-
-
[VEHICLES HONKING]
-
-
[SOMBER MUSIC]
-
-
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
-
-
Water work is night work.
-
-
That's because every
part of this business
-
is completely illegal.
-
-
The water mafia in Delhi
dig holes, deep holes
-
into the ground 300
feet below the surface.
-
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
-
-
[MACHINE WHIRRING]
-
This water is then pumped
from below the surface
-
into these large
tankers, which then
-
chuck this water into the
city in the dead of night.
-
-
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
-
-
The cities grow.
-
The supply of water is
shrinking much faster
-
than anyone imagined.
-
And the story of
Delhi's water mafia
-
is probably going to be the
story of growing cities all
-
over the world.
-
-
Within the next decade, 2/3 of
the world's population could
-
face a daily struggle for water.
-
-
As populations grow and
drought intensifies,
-
a resource essential to
life is fueling conflict,
-
from the Middle East to India to
the embattled rivers of China,
-
posing a new kind of
threat to global security.
-
[THEME MUSIC]
-
-
[SOMBER MUSIC]
-
-
Everyone buys water
from the water mafia--
-
the rich, the poor,
the middle class.
-
That's because Delhi
and its surroundings
-
have about 24 million people,
and anywhere between 30% to 40%
-
don't have access
to municipal water.
-
And as the black market water
trade became more organized,
-
the trucks got
bigger, the people who
-
were controlling it got richer.
-
-
Now the water mafia
behaves in a way
-
that this water
will last forever.
-
But as temperatures
continue to rise,
-
the mafia is finally
going to run out of water.
-
And that's when we're really
going to have a problem.
-
[UPBEAT MUSIC]
-
-
The status of the
world's freshwater supply
-
today is a crisis as big
as anything out there.
-
-
Less than 1% of
the world's water
-
is accessible for human use.
-
Populations are going up.
-
As economies grow and
countries develop,
-
they use more and more water.
-
And we're polluting
what there is, making
-
it less and less accessible.
-
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
-
-
Water scarcity is
with us here and now.
-
-
Warmer temperatures,
less predictable rains
-
will all combine to make
societies a little less stable.
-
People generally have three sets
of responses to water scarcity.
-
They can adapt if they
have the resources.
-
They can move, or they
can suffer and die.
-
And if they're moving, this
becomes a security concern
-
worldwide.
-
-
15,000 migrants and refugees
on the Greek Island of Lesbos,
-
with around a thousand people
a day washing ashore on this
-
island alone.
-
Leaving behind them the chaos
and the conflict in Syria,
-
for many refugees, the
idyllic island of Lesbos
-
is their first place
of entry to Europe.
-
Boat after boat after
boat, this island
-
is overwhelmed by the number
of refugees and migrants
-
coming on to its shores.
-
-
My name is Hiba Dlewati, and I
am a Syrian-American journalist.
-
-
I've been following the Syrian
conflict for three years.
-
What makes following this
refugee crisis so interesting
-
is that each story has layers.
-
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
-
-
The role of drought
and water in the region
-
is not one that occurs
to you right away,
-
but it affected everyone.
-
And no one has really
been talking about it.
-
No one has been talking about
more than a million people
-
having to leave their
homes because they
-
could no longer farm the land
because they had no more water.
-
-
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
-
-
A five-year drought that started
in 2006 destroyed over half
-
of Syria's most fertile areas.
-
Waves of farmers
abandoned their fields
-
and moved to crowded
cities in the north
-
where anti-government
resistance was already rising.
-
Estimates have ranged from
800,000 up to 2.5 million
-
farmers moved to the urban
centers in the north of Syria
-
and were relegated to the
peripheries of these cities
-
into what was
really shantytowns.
-
So you had 18- to 35-year-old
men who were essentially of war
-
age that were left with no
other options to gain a normal
-
and decent living.
-
There's no infrastructure
to absorb them.
-
They're angry.
-
They're unemployed.
-
The price of food is going
up because of water scarcity.
-
So all of these factors create
a setting for instability.
-
[SHOTS FIRING]
-
[CROWD CHANTING]
-
[SHOTS FIRING]
-
-
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
-
-
Civilians get to
the point where they
-
realize everyone
might drop on them,
-
or they might simply starve to
death or simply die of thirst.
-
And there's only one
way, and it's out.
-
It's to leave.
-
-
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
-
-
This is Hellenic Coast Guard.
-
You are in Greek
territory waters.
-
[INAUDIBLE]
-
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
-
-
The babies first, the babies.
-
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
-
-
Now there is a sense of
complete desperation.
-
-
Since 2015 alone, I believe more
than a million people, mostly
-
from Syria and Iraq, have
made their way to Europe,
-
mostly crossing this
very sea over there.
-
You can see Turkey.
-
[SOMBER MUSIC]
-
-
The situation has led to
the greatest mass migration
-
of people into Europe that we've
seen, certainly since World War
-
II.
-
International organizations,
such as the United Nations,
-
are reticent to label people
"environmental refugees."
-
They prefer the term
"environmental migrants."
-
And this is because
when you are a refugee
-
under the international
system, you're
-
afforded the right to settle
in in their countries.
-
And so the number of
environmental migrants
-
by the middle of
the next century
-
is supposed to be so
large that it's just not
-
in the capacity of nations
to actually treat them
-
like refugees.
-
-
Drought and water
scarcity are a factor
-
in areas which
are precisely high
-
up on our priorities
for security concerns.
-
That's about half of Africa.
-
That's a lot of South and
Southeast Asia, certainly
-
most of the Middle East.
-
These are the areas
where you really
-
watch for how scarcity can
drive populations, which
-
in turn drives
instability, which impacts
-
a lot of the issues
that we're concerned
-
about here in the United States.
-
-
Migration has been
part of human history.
-
-
But migrations
that are triggered
-
by permanent loss of water
resource in an area, the world
-
doesn't have much
experience dealing
-
with migration of this kind.
-
-
Lack of groundwater isn't
Syria's only water problem.
-
Its major rivers, the
Tigris and Euphrates,
-
are beginning to dry up.
-
Is this climate change
or other forces at work?
-
Both the Tigris and Euphrates
rise in Turkey and then flow
-
through Syria and then to Iraq.
-
Upstream Turkey is a
number of major dams
-
on the headwaters of
both of these rivers
-
that have impacts downstream.
-
Countries that are
upstream are referred
-
to technically as
the upper riparians.
-
And so as the upper
riparian, Turkey's
-
been sort of ratcheting
back the supply
-
to the downstream countries,
both of Iraq and Syria.
-
River systems generally empower
those that are located upstream.
-
If you're sharing a river
with two or more countries
-
and you are located furthest
downstream, in a sense,
-
you are powerless.
-
The Middle East,
already dry, could soon
-
be home to half of the world's
most water-stressed countries.
-
What will it mean
for global security
-
when water becomes
more valuable than oil?
-
With severe water
shortages in Yemen
-
and other countries
in the region,
-
violent revolution may spread.
-
[EXPLODES]
-
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
-
-
[THEME MUSIC]
-
-
[SOMBER MUSIC]
-
-
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
-
-
Controlling the sources
of water is often
-
a magnet for insurgents
and for guerrillas.
-
[SHOT FIRES]
-
-
Looking at ISIS's
propaganda, it's
-
really been part of
their apocalyptic vision
-
that a flood will
wipe out the infidels.
-
So they've seen water
as a medium of war,
-
as a medium of violence.
-
And they've taken
this all the way up
-
from the theoretical and
theological level all the way
-
down to the village level
where they've used water
-
as a tactic against enemies.
-
When ISIS began its campaign
of violence in 2013,
-
the towns and cities it targeted
were all linked by one thing.
-
ISIS is unique in the
sense that it sought
-
to actually create a state.
-
And the areas it
sought to control first
-
were the areas along the two
major rivers of Syria and Iraq,
-
the Euphrates and the Tigris.
-
ISIS, in other
words, has positioned
-
itself to be able to
use water as a weapon.
-
-
ISIS was one of the first
groups to use this tactic that's
-
been called hydro-terrorism.
-
So not only have they physically
cut control off of water,
-
they've also been able to use
just the very threat of seizing
-
control of water as
a psychological tool.
-
Many of these areas
relied on wells.
-
They relied on gas being sent so
they could pump their water out
-
of the ground.
-
And to punish them
for being rebels--
-
or as ISIS calls
them, infidels--
-
they have cut off fuel and
thus have not allowed people
-
to access the water they
need to drink, to wash,
-
to grow agriculture.
-
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
-
-
In towns and villages
that they've occupied,
-
ISIS has been able to
form what might even
-
be considered a water mafia.
-
-
They've levied high charges
for the use of water.
-
And they've been able to
use those funds to build up
-
their military capacity.
-
[EXPLODES]
-
-
In the summer of
2014, ISIS forces
-
seized control of the Mosul Dam.
-
-
In Iraq.
-
ISIS militants captured
the Mosul Dam Sunday
-
to allow ISIS to use water as
a weapon to flood major cities
-
or control its supply to
hundreds of thousands of people.
-
[PEOPLE EXCLAIMING]
-
-
The Mosul Dam is a few hundred
miles north of Baghdad.
-
So the idea that ISIS seized
the Mosul Dam was very important
-
because if the
dam were breached,
-
a wall of water,
perhaps 70 feet high,
-
could have made its way all
the way down the Tigris river
-
to the Green Zone
and actually wiped
-
out the American and allied
forces that were down there.
-
[EXPLODES]
-
[BRISK MUSIC]
-
-
Today, with our support,
Iraqi and Kurdish forces
-
took a major step forward by
recapturing the largest dam
-
in Iraq near the city of Mosul.
-
If that dam was breached, it
could have proven catastrophic,
-
with floods that
would have threatened
-
the lives of
thousands of civilians
-
and endanger our embassy
compound in Baghdad.
-
-
Until recently,
water has been seen
-
as what's known as a soft
security or a human security
-
issue.
-
-
But the defense
community has begun
-
to understand how
environmental stressors can
-
lead to societal
disruption in countries
-
that are important to
national security interests.
-
In the face of drought,
a population explosion,
-
and the constant threat of
war, solving the water crisis
-
in the Middle East could take
nothing short of a miracle.
-
[SOMBER MUSIC]
-
-
[WATER SPLASHES]
-
-
Between the desert
and the Mediterranean,
-
one country in the Middle East
seems to have plenty of water.
-
But only a few years ago, Israel
was facing the worst drought
-
in its history.
-
Right now, Israel's water supply
is in danger of drying up.
-
Severe drought is
threatening everything
-
we worked so hard to achieve.
-
The drought was terrible.
-
We reached-- in 2009 in Israel
was really in a terrible crisis.
-
When I was nominated for the
head of the Water Authority,
-
I never think that I'll have
to face this kind of crisis.
-
But I realized after
a very short time
-
that practically,
there is no water.
-
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
-
There was a famous
commercial in Israel.
-
You could see the
face of a nice woman,
-
or a very famous actor,
or a basketball player.
-
And through talking to you,
their faces were cracked.
-
Everybody immediately was aware
that there is a serious problem,
-
and the water consumption
decreased by 20% immediately.
-
A massive investment
in water recycling
-
enabled the country to reuse
up to 85% of its wastewater,
-
but drinking water was
still in short supply.
-
The state of Israel understood
that we cannot develop
-
the country as we would like
to without having a reliable
-
resource of stable water
available for all the people
-
in Israel.
-
The real leap forward has been
in desalination technology,
-
vastly improving
Israel's ability
-
to turn salty water into
fresh drinking water.
-
Israel decided to
move into desalination
-
for a lot of reasons, not least
of which were the politics
-
of being an isolated country.
-
As a political and
strategic move,
-
they decided to invest
heavily in desalination.
-
And it absolutely changed
the game in Israel.
-
High-pressure pumps force
seawater through ultra fine
-
membranes, filtering
out the salt.
-
The purified water then flows
into the national water system.
-
-
Out of drinking supply of
around 1 billion cubic meters
-
per year in Israel,
around 60% comes
-
from the desalination plants.
-
So it's a revolution.
-
We're the number one recycler
of wastewater in the world.
-
We have desalinization.
-
Israel has no water problems.
-
-
Desalinization is deeply
dependent on the cost of energy.
-
And so you can only use
it when the water is
-
going to drink in water, when
that population is on the coast
-
and when there's
no other options.
-
Right now, desalinated water
can be three or four times more
-
expensive than
conventional water.
-
And it produces residues,
which are toxic and have
-
to be disposed of in an
environmentally safe manner.
-
But if desalination becomes
cost-effective eventually,
-
it will fundamentally change
the geopolitics of water.
-
It will turn the geopolitics
of water on its head.
-
[SOMBER MUSIC]
-
-
As an engineer,
I believe that we
-
need to bring some
value to our planet.
-
And we are in the
middle of an arid area.
-
You don't have water, which
is essential for life.
-
Supplying water is
like creating life.
-
Israel's revolution has
transformed life in the country.
-
But this water miracle
in the Holy Land
-
also has a darker side.
-
-
[THEME MUSIC]
-
-
[SOMBER MUSIC]
-
-
Since 1967, the West Bank
has been under military law
-
by Israel.
-
And the water resources
of the West Bank
-
are under the same
military occupation
-
as the rest of the resources.
-
Access to drinking water,
treatment of sewage,
-
all of these things
are much more
-
difficult within
Palestinian territories
-
than they are within Israel.
-
30% of the Palestinians receive
water less than three hours
-
a week.
-
Our houses are connected,
but no water in the pipes.
-
-
Chronic water
shortages plague most
-
of the 2.8 million
Palestinians in the West Bank.
-
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
-
-
Hundreds of thousands
live without access
-
to any water infrastructure.
-
And some villages
and some cities,
-
they purchase water by tankers.
-
And this is very expensive
and, quality-wise, very bad.
-
-
[ENGINE ROARING]
-
-
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
-
-
The West Bank is actually
surrounded by water.
-
The Jordan River flows
along its eastern border,
-
and the territory sits atop
the region's biggest aquifers.
-
Under Israeli
occupation, Palestinians
-
are barred from
accessing the river
-
and from tapping into
the water underground.
-
To make up for the
shortage, most Palestinians
-
have no choice but to buy water
from the Israeli national water
-
company, Mekorot.
-
Mekorot is the Israeli national
company that distributes water.
-
They control a set of
wells in the West Bank.
-
So people are now paying
one third of their income
-
to purchase water from Mekorot.
-
So Mekorot basically is
selling our water back to us.
-
The flow of hydrology makes the
politics really complicated.
-
The aquifers that
Israel relies on
-
for a third of
their water supply
-
originate within the West Bank.
-
Palestinians upstream
see that the aquifers
-
are within the West Bank.
-
They argue that that's
Palestinian water.
-
The water flows into
Israeli territory.
-
And Israel has been tapping
that water since the 1950s,
-
and they see that they
have rights to the water
-
as a consequence.
-
If you will allow
the Palestinians
-
to do what they
would like to do,
-
they will dry up
completely the aquifer.
-
We have to keep the water
under national authorities.
-
This is a big problem.
-
Who owns the water?
-
In the reality, who controls
the water is Israel.
-
We do not have access to our
resources in the West Bank.
-
We do not control the
water underneath our feet.
-
In 1995, a follow-up to
the historic Oslo Accords
-
between the Israelis
and Palestinians
-
allocated 80% of
groundwater to Israel.
-
The agreement was supposed
to last five years.
-
But 20 years later, the
Palestinian population
-
has boomed, while many say
their share of the water
-
remains virtually the same.
-
The taps in the homes of Arab
villagers in the West Bank,
-
they run dry most of the time.
-
As they complain, Israel doesn't
satisfy even their minimum water
-
needs.
-
Most of the cities
in Palestine, they
-
store water on their roofs
to have water in their houses
-
because the regular
water is not running.
-
And this is what we
call black forest
-
because if you look to
the Palestinian roofs,
-
it's full with
black storage tanks.
-
-
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
-
-
[SOMBER MUSIC]
-
-
[PUMP RUNNING]
-
-
Israel encourages its citizens
to move to settlements
-
in the West Bank,
in part by ensuring
-
that water flows more freely
in these exclusive compounds.
-
-
So all the settlements
in the West Bank
-
are connected to
our systems, yes,
-
and receive water
from the cohort.
-
They receive water from
other local sources too,
-
but the main supply
comes from us.
-
[BOUNCY MUSIC]
-
-
The Israeli government
has supported
-
the construction of
over 120 settlements
-
across the West Bank.
-
Some studies claim that
the 380,000 Israelis living
-
in the settlements consume up to
four times the amount of water
-
as the West Bank's
Palestinian population.
-
-
With the settlement,
this is what's
-
making our life miserable.
-
-
Settlements are taking almost of
their water from our aquifers,
-
from the wells that
drilled in the West Bank.
-
[SOMBER MUSIC]
-
-
A lot of the world sees
the settlements as illegal.
-
And from the
Palestinian perspective,
-
they're not just illegal.
-
They're immoral.
-
But the point is obvious.
-
It's just to force
people to leave the land
-
because when you don't
have water, people leave.
-
[ENGINE RUNNING]
-
-
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
-
-
[ROOSTER CROWS]
-
-
[GENTLE MUSIC]
-
-
This is the daily
sufferings of people that
-
don't have a source of water.
-
They rely on tanks,
heavy price of water,
-
and water is not
available all the time.
-
-
Wherever there is water, there
is people, there is life,
-
there is prosperity.
-
Wherever you don't have
water, there is desert,
-
and there is no life.
-
-
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
-
-
[ENGINE ROARS]
-
-
Water conflict has wracked the
region since Israel's founding.
-
-
But half a continent away,
a far larger water war
-
is threatening to erupt.
-
-
[THEME MUSIC]
-
-
Israel always has
been very conscious
-
of its water resources.
-
Out of the 38 cases of actual
violence worldwide since World
-
War II around shared
waters, 27 of these
-
were between Israelis and Arabs.
-
For us, the water was part of
the fulfillment of the Zionist
-
dream.
-
The ambition to bring
all the Jewish people
-
here needs a lot of water.
-
Water has fueled tensions
with Israel's Arab neighbors
-
since the country's
foundation, culminating
-
in the six-day war of 1967.
-
The Syrian ceasefire, and
for all practical purposes,
-
ends the war.
-
And it is safe to say that
things will never again
-
be the same in the Middle East.
-
At the war's end, Israel
had acquired land,
-
but the real prize
was under the surface.
-
The six-day war had a
lot of other causes.
-
But having said that,
at the end of the war,
-
Israel now gained,
with the Golan Heights,
-
the headwaters of
the Jordan Basin.
-
With the West Bank, they gained
the aquifers on which they had
-
been defending since the 1950s.
-
And so their, what we call,
hydro-strategic positioning
-
was made infinitely better by
the territory gained in the war.
-
Ariel Sharon said that the
six-day war was as much
-
about water as about land.
-
In one stroke, Israel
went from being
-
dependent on transboundary
water inflows
-
to being the transboundary water
controller of its subregion.
-
So that war was a
water war of a kind
-
that we have rarely
seen in modern times.
-
Some Israelis claim that control
over the West Bank's aquifers
-
is critical to preventing
Palestinian overdrilling.
-
The problem of drilling
wells in the West Bank,
-
if Israel loses its
control on the aquifer,
-
if its water level
drops a few meters,
-
we have a penetration of
seawater into the aquifer.
-
And then we all lose it.
-
And that's it.
-
[NON-ENGLISH SINGING]
-
-
The dangers of
overpumping the aquifer
-
are already evident just 30
miles from the West Bank,
-
in the other isolated
Palestinian territory of Gaza.
-
-
In 2005, Israel withdrew
from the Gaza Strip,
-
ceding control of the
coastal aquifer underneath.
-
-
And I remember in Gaza, When.
-
We told them, be careful because
if you allow unlawful wells,
-
they will dry the aquifer.
-
-
Today, more than 6,000 wells,
no more aquifer water in Gaza.
-
-
There is a huge crisis in Gaza
because in Gaza, our water
-
is polluted, our water
isn't fit for human use.
-
And if we don't
do anything, if we
-
don't address the
situation in Gaza by 2020,
-
damage is irreversible.
-
[UNSETTLING MUSIC]
-
-
Israel's new water surplus could
either foster hydro diplomacy
-
or simply strengthen
its position of power.
-
-
Maybe 10 or 20
years ago, I would
-
say that war is a
conflict, and we
-
have to preserve
our water sources,
-
and we have to keep it
safe for us, only for us.
-
We actually produce more
than we consume now,
-
so we can give water or
sell water to our neighbors.
-
-
Three years ago,
Israel announced,
-
we don't have anymore
a water crisis.
-
So I spoke to them and said, OK.
-
Congratulations.
-
You don't have any water crisis.
-
Would you please give
us back our water?
-
[CROWD CLAMORING]
-
-
The Palestinian people will
not keep silent forever.
-
If the Israelis continue
their unwise policy,
-
they will pay a very high
price, that is more violence.
-
The conflict here
is a warning of what
-
can happen when one population
controls the water of another.
-
But what happens
when a single nation
-
tries to control the water
supply of an entire continent?
-
-
[RHYTHMIC MUSIC]
-
-
The Brahmaputra in
Northeastern India
-
is the world's highest river.
-
Flowing south through
the Himalayas from China,
-
it crosses one of the most
heavily militarized borders
-
in the world.
-
-
For years, tension has mounted
between Asia's two titans
-
for what many in India see as
China's unstoppable thirst.
-
Northeast China is experiencing
its worst drought in 63 years.
-
The great Chinese
drought is continuing,
-
and there's no end in sight.
-
China is dealing
with a water crisis
-
at a number of different levels.
-
In the North China
Plain, they've
-
overpumped agricultural areas
like in a lot of the world.
-
And as a response
to this, they've
-
launched one of the
largest dam construction
-
programs in the world.
-
China today has more
than 90,000 dams.
-
It is the world's
most dammed country.
-
-
Water has been always a
huge problem in China.
-
-
China's freshwater
availability is only a third
-
of the world average.
-
A lot of the rivers
are polluted.
-
And now because
of climate change,
-
the main rivers are
starting to run dry.
-
And China's government
realized that this
-
is a serious threat to the
legitimacy of the Communist
-
Party.
-
Since China annexed
Tibet in 1951,
-
it has had its hand on the
tap of Asia, the glaciers
-
of the Tibetan Plateau.
-
The annexation of the Tibetan
Plateau by China in the early
-
1950s amounted to a de facto
water war because it changed
-
Asia's water map.
-
China became the source
of water supplies
-
to more than a dozen
countries of Asia.
-
A lot of China's neighbors
depend on flows from the waters
-
from the Tibetan Plateau,
which sustains the livelihood
-
of 1.3 billion people.
-
That's a fifth of mankind.
-
China has built 11 major
dams on the upper stretches
-
of the Mekong and
Salween rivers,
-
the lifelines of Southeast Asia,
with plans for nearly 40 more.
-
The government
insists that they are
-
hydroelectric dams that have
little effect on the river's
-
flow.
-
-
But downstream
countries who disagree
-
have little power to fight back.
-
China is known as a
hydro-hegemon because rarely
-
do you have any example of an
upstream nation being so much
-
more politically and
militarily powerful
-
than the downstream nations.
-
[RHYTHMIC MUSIC]
-
-
To address the water
shortage in the north,
-
China recently launched
a massive project
-
to divert water from
the south and channel it
-
across thousands of miles,
as far north as Beijing.
-
No country has ever attempted to
initiate something on the scale
-
that China has through its
so-called great South-North
-
Water Diversion Project.
-
We talk about huge project
without any parallel
-
in modern history.
-
Because the threat is so severe,
that means a deliberate attempt
-
to extract more water
from the Tibetan Plateau.
-
And you're not talking
about small amount.
-
You're talking about
massive amounts.
-
The project has sparked
intense animosity
-
from India, which fears
the diversion will reroute
-
the headwaters of
the Brahmaputra
-
river, a major
source of freshwater
-
for Northeast India
and Bangladesh.
-
-
What worries India is that
the Chinese pattern usually
-
is to begin building dams
as far upstream as possible
-
and then gradually move closer
to the international border.
-
So we're going to see a similar
pattern on the Brahmaputra
-
in the years to come.
-
From Hong Kong
tonight, I'm joined
-
by Andrew KP Leung,
international and independent
-
China specialist.
-
I appear on Times Now of
India, but my experience
-
with that program is
that oftentimes, I
-
couldn't get a word in because
their feelings are so strong.
-
Then why is China doing it?
-
If the river is--
-
Why is China doing it?
-
I'm trying to reply to you.
-
Well, why has China--
-
And that suggests that there
are people in India who
-
think that India should really,
if necessary, fight a war
-
and stand up to China.
-
[BRISK MUSIC]
-
-
What China is doing, in a
strict sense, is a water war.
-
It's waging a war to appropriate
water resources, which
-
are shared resources,
targeting rivers
-
that flow to other countries.
-
That amounts to waging a war
on its downstream neighbors.
-
A water war can be won
without firing a shot.
-
Shouldn't we broaden the
definition of a water war?
-
The idea of two countries
using their national militaries
-
to wage full-scale
war against each other
-
still remains unlikely for
the next decade or two.
-
But there will definitely
be conflict over water,
-
unless there are very
specific policy responses,
-
unless new technologies
are introduced.
-
We're still at a
place where we're
-
able to do something
about the problem.
-
There's still hope, but
something's got to change.
-
-
[THEME MUSIC]
-