-
YouTube is pushing pro-CCP content — and burying
China Uncensored.
-
Now we have the evidence.
-
Welcome to China Uncensored. I’m Chris Chappell.
-
YouTube knows what you want. What you really
want.
-
The more than 2 million of you subscribed
-
to this YouTube channel might think you want to
watch videos exposing the Chinese Communist Party.
-
But YouTube knows that’s not true.
-
What you really want to watch are
-
videos about how incredible
China’s high speed rail is.
-
And how there is absolutely no genocide
in Xinjiang,
-
the land of happy Uyghurs and dancing cotton.
-
Or dancing Uyghurs and
happy cotton. Don’t question the algorithm!
-
When I started this show 12 years ago, I
knew it would be hard to fight censorship from China.
-
But back in those innocent days,
I never imagined I’d soon have to fight an
-
even scarier boss: Censorship
from American tech companies.
-
You see, I just did a deep dive
into YouTube’s censorship.
-
And the results absolutely shocked me.
-
And this is not my first
YouTube censorship rodeo.
-
YouTube’s censorship really
got going in late 2016,
-
when YouTube started pulling
ads from videos—that is,
-
demonetizing them—if they
deemed them too controversial.
-
That included YouTube reaching back
in time and demonetizing old videos,
-
including one of the first videos I ever
posted on this channel
-
. It criticized the New York Times for doing a 180 on
their reporting of human rights in China.
-
“It’s really weird that there was such a big
shift after 2001. I wonder what happened?”
-
But despite YouTube’s demonetization, I
kept going. In 2019, I flew to Hong Kong
-
to cover the Hong Kong protests
and inhale more tear gas
-
than I thought humanly possible.
-
And guess
what? YouTube demonetized us again!
-
It was so bad that the media even covered it.
-
That financial pressure should have
been enough to stop us, but it wasn’t.
-
It got even worse in 2020.
-
YouTube started
outright deleting videos we made about the Coronavirus
-
. Like the one I made about how the
cure for coronavirus isn’t authoritarianism.
-
After YouTube deleted it, we made a big stink
about it on social media, including Twitter.
-
And thanks to public pressure,
-
YouTube reinstated the video.
-
Even though
they demonetized it and age-restricted it.
-
YouTube continued to do
that throughout Covid.
-
Even though more people were watching
China Uncensored than ever before.
-
In the summer of 2024, we did a subscription
push at the end of some of our episodes.
-
We got more than 30,000 new subscribers in just 5
weeks—
-
blowing us way past 2 million subscribers.
-
But then in early November 2024,
-
we noticed something new happening to
our videos—and it was weird.
-
Suddenly, our views tanked.
-
They were only getting a half
or a third of the views compared to normal.
-
The majority of our videos couldn’t
even get 100,000 views anymore.
-
On a channel, that now had
over 2 million subscribers.
-
And the way the algorithm works,
-
lower views
means YouTube recommends our videos less,
-
which leads to even lower views.
-
This is
creating a death spiral for China Uncensored.
-
So I had a phone call with our YouTube
rep, and she said we have a problem.
-
Our viewers just aren’t engaged.
-
We need to
do more to increase engagement on our videos.
-
In other words, don’t question the algorithm!
-
I started wondering, am I out of touch?
-
Do the
kids not want to hear about the CCP anymore?
-
Do I need to travel to China
and make videos about how great
-
China’s high speed trains are.
-
Or
how luxurious the labor camps are?
-
But before I could book my ticket to
China and get my organs harvested,
-
I got an email from fellow YouTubers the CCP
doesn’t like that much:
-
Serpentza and Laowhy86.
-
They said they were experiencing something weird:
-
all of a sudden, almost overnight,
-
the views on all four of their channels had cratered.
-
Was China Uncensored seeing the same thing?
-
Why yes, we were!
-
We compared notes and
realized this had happened
-
to all of our channels at the same time:
-
right around
the US presidential election in November.
-
So wait, the problem wasn’t me?
-
When YouTube
claimed we didn’t have enough engagement,
-
were they just gaslighting
us? That can’t be it, can it?
-
So we asked you. We posted a
survey in late December 2024,
-
and more than 6,000 of you responded.
-
And the results were shocking.
-
More than 1 in 4 of you said that YouTube
-
had secretly unsubscribed you
from our channel at least once.
-
More than 1 in 3 of you said YouTube
had secretly deleted your comments,
-
often multiple times.
-
There goes our engagement!
-
More than 1 in 5 of you who have
notifications turned on
-
said you are NEVER getting ANY notifications
for China Uncensored episodes.
-
Oh, but it gets worse!
-
Almost half of you told us
YouTube is “never” or “almost never”
-
recommending China Uncensored episodes for you—
-
even
though you’re subscribed to this channel.
-
Same goes for other channels
that criticize the CCP.
-
Serpentza and Laowhy86 did
their own viewer survey.
-
The vast majority of their respondents said
YouTube is “never” or only “occasionally”
-
recommending their videos
to their own subscribers.
-
Meanwhile more than a third of you said YouTube
-
is recommending Pro-CCP videos—
-
including Chinese state-run television as well as vloggers
-
in
China saying very positive things like
-
“Look at all the high speed rails,” and “There’s no
genocide happening here in beautiful Xinjiang!”
-
We also discovered when you search YouTube
for “China”...
-
China Uncensored is not in the search results.
-
But you’ll get tons
of positive videos about China.
-
Scroll down and you’ll see a lot of these channels
-
have fewer subscribers and views than China Uncensored.
-
..but to see our channel, you have
to scroll all the way down to position...95?!
-
This isn’t even a video!
It’s just our channel logo.
-
But YouTube would claim we just don’t
have as much “engagement”
-
as the other channels YouTube promotes
-
, like the one
with only 400,000 subscribers
-
that sings the praises of China’s high speed train in Wuhan.
-
Don’t question the algorithm!
-
We actually repeated this experiment many
times on different computers
-
using different incognito and private browsers.
-
In all of
these times, when we searched for China,
-
we only found a China Uncensored
video once.
-
It was video number…552.
-
We also noticed something
else odd.
-
In this search, we went back and counted the number of videos
-
that were positive versus negative about China.
-
In the first 100 videos, 65 were positive
about China.
-
More than half of those were travel vlogs
-
about how great Chinese cities
and high speed rail were.
-
Only 21 videos were negative about China.
-
Those were mostly
news reports about a new virus in China
-
and China hacking the US treasury.
-
Six videos were
neutral and 7 videos weren’t about China at all.
-
That means there were more than 3 times as many
positive videos about China as negative videos.
-
We then counted all 552 videos.
-
That was more
balanced.
-
But the majority of the videos were still positive about China.
-
And a lot of the more
critical videos were bunched up toward the end.
-
But let’s be real.
-
No one scrolls through more
than 500 videos.
-
What’s that, Shelley?
-
Ok, no one scrolls through more than 500 videos
other than Shelley
-
, who did this repeatedly.
-
Most people probably don’t scroll past 100 videos,
or even 50
-
. So it’s…interesting…that YouTube is
-
recommending so many positive videos about China
at the top,
-
and burying the negative videos.
-
We’re not the only ones who have noticed
a possible pro-CCP bias on YouTube.
-
Rutgers University’s Network Contagion Research
Institute just released a new study about TikTok.
-
Unsurprisingly, they found that TikTok
was brainwashing America’s youth.
-
In fact, it’s the first peer-reviewed
study to show that TikTok is actively
-
manipulating perceptions of China
and the CCP through algorithmic bias.
-
Ok, not that shocking, since TikTok
-
is owned
by a Chinese company with ties to the CCP.
-
But this peer-reviewed study also found evidence
of a possible pro-CCP bias within YouTube, too.
-
Part of the study looked at engagement,
-
which
is what YouTube says drives their algorithm.
-
The more you like and comment on videos,
the more they show up, right? Right??
-
Well, not according to this study.
-
They
found that YouTube showed slightly more
-
pro-CCP videos when they searched for terms
like “Xinjiang” and “Tiananmen Square.”
-
That’s despite the fact that the anti-CCP
videos had more than twice as many likes,
-
and more than three times as many
comments as the pro-CCP videos did.
-
So if engagement was the main
thing driving YouTube’s algorithm,
-
then the anti-CCP videos should have shown
up way more
-
. But they didn’t. Interesting.
-
So to recap: Two months ago, China Uncensored,
-
Laowhy86, and Serpentza, three of
the biggest anti-CCP YouTubers,
-
all experienced a mysterious, sudden and
huge drop in viewership at the same time.
-
A survey of China Uncensored viewers shows
YouTube has unsubscribed many of you,
-
deleted your comments, doesn’t
notify you of our videos,
-
doesn’t recommend anti-CCP videos to
you
-
but does recommend pro-CCP videos.
-
YouTube searches for “china” almost never
show China Uncensored videos
-
, but do show lots of positive China videos,
-
especially
at the beginning of the search results.
-
And a peer-reviewed study from Rutgers University
-
found evidence of a pro-CCP bias
in YouTube’s search algorithm.
-
Ok, it’s time to question the algorithm.
-
It looks like YouTube is up to something new.
-
They’re stepping back from simply deleting
-
people’s videos for being controversial.
-
Overt
censorship is too easy to track and measure.
-
This new thing is much worse, and
much more dangerous.
-
YouTube is quietly redirecting viewers away from
China Uncensored
-
and other channels critical of the CCP—
-
despite these viewers
demonstrating that they want this content,
-
by doing things like subscribing, leaving
comments, and turning on notifications.
-
What YouTube is doing is called “soft
censorship.”
-
Why would YouTube do this?
-
Well, I can only guess.
-
Perhaps it’s because YouTube’s parent company
-
Google has quietly started
working with China again.
-
Which is great. The Chinese Communist
Party literally considers itself at
-
war with the United States, and
Google just goes to work with them.
-
In 2017,
-
Google opened an AI research lab in China.
-
Does Google hope to get its search engine
unblocked in China?
-
Probably not. They just want access to user data from a billion
people,
-
without the pesky privacy restrictions you have in democracies.
-
How else can
they train their AIs, including Gemini?
-
But it turns out, there’s a
horrible horrible downside
-
to partnering with an evil regime bent on
controlling the minds of its own people.
-
VOA reported in 2024 that
-
Google’s Gemini parrots China’s propaganda.
-
For example, “Gemini said that the Chinese
Communist Party ‘represents the fundamental
-
interest of the Chinese people,’
-
a claim the CCP itself maintains.”
-
And “During VOA’s testing, Gemini had no
problem criticizing the United States.
-
But when similar questions were asked
about China
-
, Gemini refused to answer.”
-
So is Google’s leadership intentionally
suppressing YouTube channels
-
that criticize the CCP, so Google can maintain its
data operations in China
-
? Maybe.
-
Or it could just be malicious decisions
by a YouTube employee
-
who doesn’t like channels criticizing China’s Dear Leader.
-
Or that employee could be a Chinese agent.
-
Think I’m exaggerating?
-
I’m not. A Twitter whistleblower revealed
the company had a Chinese agent on payroll!
-
Twitter whistleblower says company
had Chinese agent on payroll
-
Another explanation might be that Google
-
has
spent seven years training its AI based on Chinese data
-
. And YouTube’s algorithm might
operate partly based on that AI training.
-
So after many years, YouTube’s AI starts to
act more like the Chinese Communist Party.
-
Whatever the cause, the result is
Americans are being fed pro-CCP narratives
-
at a time when China is
actively trying to destroy America.
-
We’re not going to take this lying down.
-
There are a bunch of things we’re
going to do to stand up to YouTube
-
over the coming weeks—like reaching out
to the media and the US government.
-
And it starts right now with you—that’s right, you.
-
If YouTube claims we “don’t have enough
engagement”,
-
let’s show ’em engagement!
-
Years ago, I started calling you, the
supporters of China Uncensored, my 50-Cent Army.
-
That was a tongue-in-cheek reference to the CCP’s 50-cent army
-
, the wumaos who comment
on China’s internet to praise the CCP.
-
Well, now I’m asking for help from you, my 50-Cent
Army.
-
This time, to troll the CCP. And YouTube.
-
I’m officially launching Operation Honey Pot.
-
NOT TO BE CONFUSED WITH OPERATION HONEY TRAP!
-
Here’s your mission, should
you choose to accept it:
-
I want every single one of you to like and
leave a comment on this video.
-
And I want you to include the honey pot emoji,
-
which is Xi
Jinping’s favorite, since he is a honey bear.
-
Leave any comment you like that includes that
emoji
-
. It can be simple, like “I honey pot China Uncensored
-
” or “Hostile foreign honey
pot.”
-
Better yet, come up with your own.
-
Just don’t write anything that would give
YouTube an excuse to delete your comment.
-
Don’t write anything “offensive” and don’t
leave more than one comment per person.
-
And don’t just like and comment on this video,
-
do it on all of our videos.
-
We publish
four videos a week, on Mondays, Wednesdays, Fridays, and Sundays.
-
If you don’t see
them in your feed, come find them.
-
In fact, go back and like and comment
on the videos
-
that we’ve published since November.
-
Don’t forget the honey pot.
-
The more people who like our videos and leave
comments,
-
the more engagement we get.
-
And one of two things will happen
-
: either you will directly
help our views dramatically go back up,
-
or our views won’t, and you will help us expose exactly
-
how YouTube is screwing with China Uncensored.
-
We’ll keep track of how many honey pots
-
show up in the comments.
-
If this goes the way
I think it will, this is only the beginning.
-
I’ve put the honey pot emoji in the
description so you can copy and paste it.
-
So like this video and leave your
honey pot comment below.
-
Do it now!
-
I’m Chris Chappell. Let’s fight that censorship!