
Trying to bring some
sense to the situation,
-
Captain Leul explained
that it will descend by itself,
-
"I am not making it descend."
-
He then pointed to the engine flame out
-
and master caution warnings,
-
and he told them,
"As the engine stops, it descends.
-
Whether you like it
or not, it is descending."
-
But the hijacker only
responded by saying,
-
"Well, we will see about that."
-
By now it was clear
that the situation was unraveling,
-
and the captain was
losing his tenuous grip.
-
The plane was now
almost completely out of fuel
-
with one of its engines already flamed out,
-
so the hijackers, now perhaps realizing
-
the gravity of what was happening,
-
briefly stepped out
of the cockpit to confer
-
amongst themselves about what to do.
-
Seizing this rare moment,
-
Captain Leul made
a final desperate announcement
-
to the passengers
with his voice broadcasting
-
over the cabin PA,
-
"Ladies and gentlemen,
this is your pilot.
-
We have run out of fuel,
-
and we are losing
one engine at this time.
-
We are expecting a crash landing,
-
and that is all I have to say.
-
We have already lost one engine,
-
and I ask all passengers
to react to the hijackers.
-
Thank you."
-
This was an extraordinary
act of courage.
-
By encouraging the passengers
to resist the hijackers,
-
Captain Leul was now
knowingly putting himself
-
at greater personal risk,
-
but it had become clear that unless
-
the hijackers could be subdued,
-
he wouldn't be permitted
to make an emergency landing,
-
so this was really
all that he could do.
-
But tragically, his call to action
-
didn't have the desired effect.
-
A few brave passengers
actually started urging others
-
to help them in rising up
and taking control back,
-
but their efforts were met
-
with a lot of hesitation and fear.
-
Some passengers worried
-
that any attempt
to overpower the hijackers
-
might provoke them
into detonating a bomb,
-
or even crashing the plane.
-
At this point, a lot of passengers
still clung to the belief
-
that they would still land safely.
-
There had even been some discussions
-
among the passengers about
opening the emergency exits
-
as soon as the plane touched down,
-
and they continued
to believe in that plan,
-
unaware that a water landing
at sea was now almost certain.
-
But there was also another problem.
-
The captain's announcement
had only been made in English,
-
and with passengers
-
from more than 30 different
countries on board,
-
it is likely that many just
simply didn't understand it.
-
So the moment passed,
-
the uprising fizzled
before it could even begin,
-
and the hijackers soon
stormed back into the cockpit,
-
striking the microphone
from the captain's hand.
-
In the cockpit of
this descending Boeing 767,
-
the tension had now
reached a breaking point.
-
The aircraft had
already lost one engine,
-
and now another repetitive
beeping could be heard,
-
a warning that the fuel pressure
-
was now also dropping
in the second engine,
-
and the captain knew
what would come next.
-
But the hijackers
still remained in denial,
-
clinging to their fantasy
about reaching Australia.
-
It is descending, the
lead hijacker pointed out again,
-
as though it was due
to some external phenomenon.
-
He then grasped for the controls,
-
suddenly pulling on
the yoke hard enough
-
to disconnect the autopilot,
-
and he soon also
reached for the thrust levers
-
and began pulling on the reversers,
-
which luckily couldn't be activated
-
since they were still clearly airborne.
-
Behind the cockpit, the
cockpit voice recorder captured
-
the cabin crew doing their best
-
to try and maintain
some semblance of order.
-
A flight attendant's voice
came over the PA,
-
"ladies and gentlemen,
-
please sit down and
fasten your seat belts.
-
Don't panic.
Please fasten your seat belts."
-
But inside the cockpit,
-
things were now getting
completely out of control.
-
The hijacker in the right seat
was still making crazy inputs
-
on the controls, in the same way a child
-
could be expected to behave,
-
and without the autopilot,
the 767 now pitched
-
and rolled erratically, climbing,
-
diving and banking hard to
the right and then to the left.
-
Information from the flight
data recorder later showed
-
that the aircraft moved rapidly
-
from pitch angles of 3.3 degrees nose up
-
to 8.3 degrees nose down,
-
and bank angles as high
as 47 degrees right
-
and 35 degrees left,
-
something that must have been
-
truly terrifying for everyone on board.
-
Now as the hijacker
pulled the nose back,
-
the plane began to climb briefly,
-
but without sufficient engine power,
-
it soon lost its airspeed and therefore,
-
began descending again.
-
So even though the hijacker
at the controls was determined
-
to get the aircraft back up
to 39,000 feet again,
-
it soon turned out that the
laws of physics were stronger.
-
"Let us land on the water,"
Captain Leul now pleaded,
-
with the plane descending and the island
-
of Grande Comore now in view.
-
He was determined to try
and salvage whatever he could.
-
Moroni's airport, Prince
Said Ibrahim International,
-
was positioned directly ahead of them,
-
so even before the hijacker had started
-
to interfere with the controls,
-
he had already started circling
to the south of the island,
-
trying desperately to keep
that airport available
-
as a last landing alternative.
-
By this point, the fuel gauges
were all reading zero,
-
and Captain Leul was trying
-
to keep the aircraft as stable as possible
-
to maintain the airport in sight,
-
just in case he could
get the plane down there.
-
But at the same time,
the hijacker was still interfering
-
with the controls, refusing to accept
-
what was about to happen.
-
So the captain now
tried one final appeal to reason,
-
hoping to buy himself enough time
-
to guide the plane down
towards the coast of Grande Comore.
-
At least let me land
on the water, he pleaded.
-
"Why? Get out of here!"
-
The hijacker snapped, once
again grabbing at the controls.
-
He yanked back on the yoke,
-
trying to force the aircraft to climb,
-
trading the last of their
speed for altitude.
-
"Let it descend by itself.
-
Don't touch it," the hijacker instructed.
-
And as he was saying that,
-
Grand Comore came back into the view,
-
prompting a new burst of
suspicion from the hijacker.
-
Captain Leul tried to reassure him,
-
but the hijacker demanded
-
to know what country that was,
-
pointing towards the island below.
-
So the captain now
bluffed a little bit.
-
"Look, I don't know,
it's not on the chart," he said.
-
And he then asked one final
time if they could please try
-
and land on the solid ground
-
as the plane descended
through about 21,000 feet,
-
but the reply came
as definitive as always, "No way!"
-
That prompted the captain
to point at the empty fuel gauges,
-
and almost exactly at that moment,
-
a cockpit chime rang out again,
-
this time warning that the
second engine was now failing.
-
Captain Leul called out,
-
"There you are, the
second engine is also out.
-
You wanted that, didn't you?"
-
And the hijacker's grim reply
came back almost immediately,
-
"Yes!"
-
In the background, a slow
steady chime continued to sound.
-
Beep, beep, beep.
-
Like a cardiac monitor
in a hospital room,
-
the aircraft itself was now confirming
-
what Captain Leul already knew.
-
Time had finally run out.
-
This aircraft was only going
to continue down from here.
-
"For the sake of my responsibility,
-
at least let the passengers
know about the condition,"
-
Captain Leul added,
continuing to be laser-focused
-
on the passengers' well-being behind him.
-
By this point, the lead hijacker
-
had seemingly accepted the truth.
-
There would be no landing in Australia
-
or anywhere else for that matter,
-
so his voice now grew colder.
-
"Descend it, increase the speed further,"
-
he ordered,
-
apparently intent on taking
everyone down with him.
-
Seconds later, with the last
engine windmilling to a stop,
-
the Boeing 767 also lost all
of its electrical power,
-
meaning that the flight data recorder
-
and cockpit voice
recorder also seized recording.
-
Beneath the fuselage,
-
the ram air turbine
deployed automatically,
-
spinning in the slipstream
-
to power only a few
critical flight instruments
-
and hydraulic systems.
-
And at this point, it
is believed that the airport
-
in Moroni was still technically
-
within gliding range,
-
but with the hijackers
actively preventing a landing,
-
Captain Leul had very
limited chances of reaching it.
-
He was now left with
only two desperate options,
-
either wrestle control
of the aircraft back
-
and attempt a high-stake
approach into Moroni
-
or ditch the powerless plane
into the Indian Ocean,
-
with the hijackers still at his back.
-
As the plane dropped
through about 15,000 feet,
-
chaos erupted in the passenger cabin
-
as some passengers started realizing
-
that the aircraft was now descending
-
down towards the sea below them.
-
They now began pulling out life vests
-
and some of them also inflated them
-
while still seated in the cabin.
-
Flight attendants and passengers
shouted at them to stop,
-
warning that a fully inflated
vest inside the cabin
-
would prevent them
from escaping after impact,
-
but those warnings were largely ignored.
-
First officer Yonas,
-
having recovered from
his earlier beating,
-
now walked back through the cabin,
-
telling people not to
inflate their life vests
-
and even helping the cabin crew
to deflate the ones who had,
-
while simultaneously instructing
-
the passengers on how
to re-inflate them later.
-
The same message was then
repeated by the cabin crew
-
and concerned passengers,
-
but many on board
simply didn't understand,
-
again because these warnings
were only called out in English.
-
But even if that
wouldn't have been the case,
-
panic had now taken hold
-
and the cabin was soon
full of inflated life vests,
-
confusion and fear.
-
Captain Leul could hear that behind him
-
as he fought to turn the aircraft around
-
to try and align it with the runway at Moroni,
-
and finally his luck turned slightly,
-
when help arrived in the
former First Officer Yonas,
-
who now pushed his way into the cockpit,
-
defying the hijackers.
-
Let me help the captain,
-
he shouted and together
the two pilots
-
now started fighting both the
hijackers and the jet itself.
-
You see, with the autopilot dead
-
and control forces heavy due
-
to limited hydraulic power,
-
flying the plane was
now physically exhausting.
-
And with the hijackers still lunging
-
for the controls,
grabbing at the yokes,
-
trying to stop the pilots
from reaching land,
-
this fight must have
been truly monumental.
-
But even though that was the case,
-
Leul and Yonas finally managed
-
to get the 767 somewhat stabilized,
-
and as they did,
they realized that Moroni's airport
-
was now no longer visible.
-
It is possible that at the time
-
that they had managed
to wrestle back the controls,
-
the airport was simply out of reach.
-
So the two pilots now instead
focused on what they could do,
-
tried to save as many lives as possible
-
by attempting a controlled ditching.
-
So they now initiated a turn
of the enormous Boeing 767
-
to try and parallel the shoreline.
-
Now there are established procedures
-
for how to do a ditching.
-
There are even checklists
-
for it in a quick reference handbook,
-
but that procedure is
created for a powered ditching,
-
meaning with both engines available,
-
and it also assumes
that all instruments are working.
-
These two pilots were
now going to attempt doing
-
the same with no engine power,
-
and with only their standby
instruments working,
-
which didn't include an IVSI
showing the descent rate,
-
so they would have to eyeball it.
-
At just 150 feet above the waves,
-
the hijackers finally gave up,
-
stepping back from the controls,
-
perhaps realizing too late
-
that they had now
doomed themselves.
-
In the rear of the cabin,
a few passengers
-
were now trying to
organize a last ditch resistance,
-
but there was now
nothing more to be done.
-
The flight was only
seconds away from impact.
-
Coming in fast and low over
the waters next to Grande Comore,
-
Ethiopian Airlines flight 961
-
now descended towards the coast
-
at an airspeed of roughly 200 knots.
-
With no engine power,
not much instrumentation
-
and very little control authority,
-
Captain Leul and First Officer Yonas
-
were now flying entirely by feel,
-
gliding their 767-200ER
towards one last desperate hope,
-
a controlled ditching just off the beach
-
near the town of Mitsamiouli.
-
Ahead lay Galawa Beach,
a stretch of white sand
-
once considered the crown
jewel of Comorrean tourism.
-
An inland from that beach
was the only major tourist resort
-
in the entire country,
the La Galawa Hotel.
-
This was a popular retreat
-
for mainly South African travelers,
-
and it was now a sunny afternoon,
-
with loads of people
packed on the beach.
-
Among those was a
couple from South Africa
-
with a camcorder,
and they soon spotted
-
a low-flying plane
approaching the shoreline,
-
assuming that it was part
of some sort of airshow.
-
So they began to film, and that footage
-
would become one of
the most dramatic recordings
-
of a crash landing ever captured.
-
As the 767 skimmed over the surf,
-
Captain Leul made a slight left turn,
-
trying to align with the waves
-
and thereby minimizing
the forces on impact.
-
But despite his skill,
-
things now didn't go according to plan.
-
Just before he could
bring the wings back to level,
-
the left wingtip struck the water,
-
and that one contact was enough.
-
The wingtip dug in, pulling
the rest of the airframe down,
-
the left engine's massive cowling
-
then scooped into the sea,
-
decelerating and turning
the aircraft with a violent jolt.
-
The plane then pivoted
around the snagged engine,
-
and the right wing soared
upward like a massive sail
-
as the fuselage whipped
around in a dramatic cartwheel.
-
To stunned beachgoers,
the splash alone was colossal,
-
a wall of sea spray fragments of fuselage
-
and glinting debris rising
hundreds of feet into the air.
-
Almost immediately,
the fuselage broke apart
-
as it also struck a shallow underwater reef
-
as part of the impact.
-
The nose sheared off,
the center fuselage ruptured
-
and the tail was then torn away,
-
and the cabin continued
to tumble through the sea
-
until it finally came to rest
-
roughly 500 meters away from shore.
-
And unfortunately,
that impact killed several
-
of the passengers on board,
-
and that included all three hijackers
-
who had been standing
in the rear of the cockpit
-
and in the galley as the aircraft hit.
-
Survivors described the chaos
-
that then followed as pure horror.
-
Some passengers had been
ejected from the wreckage
-
and landed in the surf where they
-
were then able to swim or float to safety,
-
and others were trapped inside
-
of the disintegrating
upside down fuselage,
-
rapidly filling with seawater.
-
Now the waters were shallow enough
-
for part of the overturned fuselage
-
to remain above the surface,
-
but some passengers
-
were still trapped by their
upside down seats underwater.
-
And one factor that made
survival even harder for some
-
was the fact that moments
before ditching,
-
despite the warnings from the cabin crew,
-
many passengers had
still inflated their life vests.
-
And now, floating in
the upside down wreckage,
-
those inflated vests
pinned them to the roof,
-
making it almost impossible
-
to swim downwards towards the exits.
-
Some managed to deflate
-
their vests or pull them off,
but many didn't.
-
Now the official
investigation made it clear
-
that traumatic injuries were
the primary cause of death
-
in the majority of victims in this crash,
-
but it's still widely accepted
that the inflated vests
-
also contributed to a significant number
-
of preventable fatalities.
-
But against all odds,
some passengers did survive,
-
and their survival
was due, in no small part,
-
to what happened next.
-
The crash had, like I mentioned,
taken place just offshore
-
from the nation's largest resort,
-
and that meant that
help was unusually close by.
-
Dozens of people now rushed
to the water, some swimming,
-
others grabbing small boats
or paddle boards to help.
-
Among them were scuba instructors
-
from a local dive school,
-
and a group of visiting French doctors.
-
And these impromptu first responders
-
were in the water within moments,
-
pulling dazed and injured
passengers away to safety.
-
The local airport had also been advised
-
about the hijacked jet,
-
and had therefore put their
rescue team on high alert.
-
So as soon as reports started coming in
-
about a plane crash nearby,
-
they dispatched and could support
-
the rescue efforts about 30 minutes
-
after the crash had occurred.
-
But even with that in mind,
-
in the end the death toll
was truly heartbreaking.
-
Of the 175 people on board,
only 50 had survived,
-
including First Officer Yonas
and Captain Leul,
-
who Yonas heroically had
pulled from the wreckage.
-
But that still meant that
125 people had been killed,
-
including all of the
three unbelted hijackers
-
and seven of the crew.
-
Now, what happened on board
Ethiopian Airlines Flight 961
-
is, in many ways, unimaginable today.
-
The hardened cockpit door
introduced after 9/11
-
would now prevent any intruder
-
from storming the flight deck,
-
and the mindset among
passengers has also changed.
-
No one sits back and waits anymore,
-
so hijacking a plane
with an axe and a fake bomb
-
is no longer a viable plan.
-
But that doesn't make
this story any less extraordinary.
-
It remains one of the most
harrowing and heroic episodes
-
in modern aviation history,
-
Captain Leul Abata faced
a situation with no good options,
-
no real hope and no clear way out,
-
and still he never gave up,
-
which is a real testament
of courage and dedication.
-
There were also quite
a few important lessons
-
to take away from all of this.
-
The cockpit voice recorder
-
and the flight data
recorder lost power
-
just when it mattered the most,
-
reminding us why accident
investigators continue to push
-
for backup power supplies
-
and longer recording
times on existing recorders.
-
Today, most airliners
are therefore being fitted
-
with special batteries that can power
-
the recorders for a limited time
-
in case of a complete power loss,
-
which might prove really important.
-
This also highlighted
how important it is
-
to never inflate your life vest
whilst inside of the cabin,
-
and that's the reason
this instruction forms part
-
of every single safety briefing today.
-
Again, an example of where
a procedure is written in blood.
-
And then, of course, there
are the more behavioral lessons.
-
Captain Leul's strategy of
keeping the hijackers talking
-
and appearing to cooperate
while subtly maneuvering
-
the aircraft towards a survivable outcome
-
offers a textbook example
-
of crisis de-escalation under duress.
-
Sometimes stalling is the
only lifeline you have,
-
and when you're dealing
with irrational demands
-
and real danger,
small strategic concessions
-
can sometimes buy you precious minutes,
-
minutes that in this case meant
-
the difference between
everyone dying in the cold sea
-
and 50 people walking away.
-
Thank you so much
for watching this episode,
-
and I hope that we've
earned a subscription and a like.
-
Now, if you want to see
my next video
-
before everyone else,
possibly even today,
-
well then scan this QR code or go
-
to patreon.com/join/mentourpilot
and sign up.
-
My name is Petter Hörnfeldt,
-
and you're watching Mentour Pilot.
-
Have an absolutely fantastic day,
-
and we'll see you next time.
-
Bye-bye.