-
- [David] Raiders, hello.
-
This video is about
analyzing visual evidence,
-
but let's cut right to it.
-
It's also about vampires.
-
(spooky music)
(thunder booming)
-
And we'll get to them,
-
those cape wearing, widows peaked wonders
-
of the mountains of Transylvania.
-
But first, what do we even
mean by visual evidence?
-
Like textual evidence, sure,
-
we know what textual evidence is.
-
It's written language.
-
How do we know there's
potassium hydroxide in my soap?
-
It's on the label.
-
Ah, but how much potassium hydroxide?
-
Visual evidence can tell us.
-
Visual evidence includes the
graphs, charts, tables, images,
-
and illustrations that
authors use in their texts.
-
Authors include visual evidence
-
to help readers better understand ideas
-
because sometimes words just don't cut it.
-
Visual evidence can help
strengthen a written argument
-
and help express complicated ideas.
-
So KOH, the potassium hydroxide,
-
makes up 13.4% by weight of the soap.
-
And sure it could list that
percentage on the label,
-
but to my eye, seeing the number
-
and the pie chart is more helpful.
-
I can see at a glance
-
that potassium hydroxide,
labeled here in red,
-
only makes up a small part of my soap.
-
This is useful because if
there were a lot more KOH
-
than there already is,
-
the soap would burn my
skin when I used it.
-
Soap chemistry, visual evidence at work.
-
Oftentimes, you will be asked
to evaluate visual evidence
-
to see whether it supports
-
or challenges an argument in a text.
-
This is something you'll
have to do in many classes,
-
history and science
classes as well as English.
-
And questions about this
particular skill are common
-
on standardized exams.
-
So this brings us to vampires
-
and specifically a very
complicated idea about vampires
-
that some Norwegian researchers
wanted to test in 1994.
-
Does garlic scare vampires away?
-
This is a real study.
-
They said something like,
according to folklore,
-
garlic repels vampires.
-
We wished to verify this,
-
but owing to the lack of
vampires, we used leeches instead.
-
Leeches, the real life
blood sucking worms.
-
So like vampires, kinda.
-
Based on the data,
-
does garlic actually keep vampires away?
-
Remembering that leches here
are our stand-ins for vampires.
-
In a research setting,
the leches were presented
-
with a hand smeared with garlic
-
and a clean hand with the expectation
-
that they would attach
themselves to one or the other.
-
From our data, we conclude
that the relationship
-
between vampires and garlic is blank.
-
So here's the graph.
-
What conclusions can you make
-
about the traditional relationship
-
between garlic and vampires?
-
What does this graph say happens?
-
What does the visual evidence tell you?
-
I'm going to put a little music on.
-
Feel free to pause the video and discuss
-
or make your own guesses.
-
Alright, see you in a bit.
-
(soft music)
-
So the title of this graph is:
-
How Long Do Leeches Take to
Attach Themselves to a Hand?
-
Right, and we have two bars
on the horizontal axis,
-
the X axis.
-
One is with garlic, the
other is without garlic.
-
And over here on the Y
axis, the vertical axis,
-
we can see that the legend reads seconds.
-
That's how many seconds
the leches took to attach.
-
This graph is potentially confusing
-
because it might seem
-
like the bigger bar is
the better one, right?
-
But this is response time,
-
how long do they take?
-
So 14.9 seconds over here
versus 44.9 seconds over here.
-
The shorter the response time,
-
the faster the leach latches on.
-
What can we conclude from
this study therefore,
-
what was the main conclusion of the study?
-
Well, basically the leeches went
-
for the garlic covered hand,
the seasoned hand much faster,
-
30 seconds faster on
average than they went
-
for the unseasoned hand.
-
That means they like
the garlicky hand more
-
than the ungarlicky hand.
-
And remember, tradition holds
-
that garlic repels vampires,
it sends them away.
-
So from the result of this
study, we can conclude
-
that their tradition is wrong
and vampires love garlic,
-
if vampires and leeches are the same.
-
Yeah, it's a bit of a leap.
-
Maybe this particular case feels silly.
-
Fine, but this is a useful skill.
-
You will be asked to
evaluate visual evidence
-
to see whether it supports
-
or challenges an argument in a text.
-
A friend will send you an infographic
-
about a political topic.
-
You might look up stats
for your favorite athlete.
-
You might have to puzzle
through a misleading graph
-
on TV news.
-
Understanding what data is trying
-
to tell us is a core reading skill.
-
Information, now it's got
numbers in it, trademark.
-
And now you've got numbers in you.
-
Nice work.
-
Watch out for leeches.
You can learn anything.
-
David out.